{"manifest":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","answerVersion":"0.3.0","files":["questions.json","philosophers.json","routes.json","sources.json","traditions.json","tension_rules.json","result_rules.json","learning.json"],"counts":{"questions":203,"philosophers":90,"traditions":15},"policy":{"core":"局部思想比较，不是心理测量","externalRequests":"运行时不需要联网服务；资料链接由用户主动打开","historicalMapping":"出处支持人物观点，人物对原创选项的对应为编辑解释","percentages":"关键问题比较充分后，按实际回答的加权一致程度计算契合度；核心观点权重2，交叉比较权重1，保留加一平滑；未答、跳过和对应不明确的回答不计为支持或分歧","privacy":"不上传回答；信仰、伦理等回答只保存在本机时也允许一键清除"},"compatibleAnswerVersions":["0.4.0","0.4.1","0.4.2","0.4.3","0.4.4"],"updatedQuestionIds":["T20","T39","T48","T66","T67","T75","T85","T97","T100","T102","T103","T105","T120","T121","T122","T123","T129","T108","T19","T25","T29","T71","T78","T89","T110","T111","T112","T113","T118","T124","T125","T128","T131","Q11"],"questionUpdatesByVersion":{"0.3.0":["T20","T39","T48","T66","T67","T75","T85","T97","T100","T102","T103","T105","T120","T121","T122","T123","T129","T108","T19","T25","T29","T71","T78","T89","T110","T111","T112","T113","T118","T124","T125","T128","T131","Q11"],"0.4.0":["T20","T39","T48","T66","T67","T75","T85","T97","T100","T102","T103","T105","T120","T121","T122","T123","T129","T108","T19","T25","T29","T71","T78","T89","T110","T111","T112","T113","T118","T124","T125","T128","T131","Q11"],"0.4.1":["T19","T25","T29","T71","T78","T89","T110","T111","T112","T113","T118","T122","T124","T125","T128","T131","Q11"],"0.4.2":["Q11"],"0.4.3":[],"0.4.4":[]}},"questions":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","status":"demo_editorial_release","locale":"zh-CN","instructions":"选最接近你此刻想法的一项；几项都有道理时，选你最看重的理由。","skipOptions":[{"id":"unsure","text":"还没想好"},{"id":"none","text":"都不太像我的想法"}],"skipPolicy":"两个跳过选项都不产生立场证据；分别记录以便改善题目。","topics":{"L":"生活与意义","E":"道德与理由","S":"自我与关系","F":"自由与责任","K":"知识与证据","C":"公平与共同生活","M":"意识与心灵","W":"世界与存在","V":"科学与解释","G":"语言与理解","A":"美与艺术","P":"修养与行动","R":"信仰与终极问题","H":"历史与社会"},"baseOrder":["FP01","W01","Q09","Q11","V03","FP02","H01","FP03","C01","FP04","Q02","Q08","Q04","Q10","Q07","A01","FP05"],"questions":[{"id":"Q01","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"L","title":"如果幸福是假的","prompt":"有台机器能让你在美梦里幸福地过一辈子。进去后出不来，也不会发现这是梦。假设家人都已安顿好，你愿意进去吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"愿意，只要真的感到幸福就够了。","evidenceId":"Q01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不愿意，我希望那些事真的发生过。","evidenceId":"Q01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不愿意，我想亲自做点事，改变现实。","evidenceId":"Q01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"生活路线。B 与 C 都是拒绝，但理由不同；不能把拒绝一概归为某种主义。本题只提供“体验是否足够”的线索。可展开补充一句“假设你的离开不会让别人陷入困境”，避免整题变成照顾家人的责任选择。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","nozick_experience"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Experience machine","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q02","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"E","title":"善意的谎言","prompt":"说一句小谎，就能让朋友少受一次伤害，也没有其他坏处。你觉得该说吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"不该说，结果好，也不能成为说谎的理由。","evidenceId":"Q02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"要让朋友自己决定，不能替他认定真相不重要。","evidenceId":"Q02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"该说，让朋友少受伤更重要。","evidenceId":"Q02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"道德路线。A 是这个情境下接受例外，不等于接受所有后果主义。B 不能直接对应康德。C 记录知情与自主的理由，不视为中立。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q03","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"S","title":"失忆后，还是同一个人吗","prompt":"一个人失去了所有记忆，性格和想法也全变了。你还会把他看作原来的那个人吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"对亲近的人来说还是原来的人，因为一起经历过的事并没有消失。","evidenceId":"Q03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会，身体还是他的，人也一直活着。","evidenceId":"Q03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不会，他原来的记忆、性格和想法都没了。","evidenceId":"Q03.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"自我路线。这里讨论“作为一个人怎样延续”，不判断法律身份或现实疾病。C 只能提供关系与经历的线索，不能直接认定儒家立场。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","locke_personal_identity"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Personal identity","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q04","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"F","title":"自己愿意，就算自由吗","prompt":"假设你的经历、性格和当时的状态，已经决定了你只能这么选。这还算自由选择吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"算，是我自己愿意的，又没人逼我。","evidenceId":"Q04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不算，能选别的，才叫自由。","evidenceId":"Q04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我在意的是，这个选择经过认真考虑，还是只凭一时冲动。","evidenceId":"Q04.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"自由路线。问的是在假设条件下如何理解自由，不是在询问用户是否相信世界实际上被决定。A 与 C 可兼容，选项表达用户最看重的理由，不当作互斥学派。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p29","philpapers2020","source_p25","source_p35"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Free will","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q05","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"K","title":"预测很准，就说明它对吗","prompt":"一个科学理论能解释许多现象，预测也一直很准。你会怎么想？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"我只把它当作好用的工具，暂且不管现实到底怎样。","evidenceId":"Q05.B"},{"id":"C","text":"另一个解释也可能预测得很准，仅凭预测成功还很难确定。","evidenceId":"Q05.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它应该说中了现实中的一些规律。","evidenceId":"Q05.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"认识路线。C 不是无知跳题，而是对理论选择的明确保留。不能据此直接判定全面反实在论。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p12","philpapers2020","source_p57","source_p58"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Science","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q06","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"C","title":"一样努力，收入却差很多","prompt":"两个人一样努力，生活却相差很大。判断这公不公平，你最在意什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"过得差的那个人，基本生活有没有保障。","evidenceId":"Q06.C"},{"id":"A","text":"规则是否相同，有没有人作弊或占别人便宜。","evidenceId":"Q06.A"},{"id":"B","text":"他们一开始得到的机会，是不是差得太远。","evidenceId":"Q06.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"共同生活路线。三个方面可以同时被认可，此题只记录优先关注点，不直接推出政治身份。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q07","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"L","title":"人一定要有活着的目的吗","prompt":"假如人这一辈子并没有什么老天爷提前安排好的使命，你会怎么想？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"我在乎的人、愿意做的事，就能让生活有意义。","evidenceId":"Q07.A"},{"id":"B","text":"有些事本来就值得做，不是我喜欢才有意义。","evidenceId":"Q07.B"},{"id":"C","text":"想不出最终答案也没关系，日子还是值得过。","evidenceId":"Q07.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"生活路线。题目是假设，不推断用户的宗教信仰。A 与 C 不一定冲突；只有后续回答足够时才进一步区分。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p06","source_p63","source_p85","source_p05","source_p08","source_p47"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q08","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"E","title":"大家都赞同，就一定对吗","prompt":"如果所有人都赞同一件事，它还有可能是不道德的吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"如果受影响的人都知情、自愿接受，我觉得就没错。","evidenceId":"Q08.B"},{"id":"C","text":"有可能，比如大家是被骗了，或者不敢反对。","evidenceId":"Q08.C"},{"id":"A","text":"有可能。对错有它本身的客观标准，哪怕全世界都赞成，错的依然是错的。","evidenceId":"Q08.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"道德路线。这里的“对错”指道德判断。B/C 对题干提出了条件，应保存条件，不将其强压成同一轴上的分数。A 也可能来自对共识过程的担心，不能单题确认道德实在论。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Meta-ethics","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q09","revision":4,"stage":"base","topic":"M","title":"知道大脑在做什么，就懂疼痛了吗","prompt":"假如我们查清了人感到疼痛时，大脑里发生的全部变化。这就把疼痛解释清楚了吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"还没有，疼痛也是整个身体在具体处境中的体验，不能只看脑内变化。","evidenceId":"Q09.C"},{"id":"A","text":"解释清楚了，我们已经知道疼痛是怎样产生的。","evidenceId":"Q09.A"},{"id":"B","text":"还没有，知道大脑怎样变化，也没有说明为什么会有疼痛的感觉。","evidenceId":"Q09.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"自我路线中的意识入口。B 不自动等于二元论，C 不自动否认物理解释。主界面不展示“还原”“感质”等术语。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p59","source_p64","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Mind","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q10","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"F","title":"如果时间倒回去","prompt":"时间倒回你做选择的前一刻。所有经历、想法、外部条件和自然规律都没变。你还可能选别的吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不可能，一切都一样，结果也会一样。","evidenceId":"Q10.A"},{"id":"B","text":"可能，即使一切都一样，我也能选另一条路。","evidenceId":"Q10.B"},{"id":"C","text":"可能，但那也许只是随机变化，算不上我主动选择。","evidenceId":"Q10.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"自由路线。B/C 都容许不同结果，但对选择与随机性的理解不同；不能合并。与 Q04 分别处理“世界如何运行”和“什么算自由”。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p25","philpapers2020","source_p19"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Free will","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q11","revision":4,"stage":"base","topic":"K","title":"只靠想，能想出真相吗","prompt":"有人认为，有些关于世界的道理，即使从没观察或实验过，也能靠严密推理知道。你更接近哪种想法？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"光靠想不行。要摸清现实世界究竟是什么样，归根结底都得靠观察和实际经验。","evidenceId":"Q11.B"},{"id":"C","text":"得看是什么问题。有些事靠严密推理就能定下来，有些事非得靠观察和经验，没法一刀切。","evidenceId":"Q11.C"},{"id":"A","text":"确实可以。有些关于世界的根本道理，就算不做实验，单靠理性的严密推演也能想通。","evidenceId":"Q11.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"A 明确接受关于现实的先验知识；B 将经验视为认识现实的最终根据；C 表达按问题选择认识方法的偏好，不直接等同于康德哲学。选项取最接近的理由，不能当作互斥且穷尽的知识论分类。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p17","source_p22","source_p23","source_p26","source_p27","source_p29","source_p54","philpapers2020","source_p06","source_p13","source_p15","source_p16","source_p20","source_p25","source_p45","source_p46","source_p48","source_p50","source_p53","source_p55","source_p59","source_p03"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"A priori knowledge","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"Q12","revision":4,"stage":"followup","topic":"C","title":"朋友和陌生人，你先帮谁","prompt":"朋友和陌生人遇到同样的困难，你打算用自己的钱帮助他们，但钱只够帮一个。你会怎么选？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我会帮朋友，因为我更了解他的情况，知道怎样帮才有效。","evidenceId":"Q12.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我会帮朋友，因为我们之间有一份特别的责任。","evidenceId":"Q12.A"},{"id":"B","text":"关系远近不该成为偏心的理由；既然两边急难程度完全一样，哪怕抽签决定也比直接偏袒熟人更公平。","evidenceId":"Q12.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"限定私人援助，移走原来明显更周全的公私区分答案。A 是特殊责任，C 是信息和效果理由；都不能直接推出公共分配立场。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p77","source_p66"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"L01","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"L","title":"不快乐，还值得做吗","prompt":"有件事要熬很多年，过程很苦，做成了也不会让你更开心。你还会去干吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"会。有些事哪怕让人受罪，它本身的价值也值得我去扛。","evidenceId":"L01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"算了吧，如果连最起码的开心和踏实都换不来，何必一直折磨自己。","evidenceId":"L01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"会，只要这条路是我自己选的，再苦我也认。","evidenceId":"L01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p43","source_p42","source_p63"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"L02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"L","title":"什么事才算没白忙活","prompt":"回想那些让你觉得“没白干”的事，通常是因为什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"这件事本身就该有人做，哪怕没人夸、甚至没人喜欢。","evidenceId":"L02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这是我自己认准的路，我心甘情愿把时间和心血砸在上面。","evidenceId":"L02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它让我活得更痛快、更踏实，或者少受了罪。","evidenceId":"L02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"区分体验价值、价值独立性与个人承诺。提供进一步了解伊壁鸠鲁、亚里士多德、存在思想等方向的线索；人物比较仍待补足依据。不能按一项答案直接发人物卡。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p06","source_p09","source_p61","source_p07","source_p10","source_p18","source_p34"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"E01","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"E","title":"答应保密，还能说出去吗","prompt":"你答应帮朋友保密，后来发现说出来能帮别人避免一笔损失。你会怎么想？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这秘密见不见得光、对方是不是本来就有权知情，我都得考虑。","evidenceId":"E01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"应该说，帮人避免损失更重要。","evidenceId":"E01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"答应了就有责任守住，不能只因结果更好就反悔。","evidenceId":"E01.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"E02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"E","title":"你说“不该做”，是什么意思","prompt":"当你斩钉截铁地说一件坏事“绝对不该做”时，你心里真正指的是什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"哪怕所有人都爱干，这件事本身在客观上也是错的。","evidenceId":"E02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我是在表达对害人行为的强烈反感，也希望借这句话唤起大家心里的那份不忍。","evidenceId":"E02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这种做法破坏了大家平起平坐、彼此都能接受的相处规矩。","evidenceId":"E02.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"将情境选择与评价根据分开。A/B/C 是入口，不是完整的实在论、表达主义、建构主义定义；暂不对这些理论建立排他的父子分类。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"S01","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"S","title":"出现了一个复制版的你","prompt":"一个复制人出现了，记忆和性格与你完全相同。而你就站在旁边。你怎么看他？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"某种意义上，他也是我。我的记忆和性格延续到了他身上。","evidenceId":"S01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更在意记忆和计划有没有延续，至于他算不算我，倒不那么重要。","evidenceId":"S01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"他不是我，我一直活在自己的身体里。","evidenceId":"S01.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"S02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"S","title":"从没和人交流，能了解自己吗","prompt":"一个人从小没和任何人交流过。他能知道“我是怎样的人”吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"能，但这种认识会和我们很不一样。","evidenceId":"S02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"能了解一些，他能从自己的感受和行动中认识自己。","evidenceId":"S02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"很难，认识自己，需要和别人说话、相处。","evidenceId":"S02.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"Q03 进入此路线更自然。Q09 主要提供意识议题入口；如果用户只对 Q09 有明确回答，不强行用 S01/S02 补出意识结论，可直接在结果后推荐意识专题。关系性回答不自动等于儒家，无固定自我也不自动等于佛教。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"F01","revision":4,"stage":"followup","topic":"F","title":"选择早有原因，还该负责吗","prompt":"一个人没人逼他，自己动手做了坏事。但如果顺着他的成长经历、性格和当时的处境推下来，他那一刻其实注定只会这么做——你还觉得他该担责吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"该担责。没人逼他，这就是他顺着自己心意干出来的事。","evidenceId":"F01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"谈不上“罪有应得”，但为了保护别人，还是得拦住他、帮他改过来。","evidenceId":"F01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"关键看他当时能不能听明白理由、看清后果，并据此调整自己的行动；要是能，就得担责。","evidenceId":"F01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"F02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"F","title":"怎样才算自己选的","prompt":"说一件事是“我自己选的”，你最看重什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"我能想想自己为什么想要，也能改变主意。","evidenceId":"F02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"就算过去和当时的条件都一样，我仍能选别的。","evidenceId":"F02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"是我真心想做的，不是被迫的。","evidenceId":"F02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"可以形成相容论等立场入口；A/B 有重叠，记录用户强调的理由。F01-B 不能被写成反对一切法律责任，也不将一般谅解等同自由意志怀疑主义。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p35","source_p19"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"K01","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"K","title":"看了同样的证据，还能各有道理吗","prompt":"两个人看了同样的证据，也都认真想过，却得出不同结论。他们能不能都算有道理？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我还拿不准，得弄清他们理解的词和假设是否相同。","evidenceId":"K01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"能，同样的证据，有时可以有不同的合理解释。","evidenceId":"K01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"如果问题清楚、证据足够，他们应该能慢慢达成一致。","evidenceId":"K01.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"K02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"K","title":"什么会让你改主意","prompt":"你相信一个解释。下面哪件事，最会让你重新想想？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"一再看到它解释不了的事情。","evidenceId":"K02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"发现它一开始的假设，或推理过程有问题。","evidenceId":"K02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"另一个解释说清了更多事情，留下的疑问也更少。","evidenceId":"K02.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"方法偏好可能同时存在，不从中评“谁更理性”。K02 主要提供后续探索方向，不单独区分波普尔、奎因或杜威。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p22","source_p46"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"C01","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"C","title":"有人生来就更有钱","prompt":"一个人继承了很多家产，另一个人什么也没继承。双方都没做错事，社会还需要缩小这种差距吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"需要让机会更公平，不能让出身决定一切。","evidenceId":"C01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"保障每个人的基本生活最重要，进一步的财富差距可以在此基础上讨论。","evidenceId":"C01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"通常应该尊重继承，只要财产的取得和转移都正当。","evidenceId":"C01.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p75","source_p76","source_p33"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"C02","revision":3,"stage":"followup","topic":"C","title":"多数人同意，少数人就得接受吗","prompt":"一项规定得到多数人支持，却让少数人的生活受到很大限制。你最想了解什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这个限制真的有必要吗？带来的好处值得吗？","evidenceId":"C02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它有没有侵犯人人都应该享有的权利？","evidenceId":"C02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"有没有认真听少数人的意见，让他们平等参与？","evidenceId":"C02.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"权利、参与和公共后果可以共存，不直接贴整套政治身份。结合具体条件才能进一步比较罗尔斯、诺齐克、密尔、哈贝马斯等人物。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p71","source_p75","source_p76","source_p67"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"D01","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"愿望也可能被安排","prompt":"如果有人悄悄改变了你的愿望，而你此后一直心甘情愿照着它行动，这些选择算自由吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"仍可能算自由。不管这念头当初是怎么来的，只要我现在真正理解并认准它、愿意照着做，就还是可以算作我自己的选择。","evidenceId":"D01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"算不上真自由。如果连我“想要什么”都是别人偷偷塞进脑子里的，我哪算自己做主？","evidenceId":"D01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"得看我有没有机会察觉这些愿望是怎么来的，并且能不能重新考量、改变它们。","evidenceId":"D01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p70","source_p72"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"D02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"能听明白理由，重要吗","prompt":"一个人闯了祸、做了错事。在衡量他到底该担多大责任时，你最看重哪一点？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"看他动手时清不清楚自己在干什么、明不明白会惹出什么后果。","evidenceId":"D02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"看接下来怎么处置最能防止再出事，至于他算不算“活该受罚”倒在其次。","evidenceId":"D02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"看他当时能不能听明白理由，并且有能力照着这些理由调整自己的行为。","evidenceId":"D02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"D03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"随机，会让人更自由吗","prompt":"假如你在做决定的一瞬间，脑子里像掷骰子一样多了一点纯粹的随机变化。这会让你变得更自由吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"光有随机变化还不够，还得说清楚“我”是怎么拍板作决定的。","evidenceId":"D03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不会。靠碰运气蹦出来的结果，同样不是我自己做主掌握的。","evidenceId":"D03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"可能会更自由一点——因为未来不再是早就写死、毫无变数的了。","evidenceId":"D03.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"D04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"惩罚为了什么","prompt":"如果一个人已经确定不会再伤害别人，你认为惩罚还可能有什么理由？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"哪怕他以后再也不犯了，做过的恶也得拿惩罚来抵，这是公道本身的要求。","evidenceId":"D04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"如果惩罚既不能保护别人、弥补伤害，也起不到其他作用，我反对单纯为了让他受苦而罚他。","evidenceId":"D04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"还得看怎么能真正补偿受害者，同时向所有人亮明底线：这种事绝不可接受。","evidenceId":"D04.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"选项记录本题中的理由偏好，不能单题确认人物或整套学说。","sourceStatus":"体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"M01","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"会喊疼的机器","prompt":"一个机器人被碰坏时会喊疼、躲开，还会记住是谁伤害了它。你会认为它真的疼吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"这些表现还不够，它也可能只是照程序作出反应。","evidenceId":"M01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我倾向于认为不会，真正的感受离不开活生生的身体。","evidenceId":"M01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"如果它内部处理警报、调整行为的运作机制跟人脑起到的作用一样，我倾向于认为它真的会疼。","evidenceId":"M01.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"区分功能线索、证据保留和生物条件；B 不是断言机器永远无感受。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Other minds","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"M02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"知道颜色，还没见过","prompt":"一个人从出生就只看得到黑白，却学会了关于颜色和视觉的全部科学知识。第一次看到红色时，她会知道新东西吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"她会获得辨认和想象红色的能力，这和知道新事实不一样。","evidenceId":"M02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会，亲自见到是什么感觉，书本知识给不了。","evidenceId":"M02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不会多出新的事实，只是第一次用另一种方式认识它。","evidenceId":"M02.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"假想前提，不考现实医学；A 不自动反物理主义。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","source_p59"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Consciousness","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"M03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"手机算不算记忆的一部分","prompt":"你每天依靠手机里的记录安排生活，没有它就想不起许多事。手机算不算你的记忆的一部分？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"算，它已经在日常生活里承担了记忆的工作。","evidenceId":"M03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不算，它保存信息，但记忆仍然发生在我身上。","evidenceId":"M03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"记忆更像是我和工具共同完成的，归在任何一边都不太合适。","evidenceId":"M03.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"区分扩展、内部边界与分布式描述，C 与 A 可重叠。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Extended mind","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"M04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"身体换了，感受会变吗","prompt":"如果保留你的大脑，却换上完全不同的身体，你看待世界的方式会怎样？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"核心想法会保留，变化主要是适应新身体。","evidenceId":"M04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"新的感官输入最重要；输入一样，体验就应该接近。","evidenceId":"M04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会明显改变，身体能做什么，会影响我怎样感受和理解周围的事物。","evidenceId":"M04.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"身体、脑内连续性、感官输入三种关注点，不能单题判流派。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"W01","revision":2,"stage":"base","topic":"W","title":"没有人看见的山","prompt":"假设从来没有任何有意识的生命，一座山还会存在吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"组成山的东西会在，但“这是一座山”的划分来自我们。","evidenceId":"W01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会，山的存在和有没有人看见它是两回事。","evidenceId":"W01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不能这样断定。如果完全不可能感知或经历它，“存在”是什么意思就说不清了。","evidenceId":"W01.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"B 是可理解性保留，不直接等同贝克莱；C 可与 A 相容。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p51","philpapers2020","source_p04","source_p26","source_p28","source_p55"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"External world","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"W02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"数是被发现的吗","prompt":"在任何人开始数数以前，“二加二等于四”就已经成立了吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"成立，人发现了这个关系，并没有创造它。","evidenceId":"W02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"是人建立了数和运算的规则，再得出了这个结论。","evidenceId":"W02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这套规则能成立，离不开我们反复接触和整理现实事物。","evidenceId":"W02.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"分别提供发现、约定、经验形成线索；不单题判数学本体论。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p50","philpapers2020","source_p51","source_p53","source_p54"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Abstract objects","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"W03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"换完零件，还是它吗","prompt":"一艘船的零件逐年更换，最后一个原件也没剩下。它还是原来那艘船吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"严格说不是，原来的材料已经全换掉了。","evidenceId":"W03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"“同一艘船”可以有不同的认定标准，取决于我们用这个名字指什么。","evidenceId":"W03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"是，它一直被使用和维修，没有中断。","evidenceId":"W03.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"物体同一性，不直接推个人同一性。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p02","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Material composition","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"W04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"所有事都需要解释吗","prompt":"解释一件事时，我们可以一直追问“那又是为什么”。你认为最终会怎样？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"未必有最后一层，解释可以一直继续。","evidenceId":"W04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"应该有一个根本理由，让其他事情得到解释。","evidenceId":"W04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"总会遇到一些就是如此、没有更深理由的事实。","evidenceId":"W04.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"提供解释终点偏好，不从 A 推出有神论。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p16","philpapers2020","source_p13","source_p14","source_p15","source_p27","source_p88"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Principle of sufficient reason","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"V01","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"一次反例，理论就倒了吗","prompt":"一套向来很准的科学理论，突然撞上了一个确凿的实验结果，跟它预测的完全相反。这时候你会怎么想？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"说明这套理论本身多半有漏洞，得设计新的实验来检验，把不同的解释区分开。","evidenceId":"V01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我更怀疑是测量仪器、环境干扰或某条辅助假设出了岔子，成熟的理论值得多核查几次。","evidenceId":"V01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"把新旧理论摆在一起比较，看看有没有解释力更强、能接班的新方案。","evidenceId":"V01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"三种研究取向可以并用；避免“一次失败必然推翻”误写。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p54","source_p57","source_p58","source_p46"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"V02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"电子真的存在吗","prompt":"我们不能像看石头一样直接看见电子，但关于电子的理论非常成功。你倾向怎样理解它？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"只要“电子”这个概念能帮我们把实验数据串起来、算准结果就够了，不必纠结它是不是真有个小颗粒在那儿。","evidenceId":"V02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我相信理论抓住了微观世界的一些真实规律，但“电子”本身长什么样，未必跟今天理论画出来的完全一致。","evidenceId":"V02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"既然靠这套理论能造出芯片、算准实验，那电子多半是真实存在的，理论确实说中了它的运作方式。","evidenceId":"V02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"科学实在、工具使用、关系保留的初步入口。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"V03","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"V","title":"太阳明天还会升起吗","prompt":"太阳过去每天都升起。你怎么看“明天也会升起”这件事？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"就算没法彻底证明，我们过日子也离不开这种期待。","evidenceId":"V03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我有充分理由相信，也承认仍有出错的可能。","evidenceId":"V03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"自然规律给了我们稳定的依据，不只是习惯性地猜。","evidenceId":"V03.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"三种理由可相容，不把 C 当非理性。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"V04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"难道什么都能解释","prompt":"一种说法把任何结果都解释成自己正确：成功算支持，失败也算支持。你怎么看？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"如果没有任何结果能让它出错，我不把它当作科学解释。","evidenceId":"V04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"它也许有理解生活的价值，但不能靠这些结果证明自己。","evidenceId":"V04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我会考虑它能否带来新的发现，不能只凭一次观察能否否定它来判断。","evidenceId":"V04.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"科学边界与解释价值分开；不是全套科学哲学分类。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"G01","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"话的意思在哪里","prompt":"朋友说“你可真准时”，但你其实迟到了。这句话是什么意思，主要由什么决定？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"当时的场景，以及我们共同懂得的说话方式。","evidenceId":"G01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"主要由词句本身决定；讽刺是在字面意思之外多传达的一层。","evidenceId":"G01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"他说这句话时想表达的意思。","evidenceId":"G01.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"意图、使用场景、字面与传达区分；均非唯一完整解释。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p52","source_p65"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"G02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"没名字，就想不到吗","prompt":"一种语言没有单独表示某种情绪的词，说这种语言的人还能清楚认识那种情绪吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"得看能否通过描述和交流把它说清，不一定需要单独一个词。","evidenceId":"G02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"能，体验和想法也可能出现在有名字之前。","evidenceId":"G02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"会更难，因为没有词，细微的区别更容易被忽略。","evidenceId":"G02.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"C 是表达策略，不是自动高于 A/B 的答案。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"G03","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"作者不在了，谁说了算","prompt":"你从一部小说中读出了作者从未想到的含义。这个理解可以成立吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"可以，只要作品本身能支持这种读法。","evidenceId":"G03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"作者的意图仍是重要边界，不能完全不管他原本想说什么。","evidenceId":"G03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"可以，读者带着自己的时代和经历去读，作品的含义也会超出作者原来的设想。","evidenceId":"G03.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"文本证据、作者意图、读者处境，承认相容和程度差异。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p65","source_p73"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"G04","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"说了就改变现实","prompt":"你在场边听见裁判说“我宣布比赛开始”。观众说同一句话，比赛却不会因此开始。你认为，这句话为什么能改变比赛的状态？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"关键在于现场的人是否真的接受并照着行动。","evidenceId":"G04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"句子的意思相同，不同的是说话者能造成的后果。","evidenceId":"G04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"社会规则给了裁判这句话实际的效力。","evidenceId":"G04.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"制度条件、共同承认、意义后果区分；无单题人物归属。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"A01","revision":2,"stage":"base","topic":"A","title":"大家喜欢，就算好吗","prompt":"一首歌几乎人人喜欢，但你觉得不好听。它的艺术价值主要由什么决定？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"得看它在当时的文化里，带来了怎样的表达或创新。","evidenceId":"A01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"喜欢它的体验就很重要，统一的评价标准对我没有那么重要。","evidenceId":"A01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"作品本身的结构和表达，值得超出个人喜好来讨论。","evidenceId":"A01.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"偏好、作品理由、历史语境入口；不做高低品味评分。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Aesthetic value","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"A02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"原作和完美复制品","prompt":"一幅画有了肉眼完全分不出的复制品。只谈艺术价值，你认为两者一样吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"一样，可感受到的形式和效果没有区别。","evidenceId":"A02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不一样，原作的创作经历，也是它的一部分。","evidenceId":"A02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不一样，原作在艺术发展中做过的贡献，不会因为复制就再发生一次。","evidenceId":"A02.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"B/C 重叠但分别强调创作事件与历史位置；不涉及市场估价。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"A03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"作者很坏，作品还好吗","prompt":"得知喜欢的作品出自一个品行恶劣的人，你会怎样重新看它的艺术价值？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"会受到影响，作品表达什么与作者的行为可能有关。","evidenceId":"A03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"如果那些问题进入了作品，作品的价值就会受影响；不能只凭作者身份下结论。","evidenceId":"A03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"作品仍可以很好，作者的人品不直接决定它。","evidenceId":"A03.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"本题包含条件答案但不总放在同一位置；不评价观众道德水平。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"A04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"一块石头进了美术馆","prompt":"一块普通石头被艺术家选中并展出。什么最可能让它成为艺术？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"仅仅选中并展出还不够，我更期待可辨认的创造或表达。","evidenceId":"A04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它让人以新的方式感受和理解原本普通的东西。","evidenceId":"A04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"创作意图和艺术活动的背景，改变了它的身份。","evidenceId":"A04.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"不是艺术知识考核；不将 C 写成保守落后。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"P01","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"知道却一直不做","prompt":"一个人讲得清为什么该诚实，却总在方便时撒谎。你会说他真的知道应该诚实吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"知道，但他没有做到；认识和行动会脱节。","evidenceId":"P01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"还算不上真正知道，因为深刻的认识会在行动中表现出来。","evidenceId":"P01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"知道理由还不够，他缺少让自己做得到的习惯。","evidenceId":"P01.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"认识与行动、实践性理解、习惯三种线索，不能单题贴王阳明。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p05","source_p06","source_p07","source_p77","source_p79","source_p85","source_p86","source_p90"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"P02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"善良要练习吗","prompt":"让一个孩子逐渐懂得体谅别人，你最看重什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"通过规矩和练习，慢慢形成可靠的习惯。","evidenceId":"P02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"让他经历具体关系，学会理解别人为什么难受。","evidenceId":"P02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"保护和引导他本来就有的同情心。","evidenceId":"P02.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"倾向不同教育理由，不从 A/B 直接判孟子荀子。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p77","source_p78","source_p79","source_p07","source_p33","source_p85"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"P03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"越努力越别扭","prompt":"一件本来熟练的事，你越盯着每一步控制，反而越做不好。你倾向怎么调整？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这样勉强自己，让我怀疑这个目标到底值不值得。","evidenceId":"P03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"放松刻意控制，让练出来的熟练自然发挥。","evidenceId":"P03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"找到出错的步骤，继续拆开练到稳定。","evidenceId":"P03.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"自然熟练、训练、目标反省，不把放松等同完整道家学说。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p82","source_p81","source_p84","source_p90"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"P04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"一直惦记别人的评价","prompt":"别人的一句评价总让你烦恼。哪种想法更能让你放下？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"分清我能掌握的行动，和无法掌握的评价。","evidenceId":"P04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"想想自己是否太执着于“我应该是怎样的人”，所以难以接受别人的评价。","evidenceId":"P04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"把注意力放回值得经营的关系，不让一句话替所有人下结论。","evidenceId":"P04.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"提供实践入口，不是心理治疗建议或佛教归属判断。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p10","source_p11","source_p87","source_p08","source_p38"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"R01","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"一定要有第一步吗","prompt":"有人说：“世界上每件事都有原因，所以世界一定有最初的原因。”你更接近哪种反应？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"每件事各有原因。可为什么整个世界也要有同样的原因？这一点我不太信服。","evidenceId":"R01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"也可能没有最初一步，因果一直延续。","evidenceId":"R01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"有吸引力，我也想找到不再依赖别的东西的根源。","evidenceId":"R01.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"B 是论证保留，不等于无神论；A 不直接等于任何宗教。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"R02","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"信任需要多少证据","prompt":"面对无法最终证明的宗教信念，哪种想法更接近你？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我可以作出信仰承诺，同时承认它还没有得到知识上的证明。","evidenceId":"R02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"这些证据说服不了我，我需要更充分的理由。","evidenceId":"R02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"个人经历和生活实践也能给我相信的理由。","evidenceId":"R02.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"涉及个人信念但不要求披露宗教身份；可跳过，本地保存。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p42","source_p47","source_p14"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"R03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"苦难提出了什么问题","prompt":"假设有人相信一位全能且完全善的创造者，世上的无辜苦难会让你怎样看这种信念？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"它构成很强的反对理由，需要认真回答。","evidenceId":"R03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人的理解有限，苦难未必足以否定这种信念。","evidenceId":"R03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更想问信仰怎样回应苦难，而不是只解释它为何存在。","evidenceId":"R03.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"只讨论假设下的评价，不推断本人信仰。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p31"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"R04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"怎样理解自己与世界的关系","prompt":"想弄明白自己为什么活着、怎样在这个世界上安心生活，你更愿意从哪里开始？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"信任或亲近某种超越个人的存在，例如神。","evidenceId":"R04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"改变自己看待欲望、放不下的事和日常生活的方式。","evidenceId":"R04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"理解世界的根源，以及自己在其中的位置。","evidenceId":"R04.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"兴趣选择，只推荐专题，不用于信仰或学派匹配。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"interest_only","sourceIds":[],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"H01","revision":2,"stage":"base","topic":"H","title":"时代变了，道理会变吗","prompt":"一个时代广泛认可的观念，到了另一个时代却被反对。你最想了解什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"谁有能力把自己的说法变成大家默认的道理。","evidenceId":"H01.C"},{"id":"A","text":"哪一方有更站得住的理由，而不只是哪一方更流行。","evidenceId":"H01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不同的生活条件，怎样让人形成不同的观念。","evidenceId":"H01.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"理由、条件、权力关注点；后两项不是否认真理。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p30","source_p40","source_p41","source_p72","source_p37","source_p58","source_p68"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"H02","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"想法从哪里来","prompt":"你原以为完全属于自己的一个想法，后来发现和家庭、教育、时代密切相关。这会改变你对它的看法吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不会直接改变真假，还得看它本身的理由。","evidenceId":"H02.A"},{"id":"B","text":"会让我重新检查，有没有把学来的习惯，当成了人本来就该有的想法。","evidenceId":"H02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"会让我寻找是谁受益，以及哪些其他想法被排除了。","evidenceId":"H02.C"}],"editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"来源不自动决定真假；C 不等同阴谋论。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p65","source_p72","source_p43","source_p69"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"H03","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"改变社会，从哪里开始","prompt":"面对持续出现的不公平，你最想改变什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"重新检查大家习以为常的观念，质疑那些被当成理所当然的事。","evidenceId":"H03.B"},{"id":"C","text":"改进参与和协商的方式，让受影响的人能实际发声。","evidenceId":"H03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我更重视制度和资源分配，它们直接影响人的处境。","evidenceId":"H03.A"}],"editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"行动优先级，不推断完整政治立场。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p48","source_p67","source_p70"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"H04","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"历史会越来越好吗","prompt":"拉长眼光回看几千年的人类历史，你觉得它整体上是在往更好的方向走吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"别笼统地谈“人类整体进步”，我更想问：每一次所谓的进步里，到底是谁享了福、又是谁在底下付出了代价？","evidenceId":"H04.C"},{"id":"A","text":"虽然中间常有曲折甚至倒退，但拉长看，人类的认识在积累，自由也在一步步拓宽。","evidenceId":"H04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"历史根本没有一条包赚不赔的向上轨道，今天好不容易攒下的文明成果，明天也可能得而复失。","evidenceId":"H04.B"}],"editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"历史方向与评价尺度分开，不以一句话对应黑格尔或福柯。","sourceStatus":"原创体验草案，哲学出处与测量效度待核查"},"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p37","source_p68","source_p21","source_p63","source_p69"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T01","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"从哪里解释世界","prompt":"想解释雷雨、星辰和生命为什么会出现，你更愿意从哪里寻找它们共同的原因？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"自然内部的成分和运行方式。","evidenceId":"T01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"自然之外、有意安排这一切的力量。","evidenceId":"T01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我想知道每件事各自的原因，是否有共同根源可以留待研究。","evidenceId":"T01.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p01","source_p04"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T02","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"变化背后留着什么","prompt":"水冷了结成硬邦邦的冰，热了又化成看不见的蒸汽。如果世间万物也像这样变来变去，你觉得万物底层是什么样的？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"世界至少得由好几种截然不同的基本元素拼成，不可能全归成一种东西。","evidenceId":"T02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"何必非要找什么不变的底料，变化本身和事物之间的拉扯就是最底层的现实。","evidenceId":"T02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"看起来千差万别的东西，底下说不定都是同一种最基本的自然物质变出来的。","evidenceId":"T02.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p01","source_p02"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T03","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"对立会带来秩序吗","prompt":"弓的两端彼此拉扯，才让它能够射箭。你觉得世界的秩序更像什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这是局部比喻，不能据此理解整个世界。","evidenceId":"T03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"对立力量的相互牵制，本身就能形成秩序。","evidenceId":"T03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"有一个更稳定的安排，使对立不至于失控。","evidenceId":"T03.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p02"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T04","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"知识的对象必须不变吗","prompt":"如果某样东西每时每刻都在变化，它还能被真正认识吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"可以，认识变化中的关系和规律也是知识。","evidenceId":"T04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"可靠的知识需要稳定的对象，只知道眼前不断变化的样子还不够。","evidenceId":"T04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"能得到眼下够用的判断就好，我并不追求永恒不变的知识。","evidenceId":"T04.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p02","source_p03","source_p06","source_p49","source_p82","source_p36","source_p74"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T05","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"推理撞上眼见","prompt":"假如有一段逻辑严密、你挑不出半点毛病的推理证明：“真正存在的东西绝不会凭空产生，也不会消失”；可你睁开眼，满世界都是生老病死和变化。你信谁？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"信我亲眼看到的。变化明明就在发生，那段推理肯定在哪儿藏了错。","evidenceId":"T05.B"},{"id":"C","text":"变化明明就在眼前，可那段逻辑我也驳不倒，我还拿不准该信哪边。","evidenceId":"T05.C"},{"id":"A","text":"信严密的理性推理。感官看到的生灭变化可能只是表象，还需要更深层的解释。","evidenceId":"T05.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p03","source_p02","source_p12","source_p82"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T06","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"颜色藏在哪里","prompt":"同一件衣服在阳光下和昏暗灯光下看起来颜色不一样。你觉得“颜色”到底在哪儿？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"颜色既不单在衣服上、也不单在眼睛里，而是物体、光线和看的人碰到一起才产生的关系。","evidenceId":"T06.C"},{"id":"A","text":"物体的微粒排列会影响光的反射，刺激我们的感官后才生出“颜色”的感觉，颜色未必是物体本身带着的。","evidenceId":"T06.A"},{"id":"B","text":"颜色就是衣服本身实实在在带着的属性，光线变化只是影响了我们看清它而已。","evidenceId":"T06.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p04"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T07","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"拆到最后就够了吗","prompt":"想弄明白一棵树为什么会抽芽、长高，如果只去分析它里头的分子和原子怎么排列运动，在道理上就够了吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"够了。再复杂的生命现象，归根到底都是最基本的微观粒子按规律组合运动的结果。","evidenceId":"T07.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不够。还得看根、茎、叶怎么配合着维持整棵树的存活，这种“整体结构与功能”没法只拆成零件来解释。","evidenceId":"T07.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不够。活生生的生命里头，还有纯粹的物理和化学成分解释不了的精神或生命力量。","evidenceId":"T07.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p04","source_p07_nature","source_p36","source_p49"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T08","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"过得顺，还要追问吗","prompt":"一个人日子过得顺风顺水，也从没琢磨过“人活着到底图什么”。你会觉得他的人生缺了点什么吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"不觉得，日子过得舒坦就挺好，干嘛非要跟自己较劲。","evidenceId":"T08.B"},{"id":"C","text":"只要他没亏待身边的人就行，爱不爱琢磨人生大道理不重要。","evidenceId":"T08.C"},{"id":"A","text":"缺了点东西。活一辈子却从不审视自己的活法，总归有些遗憾。","evidenceId":"T08.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p05","source_p08","source_p10","source_p11"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T09","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"承认不知道","prompt":"争论到最后，你发现自己原来并没有弄懂一个词。接下来更愿意怎样？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"了解大家在什么情况下怎样使用这个词，比给它一个统一定义更有帮助。","evidenceId":"T09.C"},{"id":"A","text":"承认自己没弄懂，和对方把这个词的意思继续谈清楚。","evidenceId":"T09.A"},{"id":"B","text":"查找可靠的专业定义，让讨论有一个明确的依据。","evidenceId":"T09.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p05","source_p52"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T10","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"好判断怎样学会","prompt":"遇到剪不断理还乱的人情和责任冲突，你更信得过哪种判断方式？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"靠多年历练出来的分寸感和为人修养，看清眼下这件事怎样处理最妥当。","evidenceId":"T10.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我会用一条谁都不能破的底线原则，判断眼前这件事该不该做。","evidenceId":"T10.B"},{"id":"C","text":"把每种做法的好坏后果摆在桌面上算清楚，选伤害最小的那个。","evidenceId":"T10.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p44","source_p56","source_p77"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T11","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"快乐之外的好生活","prompt":"撇开大富大贵不谈，你觉得日子要过得好，最不能缺的是什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"身体少遭罪，心里不慌张，身边有几个交心的朋友。","evidenceId":"T11.B"},{"id":"C","text":"守住内心的定力，不管顺境逆境都不违背良心。","evidenceId":"T11.C"},{"id":"A","text":"把自己的本事真正使出来，也学会判断，把值得做的事做好。","evidenceId":"T11.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p09","source_p10","source_p33","source_p11"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T12","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"体面一定值得追吗","prompt":"身边的圈子讲究排场和体面，不跟着凑热闹就会显得格格不入。你会怎么办？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"别人爱讲究是别人的事，我既不特别赞成，也没打算反对。","evidenceId":"T12.C"},{"id":"A","text":"干脆甩掉这些撑场面的应酬，宁可被人说怪，也不受这份累。","evidenceId":"T12.A"},{"id":"B","text":"该有的礼数和体面还是得留着，这也是维系人情的一部分。","evidenceId":"T12.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p08","source_p81","source_p80"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T13","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"欲望越来越多","prompt":"明明吃穿不愁、日子安稳，心里却还是痒痒的，总想要更多。你会怎么跟这股劲儿相处？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"让自己冷静下来，分清哪些是真正需要的、哪些只是多余的追逐，少一点挂碍才更安宁。","evidenceId":"T13.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不压抑它，干脆找个更有挑战的目标，把这股野心变成往前冲的劲头。","evidenceId":"T13.B"},{"id":"C","text":"想要更多又不是坏事，去把条件创造出来、光明正大地满足它就是了。","evidenceId":"T13.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p08","source_p09","source_p38","source_p81","source_p11","source_p84","source_p87"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T14","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"没有奖励的正直","prompt":"做一件仗义执言的事，不仅没好处、没人夸，甚至心里也挺憋屈。你还会做吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"得看这样做实际上能不能帮到人；要是于事无补，犯不着只为显得高尚去白白受罪。","evidenceId":"T14.B"},{"id":"C","text":"要是半点好处都落不着，我大概会打退堂鼓。","evidenceId":"T14.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会。人立身处世的骨气，比外面的得失更要紧。","evidenceId":"T14.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p10","source_p11","source_p05","source_p06","source_p08","source_p09","source_p34","source_p38","source_p43","source_p82"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T15","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"过好自己就够了吗","prompt":"你已经能安稳地过自己的日子，但公共事务让你烦心。你更认同哪种做法？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"是否参与应由本人决定，不能仅因为属于这个群体就要求付出。","evidenceId":"T15.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我们彼此依赖，过好自己的生活也包括承担对他人的责任。","evidenceId":"T15.A"},{"id":"B","text":"尽量少卷入纷争，经营身边人的生活就够了。","evidenceId":"T15.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p11","source_p10"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T16","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"两边都说得通","prompt":"认真听过对立论证后，两边仍难分高下。你更愿意怎么办？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"暂不下定论，同时照经验和日常安排继续生活。","evidenceId":"T16.A"},{"id":"B","text":"选择证据稍强的一边，不可能永远等下去。","evidenceId":"T16.B"},{"id":"C","text":"去寻找一个不依赖这些争论的确定起点。","evidenceId":"T16.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p12"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T17","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"万物可能有怎样的共同来源","prompt":"假如这千姿百态的大千世界背后有一个共同的终极源头，你觉得它更像什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"某种最基础的自然物质，万事万物都是由它聚散变化出来的。","evidenceId":"T17.B"},{"id":"C","text":"一位有意志、有目的，主动创造了这一切的造物主。","evidenceId":"T17.C"},{"id":"A","text":"一个本身浑然一体、不由更小部分组成的终极根源，世间万物都依靠它才能存在。","evidenceId":"T17.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p13","source_p84"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T18","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"向内看能认识什么","prompt":"认识自己时，向内反省最可能让你接近什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"隐藏的社会影响，内心也不是凭空形成的。","evidenceId":"T18.C"},{"id":"A","text":"反省自己，也能接近不随个人喜好改变的真理和善。","evidenceId":"T18.A"},{"id":"B","text":"能了解自己的感受和习惯，但不能凭此知道经验之外的事。","evidenceId":"T18.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p13","source_p14"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T19","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"恶是什么","prompt":"看到欺骗、残忍这样的事，你更倾向怎样理解“恶”？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"像疾病损害健康一样，是原本应有的善受损或缺失。","evidenceId":"T19.A"},{"id":"B","text":"善恶是两股彼此对抗的力量，恶也能独立存在。","evidenceId":"T19.B"},{"id":"C","text":"“恶”是人作出的评价，而非构成世界的一种东西。","evidenceId":"T19.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p14"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T20","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"从概念到存在","prompt":"朋友这样劝你相信上帝：“上帝是能想到的最伟大者。如果只存在于想象中，就还能设想一个更伟大、真正存在的上帝。”你会被这个理由说服吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"说服不了我。脑子里把一个概念定义得再完美，也没法单靠定义就变出它的真实存在。","evidenceId":"T20.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我暂不评价这套推演，更关心相信上帝会让人活出怎样的生活。","evidenceId":"T20.C"},{"id":"A","text":"有道理。既然是“无可超越的最伟大者”，它就不可能只停留在想象里，必然在现实中也存在。","evidenceId":"T20.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p15","source_p29","source_p31"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective","help":"这段话想只靠“最伟大者”这个概念，推出它在现实中存在。题目问你是否接受这种论证方式。"},{"id":"T21","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"信仰和理解谁先","prompt":"面对一种你还没有完全理解的信仰，哪种想法更接近你？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"信任可能推动理解，理解也可能带来信任，顺序因人而异。","evidenceId":"T21.C"},{"id":"A","text":"信仰可以成为理解的起点，我愿意深入了解自己所信的。","evidenceId":"T21.A"},{"id":"B","text":"充分的理由是信仰的基础，有了这些理由我才会相信。","evidenceId":"T21.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p14","source_p15","source_p42"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T22","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"知道是什么，就知道它存在吗","prompt":"就算你把“凤凰”或“三角形”是什么样子、有什么特征彻底研究透了，你能单凭这个，就解释清楚它为什么会真正在现实里存在吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不能。“它是什么样”和“现实里到底有没有它”是两码事，得另外找原因。","evidenceId":"T22.A"},{"id":"B","text":"如果真把一样东西的本质彻彻底底摸透了，它为什么存在也就包在里头了。","evidenceId":"T22.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这得看你说的“彻底研究透”包不包括它的来龙去脉，现在还不好一概而论。","evidenceId":"T22.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p16","source_p18"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T23","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"万物都靠别的条件，解释就够了吗","prompt":"假如世上的每一样东西都得靠别的条件才能存在（比如树靠水和土壤，水和土壤又各有形成的条件）。顺着链条追下去，要是每样东西都依附于别的条件，这事儿算解释完了吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"算解释完了。样样东西各有条件，条件之间的联系本身就能构成解释，不非得在链条尽头找一个“谁也不靠”的起点。","evidenceId":"T23.B"},{"id":"C","text":"追到一定程度就可以停了，宇宙有些底层的事实可能本来就没有更深一层的原因。","evidenceId":"T23.C"},{"id":"A","text":"没解释完。要是所有东西都得靠别的东西撑着，那整条链子还是悬空的——最后非得有一个自己就能独立存在的终极根源托底不可。","evidenceId":"T23.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p15","source_p16","source_p18"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T24","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"经典和论证冲突","prompt":"某部你尊重的宗教经典，字面意思与可靠的理性论证冲突。你更愿意怎么处理？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"把两者看成不同活动，不要求得出同一类答案。","evidenceId":"T24.C"},{"id":"A","text":"重新理解经典，它可能有超出字面的含义，与论证并不冲突。","evidenceId":"T24.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我更相信经典的字面意思，因为人的推理能力可能有局限。","evidenceId":"T24.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p17"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T25","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"共同的道德根据","prompt":"信仰和背景完全不同的一群人，要想坐下来定出一套大家都认的道德底线，这套底线最终靠什么立住？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"靠人类共通的生存需要，以及大家讲道理、摆事实的理性讨论。","evidenceId":"T25.A"},{"id":"B","text":"光靠人自己的算计立不住，背后得有超越凡人的神圣启示或信仰托底。","evidenceId":"T25.B"},{"id":"C","text":"靠大家坐下来讨价还价达成的契约，没必要假装有什么天生的法则。","evidenceId":"T25.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p18","source_p17","source_p20"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T26","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"两样东西凭什么是两个","prompt":"流水线上造出了两枚一模一样的硬币，材质、重量、花纹分毫不差。你凭什么说这是“两枚”硬币，而不是同一个东西？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"因为它们占着不同的位置、有着各自的来历，光靠这些就够分清了。","evidenceId":"T26.B"},{"id":"C","text":"要是连空间位置和所有特征都真的丝毫不差，那就没法再说它们是两个了。","evidenceId":"T26.C"},{"id":"A","text":"每一枚硬币都有让它成为“这一个”而非“那一个”的独特底子，这不是靠外在特征对比出来的。","evidenceId":"T26.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p19"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T27","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"看见更好，就只能选它吗","prompt":"理智已经替你算得很清楚：选这条路对你自己最有利。但在做决定的那一刻，你还能放下个人得失，主动选择那条吃亏却公正的路吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我更想弄明白人心里的动机是怎么一点点形成的，至于独立于这些动机的“纯粹意志”是否存在，我还拿不准。","evidenceId":"T27.C"},{"id":"A","text":"能。哪怕算清了哪边对自己更划算，人的意志依然可以为了公正本身作出选择，不必只顺着个人利益走。","evidenceId":"T27.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人没法违背自己眼下认定的“最好判断”；真要是选了公正，也是因为你重新想通了“公正比划算更重要”。","evidenceId":"T27.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p19"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T28","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"具体的树之外，还需要“树本身”吗","prompt":"路边的松树、柳树、槐树有一天都会枯死。但哪怕世上所有的树都消失了，“树”这个纯粹的模子或本质，还会独立存在吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不会。现实里只有一棵棵具体的树，“树”只是我们脑子里用来归类的概念。","evidenceId":"T28.A"},{"id":"B","text":"会。具体的树生生灭灭，但它们共同分有的那个“树的本质”是真实且不变的。","evidenceId":"T28.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我看不出假设一个脱离具体树木的“树本身”，到底能帮我们多解释什么。","evidenceId":"T28.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p20","source_p06","source_p17","source_p19"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T29","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"少一个假设","prompt":"两套理论预测得一样准。第一套只用眼前已知的东西就能说通；第二套还额外假设了一种谁也没亲眼见过的神秘东西。你更偏向哪一套？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"看哪一套更接近世界的真实底色，有些真实存在的东西本来就没法直接看到。","evidenceId":"T29.B"},{"id":"C","text":"光比谁假设少没用，我得看它们接下来能不能预测出不一样的新现象。","evidenceId":"T29.C"},{"id":"A","text":"能用简单的道理说通，新增的东西就得有额外的解释作用，不能凭空多编一个出来。","evidenceId":"T29.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p20","source_p53"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T30","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"掌权者也适用同样的道德要求吗","prompt":"一个领导者为了避免整个社会陷入崩溃，考虑使用在私人交往中难以接受的手段。你怎么看？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"所谓危险可能被夸大了，我想知道它是不是为这些手段开脱的借口。","evidenceId":"T30.C"},{"id":"A","text":"领导者要承担公共责任，不能完全照搬私人交往中的判断。","evidenceId":"T30.A"},{"id":"B","text":"公共身份也不能让人免于基本的道德约束。","evidenceId":"T30.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p21","source_p24"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T31","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"冲突一定是坏事吗","prompt":"普通民众和掌权者之间公开爆发利益争执，你觉得这对一个社会来说意味着什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"未必是坏事。只要能把争执引向公开议事和立法，这种博弈反而能逼出保护大众自由的好制度。","evidenceId":"T31.A"},{"id":"B","text":"争执闹大了很容易拖垮社会秩序，还是应该由强有力的统一权威出面压住阵脚。","evidenceId":"T31.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我只关心哪一边的诉求更占理，吵架和冲突本身没什么值得叫好的。","evidenceId":"T31.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p21","source_p24"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T32","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"只找到支持自己的例子","prompt":"研究一个想法时，你发现自己总记住支持它的例子。接下来更重要的是什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"概念和推理是否正确同样重要，错误的前提会让更多观察也偏离方向。","evidenceId":"T32.B"},{"id":"C","text":"请持不同立场的人一起讨论，暴露各自的盲点。","evidenceId":"T32.C"},{"id":"A","text":"主动收集不符合预期的例子，有计划地观察，检查自己有没有偏见。","evidenceId":"T32.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p22","source_p46","source_p57"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T33","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"怀疑之后还剩什么","prompt":"假设感官与记忆都可能欺骗你，什么还能成为认识的起点？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"怀疑时的经验值得仔细观察，至于背后是否有一个不变的“我”，我还拿不准。","evidenceId":"T33.C"},{"id":"A","text":"既然我正在怀疑，就至少能确定：我此刻在思考。","evidenceId":"T33.A"},{"id":"B","text":"没有必要找到绝对确定的起点，证据可靠就能继续。","evidenceId":"T33.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p23","source_p22","source_p54","source_p65"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T34","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"思想能离开身体吗","prompt":"你脑子里的念头、心里的悲喜，和这具血肉之躯到底是什么关系？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"心灵和肉体本就是截然不同的两类存在，没法只拿脑神经和肉体活动来解释人的精神世界。","evidenceId":"T34.A"},{"id":"B","text":"并没有独立于肉体之外的心灵，人的念头和感受归根结底都是大脑与身体的活动。","evidenceId":"T34.B"},{"id":"C","text":"一上来就把“心”和“身”硬劈成两半来问，可能从根子上就想偏了。","evidenceId":"T34.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p23","source_p04","source_p13","source_p14","source_p16","source_p24","source_p35","source_p36","source_p39","source_p59","source_p60","source_p61","source_p64","source_p87","source_p89"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T35","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"没有共同裁决者","prompt":"假如社会上没有统一的裁判，每个人受了委屈都自己动手算账，结果冲突没完没了。你觉得靠什么最能破这个局？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"设立几个能互相制衡的公共机构，免得请来一个大裁判，反倒成了欺压所有人的新威胁。","evidenceId":"T35.B"},{"id":"C","text":"靠小规模协商和互助来化解，尽量别把大权集中到少数人手里。","evidenceId":"T35.C"},{"id":"A","text":"必须立起一个说话算话、能强力执行裁决的最高权威，才能彻底结束人人自危的混战。","evidenceId":"T35.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p24","source_p30","source_p83"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T36","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"理解欲望，会更自由吗","prompt":"某天你突然看清，自己心里的嫉妒其实源于早年的经历和爱比较的习惯。看清这一点，会让你变得更自由吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"光想通原因未必有用，能因此去改变身处的环境才更要紧。","evidenceId":"T36.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会。看清这股嫉妒是从哪儿来的，心里的执念就会松动，不再那么容易被它推着走。","evidenceId":"T36.A"},{"id":"B","text":"未必。原因弄明白了，下次我仍可能只能作出同样的选择。","evidenceId":"T36.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p25"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T37","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"自然之外还需要安排者吗","prompt":"假如四季轮替、万物生长都能用自然界自身的因果规律说清楚，你觉得还需要一位“幕后安排者”吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不需要了。自然界靠自身的因果规律就能运转，再假设一个外在意志纯属多余。","evidenceId":"T37.A"},{"id":"B","text":"仍然需要。自然界居然能有这么井然的规律，这本身就指向了一位超越自然的创造者。","evidenceId":"T37.B"},{"id":"C","text":"科学规律只是在记录“事情通常怎么发生”，单凭它既推不出幕后有安排，也证不出完全没目的。","evidenceId":"T37.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p25","source_p01","source_p02","source_p09"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T38","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"谁继承了你的记忆","prompt":"假如手术把你的记忆和意识全都转移到了另一具身体里，而原来的身体醒来后一片空白。你觉得哪一边才是真正的“你”？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"原来那具一直活生生喘着气的身体。","evidenceId":"T38.B"},{"id":"C","text":"两边各延续了一些东西，很难说哪一边独占了全部的“我”。","evidenceId":"T38.C"},{"id":"A","text":"带着我全部记忆和念头醒来的那一边。","evidenceId":"T38.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p26","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Personal identity","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T39","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"最初的想法来自哪里","prompt":"人刚生下来时像一张白纸，还是脑子里早就自带了一些理解世界的基本底色？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"人是在学说话、跟人打交道的过程里才学会思考的，不能光盯着一个人的脑子看。","evidenceId":"T39.C"},{"id":"A","text":"更像白纸。一切想法都得靠眼睛看、耳朵听，再加上对自身感受的体会一点点攒出来。","evidenceId":"T39.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人在接触外界之前，心里就已经自带了一些基本观念。","evidenceId":"T39.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p26","source_p18","source_p20","source_p22","source_p23","source_p27","source_p28","source_p29","source_p51"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T40","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"为什么偏偏这样","prompt":"世上发生的每一件事、存在的每一样东西，背后都必定有一个充足的理由，能解释“它为什么偏偏是这样，而不是别的样子”吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"必定有。就算人类眼下还查不出来，世上也绝没有无缘无故、毫无道理的事实。","evidenceId":"T40.A"},{"id":"B","text":"未必。追到最底下，有些事实可能单纯“就是这样”，并没有什么更深的理由。","evidenceId":"T40.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我们可以一直往深处追问理由，但宇宙是不是事事都有终极答案，现在还不好断定。","evidenceId":"T40.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p27","philpapers2020","source_p25"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Principle of sufficient reason","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T41","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"两样完全一样的东西","prompt":"有人做了个思想实验：假如有两样东西，不仅自身的所有特征丝毫不差，连它们所处的位置、跟周围一切事物的关系也完全重叠。你觉得它们还能算是“两个”东西吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"能算两个。是不是两个独立的东西，不非得靠某处特征不一样来证明。","evidenceId":"T41.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这个设想本身就挺含糊，尤其“连所处位置和一切关系都相同”到底是什么意思，很难说清。","evidenceId":"T41.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不能。要是里里外外、连前因后果和位置关系都找不出半点差别，那就没有理由说它们是两个，它们根本就是同一个东西。","evidenceId":"T41.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p27"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T42","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"感受到的桌子背后还有什么","prompt":"你看到棕色的桌面、摸到坚硬的木头、听到敲击的声响。如果把颜色、软硬、形状这些能感觉到的特征全剥掉，底下还剩不剩一个永远摸不着、看不见的“物质底座”在托着它们？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"光靠我们的感官经验，既没法证明有这个底座，也没法证明没有。","evidenceId":"T42.C"},{"id":"A","text":"并不需要一个看不见的物质底座，这一组稳定出现的颜色、触感和规律，本身就已经是桌子了。","evidenceId":"T42.A"},{"id":"B","text":"肯定有。要是底下没有一个不靠人感知的物质实体托着，这些特征就成了无根的幻影。","evidenceId":"T42.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p28"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T43","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"为什么不该伤害别人","prompt":"明知一件事会害人，你手就停住了。拦住你的那股劲儿到底是什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"是心里的不忍和在乎。要是没有半点心疼，光懂大道理根本推不动人。","evidenceId":"T43.A"},{"id":"B","text":"哪怕当时心里没波澜，单靠理智也能想明白为什么不该害人。","evidenceId":"T43.B"},{"id":"C","text":"主要是因为社会规矩摆在那儿，越界了大家都没法好好处。","evidenceId":"T43.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p29","source_p05","source_p07","source_p33","source_p34","source_p39"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T44","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"好掌权者够不够","prompt":"即使现在的掌权者很贤明，权力还需要被其他权力限制吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"未必，过多限制可能妨碍能干的人做事。","evidenceId":"T44.B"},{"id":"C","text":"关键是公开参与和监督，不一定靠权力之间相互制约。","evidenceId":"T44.C"},{"id":"A","text":"需要，再贤明的人掌权，也该有别的机构能够制约他。","evidenceId":"T44.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p30","source_p26"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T45","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"同一制度适合所有地方吗","prompt":"一种法律制度在某地运作很好，换个社会能直接照搬吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"外人觉得合不合适不重要，关键看这套制度是不是当地人自己商量、自愿接受的。","evidenceId":"T45.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不能直接照搬，法律和制度得贴合当地的气候环境、人情习惯和社会条件。","evidenceId":"T45.A"},{"id":"B","text":"只要背后的基本原则是对的，放到哪里都应该尽量按同一套标准推行。","evidenceId":"T45.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p21","source_p30"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T46","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"讨厌的信念也能表达吗","prompt":"一种宗教或人生信念让你很反感，但没有伤害或强迫别人。你愿意容许它公开表达吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"愿意，我不喜欢它，但只要没有伤害或强迫别人，就应允许它公开表达。","evidenceId":"T46.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不愿意，错误信念的传播本身就需要阻止。","evidenceId":"T46.B"},{"id":"C","text":"私人可以保留，公开表达应受到更严格限制。","evidenceId":"T46.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p31","source_p26","source_p45"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T47","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"共同规则还能让人自由吗","prompt":"法律和规矩不可能每条都顺着你的心意。在什么情况下，守规矩不会让你觉得是在“受人摆布”，反而算是一种自由？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"只要这套规矩是我当初确实点头答应过的，守自己认下的承诺就不算受人摆布。","evidenceId":"T47.B"},{"id":"C","text":"只要它在管束之外，还给我留出了足够宽敞、谁也别来干涉的私人生活空间。","evidenceId":"T47.C"},{"id":"A","text":"只要它是大家作为平等成员一起参与定出来的、奔着共同利益去，遵守它就是在遵守我们自己定的规矩。","evidenceId":"T47.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p37","source_p67","source_p71"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T48","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"能力差异说明了什么","prompt":"一项调查发现，两个群体的平均考试成绩长期不同。要解释这种差异，你更关注什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"不能只凭群体平均分判断具体的人，评价一个人还得看他自己的实际表现。","evidenceId":"T48.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我会比较两边从小得到的教育资源和生活条件，考分高低要放在这些背景里理解。","evidenceId":"T48.A"},{"id":"B","text":"先天禀赋的差异也不必避讳，得实事求是地查清它和后天环境各占了几分原因。","evidenceId":"T48.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p33","source_p62"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T49","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"能让所有人都这么做吗","prompt":"你很想给自己破一次例，但转念一想：“要是人人都拿这个借口破例，规矩就全垮了。”这个念头会拦住你吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"会。做人做事的标准不能搞双标，不该只给自己留后门。","evidenceId":"T49.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不一定，得看我这次破例实际上有没有闯祸。","evidenceId":"T49.B"},{"id":"C","text":"看我当时处在什么位置、担什么角色，不同身份本来就该有不同的尺度。","evidenceId":"T49.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p34"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T50","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"把一个人当作工具","prompt":"如果牺牲一个无辜的人，能救活或者造福很多人，我们能跨过他本人的意愿，把他当成救人的垫脚石吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"在极端情况下可以，但得算清楚救下的人和付出的代价到底差多少。","evidenceId":"T50.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这不能由某个人私下决定，得看有没有经过公正的程序和共同授权。","evidenceId":"T50.C"},{"id":"A","text":"绝对不行。哪怕为了大多数人，也不能把一个活生生的人当成纯粹的工具。","evidenceId":"T50.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p34","source_p56","source_p63","source_p66","source_p44","source_p75","source_p76"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T51","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"怎样理解“我”是什么","prompt":"当你在夜深人静琢磨“我到底是谁”的时候，你觉得哪个切入点最实在？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"看看我的身体、走过的路，以及和身边人的羁绊——这些加起来就是我。","evidenceId":"T51.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不用找什么固定不变的底子，此刻正在思考、发愿和行动的这股劲儿，就是“我”。","evidenceId":"T51.A"},{"id":"B","text":"所有念头和经历背后，肯定有一个始终不变的“我”在当主人。","evidenceId":"T51.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p35"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T52","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"自然只是零件吗","prompt":"大自然不仅有风吹石落，还能孕育出活生生的生命、不断长出全新的结构。你怎么看大自然的这种“创造力”？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"自然界本身就有一股主动生长、自我组织的活力，绝不只是死零件在被动碰撞。","evidenceId":"T52.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不用把自然想得那么神秘，只要摸透了底层的基本粒子和物理规律，照样能解释复杂生命是怎么拼出来的。","evidenceId":"T52.B"},{"id":"C","text":"从整体和从零件着手，本来就是两种研究角度；大自然的根本性质，我还说不准。","evidenceId":"T52.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p36","source_p49","source_p74"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T53","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"独处就能拥有全部自由吗","prompt":"一个人眼下没人绑着他、拦着他，但周围人都不拿他当能自己做主的人，法律和制度也不保护他的权利。这样算活得自由吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"算自由了。只要眼下没人强行阻拦就是自由，至于有没有条件办成事是另一码事。","evidenceId":"T53.B"},{"id":"C","text":"关键看他内心是不是清楚、笃定地认可自己的选择，外头的制度不是决定性的。","evidenceId":"T53.C"},{"id":"A","text":"还远远不够。真正的自由，需要别人承认你的平等身份，也得有制度为你撑腰。","evidenceId":"T53.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p35","source_p37","source_p40","source_p41","source_p62","source_p67","source_p70"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T54","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"满足为什么总不长久","prompt":"心心念念的东西刚到手，高兴没两天，心里又空落落的想要别的了。你怎么看这种状态？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"说明之前没找对真正想要的东西，选对了目标就能踏实下来。","evidenceId":"T54.C"},{"id":"A","text":"人的欲望本来就是个无底洞，填满这一个，马上又会挖出下一个。","evidenceId":"T54.A"},{"id":"B","text":"有新念想才说明人活得带劲，真要是啥都不想了反而没意思。","evidenceId":"T54.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p38","source_p43"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T55","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"同情是不是根本理由","prompt":"看见别人受苦，你脑子里还没来得及想什么规矩和回报，心就先揪起来了。这种本能的同情，够不够撑起人的道德？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"够了。直接对他人的痛苦感同身受，就是人行善最根本的源头。","evidenceId":"T55.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不够。同情心太看心情和远近了，还得靠理性的道德原则来掌舵。","evidenceId":"T55.B"},{"id":"C","text":"它是个好苗头，但一件事做得到底对不对，最后还得看实际帮到了多少。","evidenceId":"T55.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p38","source_p44","source_p45","source_p78","source_p80"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T56","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"神的形象可能从何而来","prompt":"在各种宗教里，人们常把全知、全善、全能这些最美好的品质归给“神”。你觉得这主要说明了什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"说明人类确实仰望并触碰到了那位真实存在、超越凡人的神圣者。","evidenceId":"T56.B"},{"id":"C","text":"单看神圣形象本身没法下定论，它是真有其神还是人心投射，两头都有可能。","evidenceId":"T56.C"},{"id":"A","text":"说明人把自己身上最向往的智慧和爱放大到了极致，再把它们投射到天上，当成了一位独立于人的神。","evidenceId":"T56.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p39"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T57","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"工作为何不像自己的生活","prompt":"一份工作薪水并不低，但做什么、怎么做、做出来的东西归谁，全由上头和系统说了算。人每天像拧螺丝一样交差，下班后觉得整个人被掏空了。你觉得病根在哪儿？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"主要是公司管理太死板、沟通不畅，改善一下流程和氛围就能缓解。","evidenceId":"T57.C"},{"id":"A","text":"病根在于人沦为了活计的附属品，既做不了劳动的主，也无法在成果里看见自己的创造——这不是涨点工资能打发的。","evidenceId":"T57.A"},{"id":"B","text":"既然是明码标价、自愿签合同拿钱干活，觉得空虚主要还是个人心态和期待没调好。","evidenceId":"T57.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p40"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T58","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"家庭形式为什么会变","prompt":"理解历史上不同的家庭和亲属制度，你更愿意优先考察什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"人们怎样谋生、拥有和继承财产，以及这些安排如何影响家庭关系。","evidenceId":"T58.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人类不变的天性怎样在不同地方表现。","evidenceId":"T58.B"},{"id":"C","text":"个人爱情观念怎样逐步取得影响。","evidenceId":"T58.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p41"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T59","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"国家一直都会存在吗","prompt":"“国家”这种有政府、有法律、有强制力的组织，是人类只要聚在一起过日子就永远离不开的吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"是，只要人聚多了，没有统一的法律和公共权威来维持秩序，社会早晚会陷入混乱。","evidenceId":"T59.B"},{"id":"C","text":"那得看你把什么叫作“国家”，概念没对齐之前不好一概而论。","evidenceId":"T59.C"},{"id":"A","text":"未必。国家是在特定的历史和阶级条件下才长出来的，未来条件变了，人类未必还需要它。","evidenceId":"T59.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p41","source_p24","source_p40"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T60","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"证明完再承诺吗","prompt":"无论是决定彻底相信一个人，还是投身某种信念，你永远不可能事先拿到 100% 没风险的证据。这时候你会怎么选？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我愿意试一试，也给自己留条退路，不想一下就把一辈子搭进去。","evidenceId":"T60.C"},{"id":"A","text":"该迈出去的时候就得迈出去。真要等证据万无一失，人生很多重要的承诺就永远做不成了。","evidenceId":"T60.A"},{"id":"B","text":"越是重大的承诺越得沉住气，在理由和底细还没看清之前，我不愿凭一腔热情贸然押上去。","evidenceId":"T60.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p42","source_p61","source_p47","source_p63"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T61","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"道德也需要查来历吗","prompt":"如果某种被奉为“高尚”的传统美德，追根溯源一看，最初其实是弱者出于怨恨、或者上位者为了驯服别人才发明出来的，你还会认它吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"这正是我要追查的：得看这套美德最初服务于什么，它是在滋养人的生命力，还是让人变得顺从乏力。","evidenceId":"T61.A"},{"id":"B","text":"来路不体面不代表道理本身错了，关键看它放到今天还有没有站得住脚的理由。","evidenceId":"T61.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不管最初是怎么来的，只要它在今天还能帮大家维持基本的信任与秩序，就有继续保留的价值。","evidenceId":"T61.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p43"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T62","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"没有现成标准时","prompt":"如果有一天，从小被灌输的“成功标准”和大道理突然全都不让你信服了，你会怎么办？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"去寻找那些不随我个人好恶摇摆的价值——对错和好坏，总得有比个人心意更稳固的根据。","evidenceId":"T62.B"},{"id":"C","text":"有一段日子没弄清什么最重要，我也能接受，期待可以放低些。","evidenceId":"T62.C"},{"id":"A","text":"自己为自己拿主意——在实际行动中摸索出一套我真正认可、也愿意担起后果的活法。","evidenceId":"T62.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p43","source_p74","source_p61"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T63","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"谁的痛苦更重要","prompt":"在制定公共政策时，不管是素不相识的普通人，还是你的熟人或社会名流，只要承受着同样的痛苦，政策就应该一视同仁吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"比起算谁更痛，我更关心这项政策有没有踩过任何人的基本权利红线。","evidenceId":"T63.C"},{"id":"A","text":"应该。只要是同样程度的痛苦，不管落到谁头上，分量都完全一样。","evidenceId":"T63.A"},{"id":"B","text":"未必。人和人有亲疏远近、责任轻重，有些关系本来就该多担一份。","evidenceId":"T63.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p44","source_p45","source_p80","source_p66"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T64","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"快乐也有高低之分吗","prompt":"刷短视频傻乐一小时，和读懂一本好书后心潮澎湃一小时——假设快乐的程度和时长完全一样，你会觉得后一种快乐更高级吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"会。能让人开窍、体验更丰富的快乐，分量就是不一样。","evidenceId":"T64.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不会。只要一样开心、一样久，开心就是开心，没必要分三六九等。","evidenceId":"T64.B"},{"id":"C","text":"看对谁而言吧，每个人受用的东西不同，没法拿一把尺子替所有人排高低。","evidenceId":"T64.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p44","source_p45"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T65","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"别人看不惯，就该管吗","prompt":"一个成年人的生活方式让多数人看不惯，但没有伤害别人。大家有理由强制干涉吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"有，一起生活，就该遵守共同认可的生活标准。","evidenceId":"T65.B"},{"id":"C","text":"除了眼前的伤害，还要考虑它对大家的长期影响。","evidenceId":"T65.C"},{"id":"A","text":"没有，每个人都该有尝试自己生活方式的自由。","evidenceId":"T65.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p45","source_p31","source_p71","source_p76"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T66","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"争的到底有没有差别","prompt":"两派人吵得不可开交，但到目前为止，不管按哪一派的说法去观察、去办事，得到的实际结果都一模一样。你怎么看这场争论？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"也许以后能测出差别，这个问题值得继续研究。","evidenceId":"T66.C"},{"id":"A","text":"要是推到底，两边在任何可能的实际后果上都毫无差别，那它们或许只是换了套词儿在说同一件事。","evidenceId":"T66.A"},{"id":"B","text":"就算实践中看不出差别，它们对“世界底层到底是什么样”的解释，依然可能有重要不同。","evidenceId":"T66.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p46","source_p47","source_p48"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T67","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"一次成功够不够真","prompt":"一个想法眼下很有用，怎样才能更有理由相信它？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"让不同的人反复检验，发现错了就改。眼下一次成功还不够。","evidenceId":"T67.A"},{"id":"B","text":"继续在日常中试用，检验它能否稳定地解决我的问题。","evidenceId":"T67.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更重视它依靠的前提是否足够确定。","evidenceId":"T67.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p46","source_p48","source_p57","source_p22"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T68","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"必须选择，又证据不足","prompt":"人生走到十字路口，有件事你必须马上拍板，拖着不选本身也是一种放弃；偏偏眼下的证据又不够帮你算出标准答案。你会怎么办？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"证据不够就不能勉强自己相信；宁可承受错过这次机会的代价，也不在依据不足时硬下判断。","evidenceId":"T68.B"},{"id":"C","text":"行动上我会选风险最小的做法；相信哪种说法，我仍没有定论。","evidenceId":"T68.C"},{"id":"A","text":"既然躲不开，就允许自己顺着内心的信念和热望迈出这一步，同时坦然承认这是一场未有定论的冒险。","evidenceId":"T68.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p47"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T69","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"理论进了生活之后","prompt":"一套原本挺好使的理论，拿到现实里解决新问题时卡壳了。你觉得该怎么调整？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"理论本来就只管如实弄清世界是什么样，能不能解决实际问题不是它的本职。","evidenceId":"T69.C"},{"id":"A","text":"理论本来就是解决问题的工具，卡壳了就顺着实际困难去改它，甚至重新审视问题本身有没有问错。","evidenceId":"T69.A"},{"id":"B","text":"理论大框架一般没毛病，多半是底下具体落地的办法没找对。","evidenceId":"T69.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p47","source_p48"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T70","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"一分钟总是一样长吗","prompt":"钟表上的一分钟永远一样长，但苦苦等待、沉浸听歌和事后回忆里的一分钟，快慢却天差地别。你怎么看这种差别？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"人亲身经历的时间是连成一片的，上一秒的心境会渗进下一秒，钟表上均等的刻度根本量不出这种流动。","evidenceId":"T70.A"},{"id":"B","text":"客观流逝的时间其实一分一秒都没变，觉得快或慢，只是人脑子里的主观估计。","evidenceId":"T70.B"},{"id":"C","text":"钟表刻度用来方便约事，心里快慢则是活生生的感受，两边各有各的用处，没必要争哪个更真实。","evidenceId":"T70.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p49","source_p60"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T71","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"推理对错由什么决定","prompt":"你和别人对同一步推理有分歧。你认为，判断“谁推得对”最终应根据什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"看它符不符合人类共通的思维习惯——所谓逻辑规律，归根结底也是从人脑平时怎么想事情里总结出来的。","evidenceId":"T71.B"},{"id":"C","text":"看你们正在用哪一套逻辑规则；换一套规则体系，同一步推理的对错判断也可能跟着变。","evidenceId":"T71.C"},{"id":"A","text":"看客观上前提能不能推出结论。推理对错有它独立的标准，就算全世界人都习惯推错，错的也变不成对的。","evidenceId":"T71.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p50","source_p51","source_p53","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Logic","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T72","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"晨星和暮星原来是同一个","prompt":"早晨见到的“晨星”和傍晚见到的“暮星”其实都是金星。为什么知道这一点，仍然算知道了新东西？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"因为大家平时在截然不同的场合里用这两个名字，把两套用法对接起来，自然就多知道了新情况。","evidenceId":"T72.C"},{"id":"A","text":"虽然指的都是金星这同一颗星，但“清晨亮起的那颗”和“傍晚出现的那颗”给出了两条不同的认识路径，把两条路接通就是新知识。","evidenceId":"T72.A"},{"id":"B","text":"新知识在于发现“这两个名字居然指的是同一个东西”，名字本身未必就含有两种不同的意义。","evidenceId":"T72.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p50"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T73","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"不存在的国王","prompt":"法国早就没有国王了。这时候如果有人一本正经地说“现在的法国国王是个秃头”，你会怎么反驳或处理这句话？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"这句话其实暗含了“现在有法国国王”这个假前提，前提就错了，整句话自然是假的。","evidenceId":"T73.A"},{"id":"B","text":"既然现实里没有这号人，这句话就谈不上真假。说话人是在开玩笑还是演戏，得结合当时的场景来理解。","evidenceId":"T73.B"},{"id":"C","text":"哪怕现实里没有，我们脑子里也能谈论“法国国王”这个虚构对象，再讨论他秃不秃。","evidenceId":"T73.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p51"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T74","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"词离开生活之后","prompt":"有人反复问“时间本身究竟是什么”，越问越糊涂。你更愿意从哪入手？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"继续往深处挖，找出“时间”背后共同的实体或统一的本质。","evidenceId":"T74.B"},{"id":"C","text":"别在日常字眼上打转了，直接看物理学是怎么精确定义和测量时间的。","evidenceId":"T74.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我会从“赶时间”“时间过得快”这些日常说法里找答案。越想越糊涂，多半是因为把词从生活场景里抽出来硬想了。","evidenceId":"T74.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p52"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T75","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"“有这种数”和“数存在”，是一回事吗","prompt":"问“有没有比 100 大的质数”，顺着数学规矩一算就知道“有”。但如果有人接着问：“那‘数’这东西，在现实宇宙里到底存不存在？”你会怎么回答？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"数只是人类发明出来方便算账的计算工具，犯不着把它当成真实存在的东西。","evidenceId":"T75.C"},{"id":"A","text":"这其实是两码事：前一句是在数学规则里找答案，后一句是在问“我们要不要采用数学这套语言框架”。","evidenceId":"T75.A"},{"id":"B","text":"数学规律和数的存在是客观的，不管人类用不用这套语言，它都在那儿。","evidenceId":"T75.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p53","source_p50","source_p55"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T76","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"失败的是哪一句","prompt":"做实验时，测出来的结果跟理论预测的对不上。这能直接证明理论里的某一条具体判断错了吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"未必。接受实验检验的从来不是孤零零的一句话，从核心定律、辅助假设到仪器刻度，哪一环出毛病都会让结果跑偏。","evidenceId":"T76.A"},{"id":"B","text":"只要实验操作本身扎实可靠，结果对不上，就至少说明那条推出来的预测错了。","evidenceId":"T76.B"},{"id":"C","text":"单看一次失败还不好说是哪儿的问题，让不同的人换设备重复做几次，可能有助于分清是哪一环出了岔子。","evidenceId":"T76.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p54","source_p58"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T77","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"还叫不叫那个名字","prompt":"你一直向朋友推荐一位作家，后来发现那些著作其实是别人代写的。再说起这个名字时，你觉得自己仍在说谁？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"指真正写出那些作品的捉刀人——毕竟我心里认准的“那位大作家”，就是写下这些文字的人。","evidenceId":"T77.B"},{"id":"C","text":"这个名字指谁，就按眼下聊天时大家约定的用法来理解。","evidenceId":"T77.C"},{"id":"A","text":"还是指最初取了这个名字、一路被大家叫下来的那个人——只是我们今天才发现，原来那些书不是他写的。","evidenceId":"T77.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p55","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Proper names","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T78","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"像水一样，就还是水吗","prompt":"在另一颗星球上，有一种液体，外观、味道、用途都和水一样，化学成分却完全不同。你会把它也看作水吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"日常可以叫它水，科学分类则应该另算。","evidenceId":"T78.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不会。水是哪种物质，取决于它本身的组成，不只是外观和用途。","evidenceId":"T78.A"},{"id":"B","text":"会。只要感受和用途都一样，对我来说它就是水。","evidenceId":"T78.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p55","philpapers2020"],"relatedSurveyTopic":"Possible worlds","sourceRelation":"议题参考，非原题翻译或量表授权","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T79","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"同一个动作，不同的行动","prompt":"你半夜起床按开关开灯，结果把窗外经过的路人吓了一跳。要弄清你刚才“到底是有意干了什么”，最关键的是看什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"看我按下开关时心里知道些什么，以及我原本是奔着什么目的去的。","evidenceId":"T79.A"},{"id":"B","text":"别管心里怎么想，就看我实际上做了什么动作、惹出了什么结果。","evidenceId":"T79.B"},{"id":"C","text":"动作就是动作，理由是我事后怎么给自己的行为找说法，两码事可以分开看。","evidenceId":"T79.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p56"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T80","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"科学标准会变吗","prompt":"当科学经历一场大洗牌（比如从牛顿力学跨入相对论）时，你觉得变的只是具体结论，还是连“什么问题才值得问、什么才算好解释”的评判标准也跟着换了？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"评判标准基本没变，科学发展主要就是发现的新事实越来越多、算得越来越准。","evidenceId":"T80.B"},{"id":"C","text":"评判标准可能会跟着变，但既然连尺子都可能换了，怎么证明新理论比旧理论“更进步”就得另外讲道理了。","evidenceId":"T80.C"},{"id":"A","text":"会一起改变。每个时代的科学都有自己的一套研究传统，连带影响了大家拿什么当典范、按什么标准打分。","evidenceId":"T80.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"科学与解释","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p58"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T81","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"描述感受，能帮助理解世界吗","prompt":"桌上有只杯子，你每次只能看到它的一个侧面，转一圈却仍认得它。有人研究“我们怎样看见这只杯子”，把“外面的杯子到底存不存在”这个问题搁在一边。你觉得这种研究有意义吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"有点用，主要能帮我分清哪些是亲眼所见、哪些是脑子自己补出来的判断。","evidenceId":"T81.C"},{"id":"A","text":"很有用。我想弄清，我们是怎样把零碎的印象认成一个完整事物的。","evidenceId":"T81.A"},{"id":"B","text":"作用有限。要弄清人怎么看见杯子，还是得靠物理光学和大脑视觉研究来给出实证解释。","evidenceId":"T81.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p59"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T82","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"观察世界，还是生活在其中","prompt":"有人觉得人就像坐在屏幕前看世界的观众，有人觉得人从一开始就泡在生活里。你怎么看“我”和“世界”的关系？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"我首先是个在生活里干活、用工具、跟人打交道的人，不是置身事外的看客。","evidenceId":"T82.A"},{"id":"B","text":"最核心的还是我的心灵怎样去认识、看清外面的客观事物。","evidenceId":"T82.B"},{"id":"C","text":"说穿了，我的身体也是自然界的一件物体，无非是在跟其他物体发生物理作用。","evidenceId":"T82.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p60","source_p64"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T83","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"角色能替你负责吗","prompt":"有人说：“我只是照着自己的身份做事，没什么可选择的。”你更接近哪一种看法？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"如果角色规定得足够清楚，责任主要在制度。","evidenceId":"T83.B"},{"id":"C","text":"只有他当时真的能作出别的选择，才谈得上让他负责。","evidenceId":"T83.C"},{"id":"A","text":"身份和处境会限制选择，但他仍需要说明自己为什么这样做，并承担责任。","evidenceId":"T83.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p62","source_p67"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T84","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"被允许就够了吗","prompt":"规则允许所有人选择职业，但一些人从小被教育成“不适合这样活”。他们已拥有同样的自由吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我会根据他们实际能过上怎样的生活来判断，他们内心怎样看待自己，不是这里的关键。","evidenceId":"T84.C"},{"id":"A","text":"没有，成长环境和别人贴的标签，会影响他们实际能作出什么选择。","evidenceId":"T84.A"},{"id":"B","text":"有了，选择权相同，内心障碍是另一个问题。","evidenceId":"T84.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p33","source_p62","source_p70","source_p72"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T85","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"找不到最终意义，怎样生活","prompt":"如果宇宙本来就是冷冰冰的，根本不在乎人类活得有没有意义，你打算怎么过这一生？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"认清没有终极答案的事实，但依然热气腾腾地活着，护好眼前的人和事。","evidenceId":"T85.A"},{"id":"B","text":"继续寻找那个能安放灵魂、给我终极解答的信仰。","evidenceId":"T85.B"},{"id":"C","text":"那确实没啥好执着的了，怎么舒服怎么来，活在当下的感觉里就好。","evidenceId":"T85.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p63","source_p42"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T86","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"理解能摆脱自己的时代吗","prompt":"解释一本古书时，你能完全放下自己的时代、语言和已有看法吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"应该尽量把自己脑子里的现代成见清空，回到古人的语境里去还原那个唯一正确的原意。","evidenceId":"T86.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更关心把几种不同的解读摆在一起，比比看它们各自能说通书里的哪些细节。","evidenceId":"T86.C"},{"id":"A","text":"完全放下是不可能的，但带着自己的背景去跟古书碰撞，反而能照见并修正我原本习以为常的成见。","evidenceId":"T86.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p65","source_p60"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T87","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"没答应过，也有责任吗","prompt":"路遇一个素不相识的人陷入绝境，你明明从没答应过要管他，心里却觉得“我不能见死不救”。这份责任感是从哪儿冒出来的？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"因为算下来搭把手花不了多少工夫，却能救人一命，这笔账很值。","evidenceId":"T87.C"},{"id":"A","text":"就在对上他无助眼神的那一刻——看见他的苦难本身，就已经让我没法装作事不关己。","evidenceId":"T87.A"},{"id":"B","text":"只有明确写进普遍道德准则、或者我亲口答应过的事，才算我真正的责任。","evidenceId":"T87.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p66"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T88","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"政治只是管好事情吗","prompt":"如果一个社会管理高效、人人生活稳定，却几乎没有共同讨论和发起行动的空间，它缺少重要东西吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"缺了很重要的东西。人不能只当被照顾好的居民，能公开发声、和大家一起做成点事，本身就是自由的一部分。","evidenceId":"T88.A"},{"id":"B","text":"不觉得缺什么。能把公共事务打理得井井有条、让大家安居乐业，就已经尽到政治最大的本分了。","evidenceId":"T88.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我最在意的是，上面别来插手我自己的私人日子；有没有一起议事的广场，对我没那么要紧。","evidenceId":"T88.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p67","source_p32"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T89","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"复制改变了什么","prompt":"一幅以前只能去现场看的画，现在随时能在手机上看。这会改变你和这幅画的关系吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"没什么根本变化。只是看画的渠道变了，画本身的构图、色彩和内容还在那里。","evidenceId":"T89.B"},{"id":"C","text":"比起看画的感觉，我更关心这会让创作者被更多人看到、多一份收入，还是反而更难靠作品谋生。","evidenceId":"T89.C"},{"id":"A","text":"变了很多。在手机上随手划过，和站在原作面前细看完全是两回事；看画的方式和原作留下的历史气息，本来就是体验的一部分。","evidenceId":"T89.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p68"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T90","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"大家喜欢，是自然的吗","prompt":"热门影视和短视频总是套着差不多的爽点公式，但大众也确实爱看、乐在其中。你怎么看这种现象？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我只就作品论作品，单看它本身拍得好不好、用不用心，就够我打分了。","evidenceId":"T90.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我会警惕：是不是因为流水线天天喂我们吃同一套东西，才把我们的胃口驯化得只会喜欢它、连别的可能都想不出来了？","evidenceId":"T90.A"},{"id":"B","text":"能让这么多普通人真心喜欢、愿意反复看，这本身就说明了它的价值。","evidenceId":"T90.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p69","source_p70","source_p68"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T91","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"满意也可能不自由吗","prompt":"一个人很满意现有生活，却从来没有机会想象其他活法。这可能仍是自由的问题吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"可能算是自由受限。如果一个人连“还能想要什么”都被眼界锁死了，光觉得满意还谈不上真自由。","evidenceId":"T91.A"},{"id":"B","text":"谈不上不自由。只要日子是他自己满意的，外头又没人逼他，这就够了。","evidenceId":"T91.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更关心他实际上有没有免于匮乏和恐惧的保障，至于人的喜好是怎么被环境熏陶出来的，我没那么在意。","evidenceId":"T91.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自由与责任","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p69","source_p70","source_p32","source_p40","source_p62","source_p72"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T92","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"怎样的同意有分量","prompt":"一项规则得到大家赞同。什么最能说明它值得被接受？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"只要赞成的人够多，我就觉得这条规则可以接受。","evidenceId":"T92.B"},{"id":"C","text":"关键看懂行的专家有没有算出它确实管用，大家讨不讨论没那么要紧。","evidenceId":"T92.C"},{"id":"A","text":"得看受影响的人当时能不能平等说话、大胆质疑并得到认真回应，而不是碍于压力才点头。","evidenceId":"T92.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p71","source_p48"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T93","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"H","title":"正常是谁定的","prompt":"学校、医院等制度把某些行为称为正常、另一些称为异常。你更想追问什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这种分类能否帮助当事人，对我比它的来历更重要。","evidenceId":"T93.C"},{"id":"A","text":"这些分类从何而来，又怎样影响人们看待自己、要求自己改变。","evidenceId":"T93.A"},{"id":"B","text":"分类是否准确反映了本来就存在的自然差异。","evidenceId":"T93.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"历史与社会","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p72"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T94","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"对立的两个概念能彻底分开吗","prompt":"人们常把“理性”和“感性”摆在对立面，觉得理性清醒高级、感性只会添乱，必须靠理性把情感撇干净。你怎么看这种非此即彼的对立？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"我怀疑它们根本切不开——所谓纯粹的理性，往往正需要借用它所排斥的感性，才能说明自己是什么。","evidenceId":"T94.A"},{"id":"B","text":"确实应该把理性和感性的界限划清楚，各自是什么意思、在起什么作用，都得分明。","evidenceId":"T94.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不用在抽象概念上较劲，看大家在日常生活里具体怎么用这两个词就明白了。","evidenceId":"T94.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p73"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T95","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"一件新事物，怎样理解它","prompt":"当生活里冒出一种前所未有的新鲜事物（比如一种全新的艺术或活法）时，你第一反应会怎么去理解它？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"我会把它放进已有的类别和框架里理解。","evidenceId":"T95.B"},{"id":"C","text":"找找它跟以前见过的哪个老东西最像。","evidenceId":"T95.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不急着拿老框框去套它，看它怎么跟周围碰撞、长出以前从没见过的新东西。","evidenceId":"T95.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p74","source_p49"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T96","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"不知道自己会出生在哪里","prompt":"制定社会规则时，假设你不知道自己的出身、能力和地位。你更愿意保障什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"让整个社会的总体福祉达到最大，即使有些人可能因此承担较大的损失。","evidenceId":"T96.C"},{"id":"A","text":"先保住人人都有的基本自由和公平起点；就算允许拉开收入差距，也得让境遇最差的人跟着受益。","evidenceId":"T96.A"},{"id":"B","text":"只管定好规矩：只要钱来得干净、买卖出于自愿就受保护，不提前干预最后谁多谁少。","evidenceId":"T96.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p75","source_p76"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T97","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"分配公平看结果还是过程","prompt":"一位歌手靠大家自愿买票成了富翁，没有欺骗，也没有侵占别人的财产。他的财富远多于普通人。你怎样看这种差距？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"只要所得和交易正当，贫富有差距也可以是公平的。","evidenceId":"T97.A"},{"id":"B","text":"还要考虑社会制度有没有改善处境最困难者的生活。","evidenceId":"T97.B"},{"id":"C","text":"即使交易自愿，也应限制过大的差距，免得财富带来过大的支配权。","evidenceId":"T97.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p76","source_p75"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T98","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"礼节只是外壳吗","prompt":"问候、祭念、待人接物的礼节，对人的品格能有什么作用？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"这些礼节主要是外在形式，我更重视真诚的感受。","evidenceId":"T98.B"},{"id":"C","text":"规矩和赏罚定清楚就行，不必指望每个人都有好品格。","evidenceId":"T98.C"},{"id":"A","text":"恰当地练习这些礼节，能让人学会关怀、尊重，以及与人相处的分寸。","evidenceId":"T98.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p77","source_p79","source_p85","source_p83"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T99","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"善意从哪里长出来","prompt":"你看到一个陌生孩子陷入危险，还没来得及盘算就担心起来。你会怎样理解这份自然产生的关心？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"这主要是进化形成的反应，仅凭这种反应，还不能确定道德的根据。","evidenceId":"T99.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它可以进一步培养，成为稳定的道德感。","evidenceId":"T99.A"},{"id":"B","text":"只是短暂冲动，可靠的善更依赖后天学习和规范。","evidenceId":"T99.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p78","source_p79"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T100","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"怎样安排人的欲望","prompt":"一个新社团没有章程，各人凭喜好行事，渐渐有人占便宜、有人退出。你更愿意怎样改善？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"一起学习待人处事的规矩，让成员逐渐养成合宜的行为习惯。","evidenceId":"T100.A"},{"id":"B","text":"减少约束，给成员更多空间，让互助和善意自然发展。","evidenceId":"T100.B"},{"id":"C","text":"把合作的收益和违约的代价讲清，让成员能按自己的利益作选择。","evidenceId":"T100.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p79","source_p83"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T101","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"远近会改变关切吗","prompt":"在讨论赈灾或公共救助时，远方的陌生人和你身边的乡亲受着同样的苦。你觉得资源该怎么倾斜？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"人情有远近，紧着自己人和身边人先帮，天经地义。","evidenceId":"T101.B"},{"id":"C","text":"得看做这件事的人，长远能得到什么回报。","evidenceId":"T101.C"},{"id":"A","text":"天底下受的苦没有远近之分，不能因为对方是外人就不当回事。","evidenceId":"T101.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p80"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T102","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"规矩越多，越好管吗","prompt":"邻居原本轮流协调停车。物业增加了十几条规定后，有人更守规矩，也有人钻空子，纠纷仍然不少。你更愿意怎么做？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"找大家信得过的人协调，比起规则数量，处理纠纷的人更关键。","evidenceId":"T102.C"},{"id":"A","text":"减少不必要的规定，让邻居有更多自行协调的空间。","evidenceId":"T102.A"},{"id":"B","text":"检查现有规则哪里不清楚、执行哪里不一致，再有针对性地调整。","evidenceId":"T102.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p81","source_p84"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T103","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"换个视角看高下","prompt":"你一直觉得稳定体面的工作才算好生活，却遇到一位在山里种地的朋友。他说，你看重的那些东西对他只是负担。你会怎样想？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"这让我怀疑，自己评判好生活的标准，是不是只适合某些处境。","evidenceId":"T103.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我还是想找到一个在任何处境下都成立的最高标准，来衡量哪种生活更好。","evidenceId":"T103.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我接受不同视角各有自己的判断，不想再评价哪种生活更好。","evidenceId":"T103.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p82"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T104","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"不靠好人的制度","prompt":"要把一个团队或社会管好，你觉得最靠得住的根基是什么？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"靠带头人的品德修养和以身作则，感化大家自愿向善。","evidenceId":"T104.B"},{"id":"C","text":"靠大家平时坐下来平等商量、共同拿主意。","evidenceId":"T104.C"},{"id":"A","text":"靠把权责、考核和赏罚写清楚的明文制度，不能只把希望押在当家人是不是“大好人”上。","evidenceId":"T104.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p83","source_p21","source_p24","source_p30","source_p77","source_p78"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T105","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"抓住字句，还是抓住意思","prompt":"读懂一段经典之后，应该怎样看待原来的字句和它想表达的意思？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"读者赋予的意义更重要，可以不受作者原意的限制。","evidenceId":"T105.C"},{"id":"A","text":"字句帮助我们理解意思；如果只盯着字面，反而可能错过作者想说的。","evidenceId":"T105.A"},{"id":"B","text":"尽量贴着字句读，离开字面的解释往往不可靠。","evidenceId":"T105.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p84","source_p65","source_p73"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T106","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"没有具体形状，就是什么都没有吗","prompt":"有人说：“能做成器皿的泥巴都有固定形状，但托起世间万物的最深根源，反而必须没有任何具体形状和限制。”你怎么看？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"有道理。正因为它自己不占任何固定的形状，才能让千姿百态的事物从中生长出来。","evidenceId":"T106.A"},{"id":"B","text":"说不通。万物的源头自己也得是个实实在在的东西，不能拿“无形”来当答案。","evidenceId":"T106.B"},{"id":"C","text":"具体事物之间怎么互相影响就已经能说清世界了，不必去追问什么无形的源头。","evidenceId":"T106.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p13","source_p84","source_p81","source_p88"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T107","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"求知怎样改变自己","prompt":"“把天下事物的道理研究透”和“管好自己的言行做个好人”，这两件事在你看来是什么关系？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"世间万物的道理可以慢慢研究，眼下最要紧的是把心里已经明白的良知落实在行动上。","evidenceId":"T107.B"},{"id":"C","text":"学问渊博和人品端正是两码事，懂再多客观规律也不见得能让人变好。","evidenceId":"T107.C"},{"id":"A","text":"沉下心去一件件摸清世事的条理，心里透亮了，做人做事自然也就知道分寸了。","evidenceId":"T107.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p85","source_p86"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T109","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"有不变的我在里面吗","prompt":"你的身体每时每刻都在新陈代谢，念头和情绪也像流水一样换个不停。在这背后，真的藏着一个永远不变、统领一切的“自我”吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"背后并没有一个固定不变的“我”，这一连串前后相续的身心变化过程，就已经是全部了。","evidenceId":"T109.A"},{"id":"B","text":"肯定有。要是没有一个不变的“我”穿起这一切，怎么解释这些事都发生在我一个人身上？","evidenceId":"T109.B"},{"id":"C","text":"“什么才算同一个人”我还没想明白，对这个结论我拿不准。","evidenceId":"T109.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p87","source_p88","source_p89","source_p90","source_p29"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T110","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"抓得更紧就更安稳吗","prompt":"面对那些早晚会变、注定留不住的人或东西，你心里通常是哪种态度？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"能留多久留多久，尽量把局面控制在自己手里才踏实。","evidenceId":"T110.B"},{"id":"C","text":"干脆一开始就别太走心，不动感情就不会受伤。","evidenceId":"T110.C"},{"id":"A","text":"坦然接受聚散无常，看清“死抓着不放”是怎么折磨自己的，慢慢学会松手。","evidenceId":"T110.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"生活与意义","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p87","source_p38","source_p88","source_p89","source_p90"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T111","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"一棵树靠什么成为自己","prompt":"一棵树的生长离不开种子、土壤、水和阳光。除了这些条件，你认为它还需要一种不依赖任何条件、固定不变的本性吗？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我认可条件影响生长，对是否有这种本性还拿不准。","evidenceId":"T111.C"},{"id":"A","text":"不需要。它由相互依赖的条件形成，也因此能生长、变化、影响周围的事物。","evidenceId":"T111.A"},{"id":"B","text":"需要。条件影响它怎样生长，但它之所以是它自己，还要有一种固定的本性。","evidenceId":"T111.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p88","source_p87"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T112","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"解释世界，也需要条件吗","prompt":"有人用“万物都靠条件拼成，没有独立不变的本性”来拆解一切执念。那对于“万物皆无固定本性”这条道理本身，你怎么看？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"这条道理本身也是为了破除执念才借用的药方，药治好了病就该放下，不能把它又当成新的死教条。","evidenceId":"T112.A"},{"id":"B","text":"这条道理本身必须是绝对不动摇的终极真理，否则其他解释就全塌了。","evidenceId":"T112.B"},{"id":"C","text":"只要它能帮我看清具体问题就行，至于它自己算不算终极真理，我不纠结。","evidenceId":"T112.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p88"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T113","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"你看到的，怎样形成","prompt":"看一张第一眼像杂乱色块的图，别人点拨一句“里面有只狗”，图明明没变，你却瞬间看出一只狗来，再也回不去了。你怎么理解这件事？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"眼睛接受到的画面其实没变，变的是我脑子里事后对它的解读。","evidenceId":"T113.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更想把“眼睛第一下的原始感觉”和“脑子随后的判断”拆开研究，现在还不好说谁先谁后。","evidenceId":"T113.C"},{"id":"A","text":"人的记忆和认知从一开始就掺和在“看”里头了，我们看到的从来不是像相机一样原封不动的画面。","evidenceId":"T113.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p59","source_p89","source_p64"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T114","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"M","title":"梦境说明了什么","prompt":"做梦的时候，梦里的山川人物也显得无比真实、有头有尾。这事儿最让你感慨什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"说明人的感官经验很容易出错，哪怕当时觉得再逼真，也未必完全靠得住。","evidenceId":"T114.C"},{"id":"A","text":"哪怕一样东西在体验里再真切，我们也得追问：它是真在外头独立存在着，还是由心识和体验共同织出来的？","evidenceId":"T114.A"},{"id":"B","text":"梦终归只是梦，不能仅仅因为梦境逼真，就否定清醒时经历的现实世界。","evidenceId":"T114.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"意识与心灵","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p89"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T115","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"明白一定要按台阶来吗","prompt":"长期学习的人，某一刻突然看清自己一直执着的东西。这种直接领会重要吗？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"重要，领会不一定只是知识一点点累积，也可能改变整个看法。","evidenceId":"T115.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我更重视长期练习和逐步理解，突然想通往往也是积累的结果。","evidenceId":"T115.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更在意这种领会能否持久地改变行动。","evidenceId":"T115.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p90"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T116","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"修行离开日常吗","prompt":"一个人声称自己已经明白了修行的道理，但在吃饭、做事和待人上都没有体现。这算真正领会了吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"内心的觉悟是精神层面的事，不一定要拿日常琐事里的表现来检验。","evidenceId":"T116.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更看重他能不能把这份领悟条理清楚地讲明白，让别人也听得懂。","evidenceId":"T116.C"},{"id":"A","text":"真想通了的道理，一定会落在一蔬一饭、待人接物的行动里。我会拿他日常的表现来判断。","evidenceId":"T116.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p90","source_p86"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T117","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"哲学会妨碍信仰吗","prompt":"如果你信奉一种宗教，却遇到理性探究对它提出挑战，你更接近哪种想法？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"信仰归信仰，理性归理性，两边根本不相通。","evidenceId":"T117.C"},{"id":"A","text":"认真追问也可能是信仰要求我去做的事。","evidenceId":"T117.A"},{"id":"B","text":"理性可以探索其他问题，但信仰的核心应保留最终权威。","evidenceId":"T117.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p17","source_p18","source_p15"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T118","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"为什么都叫树","prompt":"松树和柳树长得完全不一样，我们却都管它们叫“树”。你觉得这个共同的名字凭什么能成立？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"因为人脑子会把相似的具体东西归成一类、起个总名号，用不着假设背后真藏着某种看不见的“共同本质”。","evidenceId":"T118.A"},{"id":"B","text":"因为它们确实共享着同一种真实的“树之本质”，名字指的就是这个本质。","evidenceId":"T118.B"},{"id":"C","text":"名字只是大家约定俗成的叫法，怎么归类顺手，全看当时说话的需要。","evidenceId":"T118.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p20"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T119","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"自然和心灵会来自同一种根源吗","prompt":"外面生机勃勃的自然界，和我们脑海里会思考、会感受的心灵，看起来完全不是一类东西。你觉得它们在根子上是什么关系？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"它们本来就是截然不同的两类存在。","evidenceId":"T119.B"},{"id":"C","text":"归根结底只有物质世界，所谓心灵无非是大脑和身体的物理活动。","evidenceId":"T119.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它们或许同出一源——是宇宙中同一种生长、演化的力量，在外显为自然，在内显为心灵。","evidenceId":"T119.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p36","source_p49"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T120","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"A","title":"创作只靠清楚的计划吗","prompt":"艺术家精心创作，作品里却出现了自己也没预料到的东西。你怎样看这些意外？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"成品能否打动人对我更重要，至于是否按原计划创作，我不太在意。","evidenceId":"T120.C"},{"id":"A","text":"它们可能是创作的重要部分，作品有时能表达出作者还没完全想清楚的东西。","evidenceId":"T120.A"},{"id":"B","text":"主要说明技巧还不够可控，理想的创作应尽量实现原定计划。","evidenceId":"T120.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"美与艺术","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p36"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T121","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"怎样看待宗教中的理想","prompt":"假如宗教里的神圣形象，确实寄托了人类对“大爱与智慧”的最高向往，那接下来我们最该怎么做？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"把投向天空的目光收回来，认识到爱与智慧本就是人自己的潜能，在人间好好相爱、踏实做事。","evidenceId":"T121.A"},{"id":"B","text":"更坚定地顺服那位超越人类的神圣源头——正因为标准高于凡人，人才能有所敬畏。","evidenceId":"T121.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更关心身边的人与人之间能不能好好相处，宗教怎么解释这些理想，对我没那么重要。","evidenceId":"T121.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p39"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T122","revision":3,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"只有自己知道的规则","prompt":"你在日记里自造一个词记录一种感受。每次都凭自己觉得“和上次一样”来判断是否用对，此外没有核对办法。你会相信这种判断吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"会，自己能认出这种感受就够了，用词不一定需要其他核对办法。","evidenceId":"T122.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我会看长期使用时，自己能否稳定地区分不同感受。","evidenceId":"T122.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我会怀疑，光觉得用对了，还分不清是真的用对还是自己记错了。","evidenceId":"T122.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p52","source_p50"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T123","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"有限的时间改变什么","prompt":"意识到生命终会结束，你会怎样看待自己正在过的生活？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"我原来的生活目标仍然成立，知道生命有限并不改变它们。","evidenceId":"T123.C"},{"id":"A","text":"更认真地决定自己要怎样生活，重新考虑一直跟着别人走的选择。","evidenceId":"T123.A"},{"id":"B","text":"更愿意享受眼前的生活，少为“我应该成为谁”烦恼。","evidenceId":"T123.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p60"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T124","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"S","title":"成为自己靠什么","prompt":"如果非要用一样东西来定义“你是个什么样的人”，你最认准哪一样？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"看我在现实牌局里怎么出牌——我做过的选择，决定了我是谁。","evidenceId":"T124.A"},{"id":"B","text":"看我骨子里稳定的脾气、秉性和本事，这比一时一事的选择更能代表我。","evidenceId":"T124.B"},{"id":"C","text":"看我生在什么样的群体、处在什么社会位置，以及和大家共同经历过什么。","evidenceId":"T124.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"自我与关系","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p60","source_p35","source_p37","source_p42","source_p61","source_p62","source_p64","source_p74"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T125","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"分类能把现实说尽吗","prompt":"一份报告把你熟悉的城市归为某种类型，并列出详细特征。你觉得，分类写得足够细，就能把这座城市的现实完整说明吗？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"原则上可以。只要把分类维度和定义打磨得足够精细，总能把现实严丝合缝地装进去。","evidenceId":"T125.B"},{"id":"C","text":"分类本来就是为了办事方便，只要能帮这份报告解决具体问题就行，犯不着指望它把现实说尽。","evidenceId":"T125.C"},{"id":"A","text":"永远不能。鲜活的具体生活里，总有那些分类框框装不下、甚至会被标签抹掉的毛边和矛盾。","evidenceId":"T125.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p69","source_p73","source_p74","source_p82"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T126","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"G","title":"解释一个词，能找到最后的起点吗","prompt":"查字典时，解释一个词总得用到别的词。你觉得语言底下有没有某种“终极词义”，不需要靠任何别的词对比，自己就能单独成立？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"在眼下的生活场景里能把话说明白就够用了，未必非得找到一个终极起点。","evidenceId":"T126.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我不太相信有这种起点。一个词的意思，往往得靠它和别的词怎么区分、怎么互相牵连才能显出来。","evidenceId":"T126.A"},{"id":"B","text":"肯定有。要是底下没有几个不靠别的词就能直接懂的根本意思，人连一句话都没法真正理解。","evidenceId":"T126.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"语言与理解","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p73","source_p52","source_p53"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T127","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"只劝人向善够吗","prompt":"许多人连基本生计都不稳定，治理者却主要要求他们提高道德。你更接近哪一种看法？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"连温饱都没着落时，光劝人向善是虚的，先让大家过上安稳日子才最紧要。","evidenceId":"T127.A"},{"id":"B","text":"越是艰难越得先把规矩和礼法立稳，吃饱穿暖的事，也得排在守规矩后面。","evidenceId":"T127.B"},{"id":"C","text":"生计和道德都该靠民间的自发互助来解决，管事的人少插手安排才好。","evidenceId":"T127.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p78"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T128","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"战争该怎样算账","prompt":"你生活的国家考虑主动出兵，预期获得资源和长期安全，却也会造成另一国平民伤亡。你会根据什么判断是否支持？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"我优先考虑本国的利益，即使别国付出更大代价，也可能值得支持。","evidenceId":"T128.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我要弄清是否真的在应对威胁、是否有防御需要，只比较双方得失还不够。","evidenceId":"T128.C"},{"id":"A","text":"本国获利还不够，他国承受的损害也应同等算进判断。","evidenceId":"T128.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p80"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T129","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"说得好，还是做到了","prompt":"考核官员时，你更愿意依靠什么？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"受其治理影响的人长期以来的信任程度和评价。","evidenceId":"T129.C"},{"id":"A","text":"把实际表现与职责、承诺核对，再按明确的制度赏罚。","evidenceId":"T129.A"},{"id":"B","text":"实际成绩需要考察，但品行和口碑更重要，再据此决定是否重用。","evidenceId":"T129.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p83"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T130","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"明知不妥，还在找借口","prompt":"发现自己明明觉得某件事不对，却仍在找借口去做，改进应从哪里开始？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"别再给自己找理由，就从眼前这件事改起。","evidenceId":"T130.A"},{"id":"B","text":"我的道德直觉也可能出错，应该核查它的理由再决定怎样行动。","evidenceId":"T130.B"},{"id":"C","text":"环境和习惯会影响行动，改变它们能让我更容易做到。","evidenceId":"T130.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p86"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"everyday"},{"id":"T131","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"W","title":"没有人看着时","prompt":"你离开房间后，相信桌子还在那里，但你认识桌子的证据都来自某种感知。你更愿意怎样理解“没人看时它还在”？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"桌子本来就实实在在地摆在那儿，存不存在跟有没有人感知它毫无关系。","evidenceId":"T131.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我只知道每次推门进去都能看到它，日常经验里它一直稳定出现；至于没人的时候是不是另有一位心灵始终在感知它，我不下定论。","evidenceId":"T131.C"},{"id":"A","text":"哪怕屋里没有凡人看着，也有一位无处不在的心灵（比如神）始终在感知万物，让桌子继续存在。","evidenceId":"T131.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"世界与存在","note":"原创情境；选择表示此处侧重的理由，不等于整套学说。人物侧解释见对应匹配档案。","sourceStatus":"议题与人物资料有条目级来源；情境到立场的映射为编辑推演，尚未通过量表效度检验。"},"sourceIds":["source_p28","source_p89"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；有来源时用于说明相关哲学问题","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"FP01","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"W","title":"宇宙的故事，从哪里讲起？","prompt":"一部纪录片从星球形成讲到生命出现，最后讲到人开始思考。导演说：“把前面的过程讲全，就能解释后面的一切。”你更接近哪种看法？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"大体赞同，思想也有它的来路，要从身体、生命和更早的自然过程里找。","evidenceId":"FP01.A"},{"id":"B","text":"顺序还可以反过来想：星球和身体都依赖意识而存在，意识才是更根本的。","evidenceId":"FP01.B"},{"id":"C","text":"身体和心灵是两种不同的存在，不能只用其中一种来解释另一种。","evidenceId":"FP01.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_idealism","source_p23","source_p04","source_p09","source_p28","source_p39"],"editorial":{"focus":"通过情境中的解释与取舍了解基本立场，再由专题细分","sourceRelation":"原创问题与编辑对应"}},{"id":"FP02","revision":2,"stage":"base","topic":"H","title":"小镇的人为什么变了？","prompt":"一座小镇从务农转向工厂生产。几代人后，大家对守时、家庭和成功的看法都变了。你更重视哪一种解释？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"学校、书籍和讨论带来了新思想，人们对好生活的理解发生改变，推动了工作和制度的变化。","evidenceId":"FP02.B"},{"id":"C","text":"工作、教育、制度可能相互影响，谁起主导作用需要结合具体的历史情况判断。","evidenceId":"FP02.C"},{"id":"A","text":"谋生方式、劳动和收入分配影响着人们怎样想，新想法也会反过来改变生活。","evidenceId":"FP02.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p37","source_p30","source_p41"],"editorial":{"focus":"通过情境中的解释与取舍了解基本立场，再由专题细分","sourceRelation":"原创问题与编辑对应"}},{"id":"FP03","revision":2,"stage":"base","topic":"C","title":"机器多了，谁来分这笔收入？","prompt":"一座城的工厂越来越自动化。产量上升，工人却越来越少，收入也越来越集中在少数所有者手中。长期来看，你更赞成怎样安排？","options":[{"id":"C","text":"只要工厂取得正当、交易自愿，收益就由所有者支配；缩小差距不足以成为强制分走收益的理由。","evidenceId":"FP03.C"},{"id":"A","text":"让这些工厂逐步由社会共同掌握，劳动者参与决定生产和收入分配，而不只领取工资。","evidenceId":"FP03.A"},{"id":"B","text":"工厂继续由私人经营，通过税收、公共服务和劳动保障，让更多人分享收益。","evidenceId":"FP03.B"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p75","source_p76","source_socialism","source_p32","source_p41"],"editorial":{"focus":"通过情境中的解释与取舍了解基本立场，再由专题细分","sourceRelation":"原创问题与编辑对应"}},{"id":"FP04","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"E","title":"两边都需要你","prompt":"你早早答应陪一位独居老人去医院，出门时却撞见另一边有一群人突发意外急需帮忙，两边都找不到别人顶替。必须二选一时，你心里的天平会怎么摆？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"算清楚哪边更危急、能帮到的人更多，选总体伤害最小的那头。","evidenceId":"FP04.A"},{"id":"B","text":"答应了老人的事就是契约，不能因为另一边人数多，就把许下的诺言直接作废。","evidenceId":"FP04.B"},{"id":"C","text":"没法死套公式，得看两边的具体处境，揣摩一个既重信义又懂变通的厚道人会怎么权衡。","evidenceId":"FP04.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p45","source_p34","source_p07","source_p44","source_p56","source_p80"],"editorial":{"focus":"通过情境中的解释与取舍了解基本立场，再由专题细分","sourceRelation":"原创问题与编辑对应"}},{"id":"FP05","revision":3,"stage":"base","topic":"R","title":"如果宇宙的来历都讲清了","prompt":"假设有一天，科学完整解释了宇宙如何演变，连最早的状态也有自然规律可以说明。关于这个世界为什么存在，你会怎样想？","options":[{"id":"B","text":"我认为没有创造者，世界及其规律本身就是起点。","evidenceId":"FP05.B"},{"id":"C","text":"世界怎样运行可以解释清楚，至于它是否被创造，我还拿不准。","evidenceId":"FP05.C"},{"id":"A","text":"我仍相信有一位创造者，规律说明世界怎样运行，创造者则是世界存在的根源。","evidenceId":"FP05.A"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_atheism"],"editorial":{"focus":"通过情境中的解释与取舍了解基本立场，再由专题细分","sourceRelation":"原创问题与编辑对应"}},{"id":"T132","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"K","title":"没得出结论，日子还过吗","prompt":"网上的道理公说公有理、婆说婆有理，很多宏大的争论你根本没法判断谁掌握了绝对真理。这时候日子该怎么过？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"我对哪派是终极真理不作判断，平日依靠冷暖饥饱的常识和习惯，也能把日子过下去。","evidenceId":"T132.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人做事总得有个主心骨，我会挑目前最靠谱的那套说法来指导生活。","evidenceId":"T132.B"},{"id":"C","text":"如果连日常经验为什么可靠都没弄清，我就很难放心依照它来生活。","evidenceId":"T132.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"知识与证据","note":"区分已有回答附近的另一项主张；与原有核心题共同用于人物比较。","sourceStatus":"已核对下列哲学资料；原创情境的选项对应为编辑解释。"},"sourceIds":["source_p12"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；资料用于说明相关理论","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T133","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"R","title":"苦难也是最好的安排吗","prompt":"一场大地震夺走了无数无辜者的性命，却有人在废墟旁感叹：“从宇宙全局来看，这一切依然是最好的安排。”你听完会怎么想？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"太冷酷也太敷衍了。拿轻飘飘的“全局最好”去粉饰活生生的惨剧，根本说服不了我。","evidenceId":"T133.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人眼界有限，眼前的惨痛或许真是维持更大秩序不得不付出的代价。","evidenceId":"T133.B"},{"id":"C","text":"灾难就是眼前的灾难，既证不出世界“已经最好”，也推不出宇宙“整体更坏”，不必往终极全局上引申。","evidenceId":"T133.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"信仰与终极问题","note":"区分已有回答附近的另一项主张；与原有核心题共同用于人物比较。","sourceStatus":"已核对下列哲学资料；原创情境的选项对应为编辑解释。"},"sourceIds":["source_p31","voltaire_lisbon","source_p27"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；资料用于说明相关理论","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T134","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"C","title":"能干的下属该掌握多少权力","prompt":"一位大臣很能干，也深受拥护。君主想让他自行决定其他官员的奖惩和任免。你更认同什么？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"不宜交出去，君主应自己掌握赏罚和任免，否则可能反被大臣控制。","evidenceId":"T134.A"},{"id":"B","text":"既然能干又受信任，就应给他充分的决定权，避免事事掣肘。","evidenceId":"T134.B"},{"id":"C","text":"不应由君主或大臣独占，受这些决定影响的人应能参与和监督。","evidenceId":"T134.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"公平与共同生活","note":"区分已有回答附近的另一项主张；与原有核心题共同用于人物比较。","sourceStatus":"已核对下列哲学资料；原创情境的选项对应为编辑解释。"},"sourceIds":["source_p83","source_p71"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；资料用于说明相关理论","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T135","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"P","title":"没学过道德，也能分清是非吗","prompt":"你没有系统学过道德理论，看到别人无故受辱，心里却已经觉得不对。你认为，自己这份判断主要从哪里来？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"人本来就能分辨一些是非，私心会让人忽视它。修养要把这份判断落实到行动。","evidenceId":"T135.A"},{"id":"B","text":"主要来自后天学习；还要研究事情的道理，才能知道这份判断是否正确。","evidenceId":"T135.B"},{"id":"C","text":"主要来自环境和习惯，需要像其他直觉一样接受检验。","evidenceId":"T135.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"修养与行动","note":"区分已有回答附近的另一项主张；与原有核心题共同用于人物比较。","sourceStatus":"已核对下列哲学资料；原创情境的选项对应为编辑解释。"},"sourceIds":["source_p86","source_p78","source_p79","source_p85"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；资料用于说明相关理论","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T136","revision":2,"stage":"deep","topic":"E","title":"为了未来，可以牺牲谁","prompt":"你们正在反抗不公的压迫，同伴却提出：“为了建成未来的理想社会，眼下可以有计划地牺牲一批无辜的人。”你会怎么回应？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"反抗也得有底线。绝不能拿虚无缥缈的未来，给今天杀害无辜者开绿灯。","evidenceId":"T136.A"},{"id":"B","text":"如果这真能结束更多人的苦难，那就得狠下心算算这笔代价值不值。","evidenceId":"T136.B"},{"id":"C","text":"我更关心是谁拍板做这个决定、权力和责任怎么监督，不能由几个人私下定生死。","evidenceId":"T136.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","editorial":{"focus":"道德与理由","note":"区分已有回答附近的另一项主张；与原有核心题共同用于人物比较。","sourceStatus":"已核对下列哲学资料；原创情境的选项对应为编辑解释。"},"sourceIds":["source_p63","source_p56","source_p66","source_p69"],"sourceRelation":"原创情境；资料用于说明相关理论","difficulty":"reflective"},{"id":"T137","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"V","title":"同样有证据，为什么还谈不拢","prompt":"两套科学理论都得到了不少证据支持，却一直争论不休。理解这种分歧时，哪一种说法最有说服力？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"任何一条结论背后都连着一整张信念网，证据检验的是这整张网，没法只拎出一句话定输赢。","evidenceId":"T137.A"},{"id":"B","text":"两派人马可能处在不同的研究传统里，连“什么问题最重要、怎样才算讲通了”的底子都不一样。","evidenceId":"T137.B"},{"id":"C","text":"关键得让双方亮出“出现什么结果就算我输”的预测，让不同主张接受公开的批评和检验。","evidenceId":"T137.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p54","source_p58","source_p57"],"sourceRelation":"人物论述侧重的编辑比较；选择表示更赞同的解释，非互斥命题判断","difficulty":"everyday","editorial":{"focus":"区分相近人物对共同问题的解释侧重","mapping":"comparative_emphasis"}},{"id":"T138","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"L","title":"一个人怎样成为自己","prompt":"到底是什么把你塑造成了今天这个样子？下面三种说法，你最认哪一种？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"是我一次次的选择和行动。哪怕客观环境再受限，怎么选也是我自己扛。","evidenceId":"T138.A"},{"id":"B","text":"人平时都在随波逐流，直到真正直面“生命有限、终有一死”，才会惊醒过来重选活法。","evidenceId":"T138.B"},{"id":"C","text":"人不是脱离肉体的纯精神，我的身体习惯、成长环境和身边的人，一点点共同塑造成了今天的我。","evidenceId":"T138.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p60","source_p64"],"sourceRelation":"人物论述侧重的编辑比较；选择表示更赞同的解释，非互斥命题判断","difficulty":"everyday","editorial":{"focus":"区分相近人物对共同问题的解释侧重","mapping":"comparative_emphasis"}},{"id":"T139","revision":1,"stage":"deep","topic":"F","title":"自由最需要说明什么","prompt":"都在喊“人要活得自由”，你觉得下面哪句话最切中要害？","options":[{"id":"A","text":"哪怕外面的处境再逼仄，人也仍得决定怎样回应，并替自己的行动担责。","evidenceId":"T139.A"},{"id":"B","text":"自由不能只闷在家里，人得能走到公共场合跟大家一起发声、一起做成新的事。","evidenceId":"T139.B"},{"id":"C","text":"要是连谋生手段都捏在别人手里，口头上的自由就是空的；人得摆脱受制于人的社会关系，真正掌握劳动和生活的条件。","evidenceId":"T139.C"}],"answerMode":"single_closest_reason","resultUse":"descriptive_evidence","sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p67","source_p40"],"sourceRelation":"人物论述侧重的编辑比较；选择表示更赞同的解释，非互斥命题判断","difficulty":"everyday","editorial":{"focus":"区分相近人物对共同问题的解释侧重","mapping":"comparative_emphasis"}}]},"philosophers":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","items":[{"id":"p01","name":"泰勒斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"亚里士多德等后世记载中的泰勒斯","matchScope":"自然解释与万物的来源","intro":"早期自然解释传统；自然与本原","caution":"题目只能建立很弱的自然解释联系，不能据此推断用户赞成“水是本原”；文献多为后世记载","reading":{"title":"《形而上学》卷一中关于泰勒斯的记载","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/presocratics/"},"sourceIds":["source_p01"],"matchLabel":"在这些问题的思路上接近","claims":[{"id":"p01_c1","questionId":"T01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"事物发生的原因，应当从自然本身去寻找。","sourceIds":["source_p01"],"locator":"亚里士多德等后世记载中的泰勒斯","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p01_c2","questionId":"T02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"千差万别的事物，可以用同一种最基本的自然材料来解释。","sourceIds":["source_p01"],"locator":"亚里士多德等后世记载中的泰勒斯","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p01_cross_T37","questionId":"T37","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然现象可以从自然自身的原因解释。","sourceIds":["source_p01"],"locator":"自然解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p01","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"万物有共同的自然来源，可以从自然本身寻找解释。"},{"id":"p02","name":"赫拉克利特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"残篇中的变化、对立与秩序","matchScope":"变化中的秩序","intro":"变化、秩序与对立关系","caution":"不以一句“万物流变”概括全部思想；需要残篇语境","reading":{"title":"赫拉克利特残篇选读","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heraclitus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p02"],"matchLabel":"在这些问题的思路上接近","claims":[{"id":"p02_c1","questionId":"T03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"相反的力量也能维持一个整体，就像弓身与弦之间的拉力。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"残篇中的变化、对立与秩序","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p02_c2","questionId":"T04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"事物虽然变化，变化仍可以有可理解的规律。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"残篇中的变化、对立与秩序","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p02_c3","questionId":"W03","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"可以从持续变化的过程，理解事物如何保持自身的延续。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"残篇中的变化、对立与秩序","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p02_cross_T05","questionId":"T05","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"变化是世界的实际特征，不能因抽象推论而取消它。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"变化与逻各斯","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p02_cross_T02","questionId":"T02","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解世界需要把关系和变化本身纳入解释。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"流变","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p02_cross_T37","questionId":"T37","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"世界秩序可以由自然自身的运行来理解。","sourceIds":["source_p02"],"locator":"宇宙秩序","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p02","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"世界不断变化，对立的力量也能共同维持秩序。"},{"id":"p03","name":"巴门尼德","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"诗篇真理道路的存在论论证","matchScope":"推理与不变的存在","intro":"存在、思想与感官经验的经典冲突","caution":"不能用普通的“相信理性”直接判定其存在论立场","reading":{"title":"《论自然》残篇","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/parmenides/"},"sourceIds":["source_p03"],"matchLabel":"在这些问题的思路上接近","claims":[{"id":"p03_c1","questionId":"T05","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"当感官与严密推理冲突时，更相信推理。","sourceIds":["source_p03"],"locator":"诗篇真理道路的存在论论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p03_c2","questionId":"T04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"可靠的知识应当认识真正存在、不会变来变去的对象。","sourceIds":["source_p03"],"locator":"诗篇真理道路的存在论论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p03_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性论证能够纠正感官表象给出的存在判断。","sourceIds":["source_p03"],"locator":"真理之路与意见之路","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p03","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"真正的存在不生不灭，感官中的变化需要接受理性的检验。"},{"id":"p04","name":"德谟克利特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"古代原子论的自然解释","matchScope":"构成、排列与感觉","intro":"古代原子论的重要代表","caution":"不把古代原子论等同现代物理学或现代心灵物理主义","reading":{"title":"德谟克利特残篇与古代原子论资料","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/democritus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p04"],"matchLabel":"在这些问题的思路上接近","claims":[{"id":"p04_c1","questionId":"T06","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"颜色、味道等感觉可以从原子的形状、排列和运动来解释。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"古代原子论的自然解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p04_c2","questionId":"T07","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然中的复杂事物可以用基本成分及其运动解释。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"古代原子论的自然解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p04_c3","questionId":"T01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然现象的原因可以从自然内部寻找。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"古代原子论的自然解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p04_cross_FP01","questionId":"FP01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生命和心灵也属于自然过程。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"原子与灵魂","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p04_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"灵魂活动需要由自然中的物质构成解释。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"灵魂的原子论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p04_cross_W01","questionId":"W01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然物的存在不依赖个体是否正在感知它。","sourceIds":["source_p04"],"locator":"原子与虚空","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p04","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"世界由原子和虚空构成，事物的差异来自原子的排列与运动。"},{"id":"p05","name":"苏格拉底","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"柏拉图早期对话中的苏格拉底形象","matchScope":"反省、品格与行动","intro":"反省、德性与哲学生活的核心人物","caution":"必须说明采用何种文献中的苏格拉底形象，不混同全部柏拉图理论","reading":{"title":"《申辩》《拉凯斯》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/socrates/"},"sourceIds":["source_p05","source_p06"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p05_c1","questionId":"T08","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个人值得认真检查自己相信什么、为什么这样生活。","sourceIds":["source_p05"],"locator":"柏拉图早期对话中的苏格拉底形象","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p05_c2","questionId":"T09","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"承认自己还没弄懂，才能和别人继续探讨。","sourceIds":["source_p05"],"locator":"柏拉图早期对话中的苏格拉底形象","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p05_c3","questionId":"P01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"真正认识到什么是善，会影响人怎样行动。","sourceIds":["source_p05","source_p06"],"locator":"柏拉图早期对话中的苏格拉底形象","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p05_cross_T14","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"品格是否正直，比财富与声望更根本。","sourceIds":["source_p05"],"locator":"《申辩篇》《克里同篇》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p05_cross_T43","questionId":"T43","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德探究需要辨明理由，不能仅以当下感受作结。","sourceIds":["source_p05"],"locator":"德性与知识","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p05_cross_Q07","questionId":"Q07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"好的生活有值得理性追问的标准。","sourceIds":["source_p05"],"locator":"照料灵魂","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p05","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"不断追问那些看似理所当然的信念，在对话与省察中检验人应当怎样生活。"},{"id":"p06","name":"柏拉图","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《理想国》等中期对话的知识与价值问题","matchScope":"知识与价值的标准","intro":"理念、知识、正义与灵魂","caution":"不将所有对话人物台词都当作者定论；必要时按对话或时期限定","reading":{"title":"《理想国》中的善与知识讨论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plato-ethics/"},"sourceIds":["source_p06"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p06_c1","questionId":"T04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"知识需要稳定的对象，不能只停在眼前不断变化的事物上。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"《理想国》等中期对话的知识与价值问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p06_c2","questionId":"Q07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一件事是否有价值，不完全由个人喜欢什么决定。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"《理想国》等中期对话的知识与价值问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p06_c3","questionId":"L02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有些事本身值得追求，即使没人喜欢它。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"《理想国》等中期对话的知识与价值问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p06_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性能够获得超出感官经验的认识。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"知识与善","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p06_cross_T28","questionId":"T28","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"具体事物的共同性质需要由真实的形式解释。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"形式论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p06_cross_T14","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"正义与灵魂的良好秩序值得为其自身追求。","sourceIds":["source_p06"],"locator":"《理想国》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p06","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"具体事物之外，有稳定的理念作为知识与价值的标准。"},{"id":"p07","name":"亚里士多德","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《尼各马可伦理学》与自然哲学","matchScope":"品格、判断与生命的解释","intro":"德性、实践智慧、目的与人的实现","caution":"不因用户重视习惯或“适度”就赋予完整德性伦理体系","reading":{"title":"《尼各马可伦理学》第二、六卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-ethics/"},"sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p07_nature"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p07_c1","questionId":"T10","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"好的判断需要经验，也需要在眼前的具体情况中拿捏分寸。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"《尼各马可伦理学》的实践伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p07_c2","questionId":"T11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"好的生活需要把人的能力用于值得做的活动。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"《尼各马可伦理学》的实践伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p07_c3","questionId":"P01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"反复实践才能养成好习惯，使人稳定地做对的事。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"《尼各马可伦理学》的实践伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p07_c4","questionId":"FP04","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"面对具体困境，需要凭借养成的品格、经验和实践智慧作判断。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"《尼各马可伦理学》第六卷的实践智慧","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p07_c5","questionId":"T07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释生命的生长，既需要了解物质，也需要说明整体的组织和功能。","sourceIds":["source_p07_nature"],"locator":"《物理学》第二卷；《动物的部分》第一卷","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p07_cross_L02","questionId":"L02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人的良好活动有超出个人偏好的价值。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"幸福与功能论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p07_cross_P02","questionId":"P02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"品格需要通过反复实践逐渐养成。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"习惯与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p07_cross_T43","questionId":"T43","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"实践理性参与判断什么值得做。","sourceIds":["source_p07"],"locator":"实践智慧","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p07","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"好生活离不开实践中养成的品格；理解生命则要追问整体的组织与功能。"},{"id":"p08","name":"第欧根尼（犬儒学派）","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"古代犬儒生活实践的传述","matchScope":"简单生活与摆脱名利","intro":"犬儒生活实践与对社会惯例的挑战","caution":"不把现代玩世不恭、自私或网络嘲讽等同古代犬儒主义","reading":{"title":"第欧根尼的古代传述及犬儒主义导论","url":"https://iep.utm.edu/cynics/"},"sourceIds":["source_p08"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p08_c1","questionId":"T12","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人应当减少对名声和社会排场的依赖，才能活得自在。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"古代犬儒生活实践的传述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p08_c2","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"生活越简单，就越不容易受外在条件摆布。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"古代犬儒生活实践的传述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p08_c3","questionId":"T08","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自己怎样生活，也值得认真检查。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"古代犬儒生活实践的传述","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p08_cross_T14","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"外在财富和名望不能取代德性。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"德性与自足","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p08_cross_P04","questionId":"P04","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"减少对声誉的依赖，才能摆脱不必要的束缚。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"自由与自足","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p08_cross_Q07","questionId":"Q07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"值得过的生活不能完全由当下偏好决定。","sourceIds":["source_p08"],"locator":"自然与习俗","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p08","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"看轻世俗的体面、名利与繁文缛节，用极简的生活守住赤诚与自由。"},{"id":"p09","name":"伊壁鸠鲁","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《致美诺伊克斯书》与主要教说","matchScope":"快乐、安宁与欲望","intro":"快乐、欲望、安宁与死亡","caution":"不等同纵欲；不能只因“喜欢快乐”即匹配","reading":{"title":"《致美诺伊克斯书》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epicurus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p09"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p09_c1","questionId":"T11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"生活的快乐包括身体少受痛苦、心中安宁，以及可靠的友谊。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"《致美诺伊克斯书》与主要教说","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p09_c2","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"辨别真正必要的需要与无止境的虚荣欲望，才能获得心灵的安宁。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"《致美诺伊克斯书》与主要教说","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p09_c3","questionId":"L02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"用快乐和痛苦判断生活过得好不好；安宁也属于快乐。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"《致美诺伊克斯书》与主要教说","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p09_cross_T14","questionId":"T14","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"德性的价值与愉快、安宁的生活相连。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"德性与快乐","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p09_cross_FP01","questionId":"FP01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"身心都属于自然，不需要诉诸超自然的灵魂。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"原子论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p09_cross_T37","questionId":"T37","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然变化无需用神意的安排解释。","sourceIds":["source_p09"],"locator":"自然与神","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p09","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"辨别真正需要的欲望，减少痛苦和恐惧，获得安宁的快乐。"},{"id":"p10","name":"爱比克泰德","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《论说集》《手册》的实践教导","matchScope":"判断与可掌握之事","intro":"选择能力、判断与外部境遇","caution":"不把斯多亚主义简化为压抑情绪或放弃改变社会","reading":{"title":"《手册》第一节起","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epictetus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p10"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p10_c1","questionId":"P04","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人只该对自己的判断和行动负责，至于别人的评价和外部结果，本来就不由我们控制。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"《论说集》《手册》的实践教导","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p10_c2","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个人怎样判断和行动，比能否获利或赢得名声更重要。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"《论说集》《手册》的实践教导","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p10_c3","questionId":"T11","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"恰当的判断与选择，比外部得失更能决定生活的好坏。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"《论说集》《手册》的实践教导","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p10_cross_L02","questionId":"L02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"德性有不取决于个人偏好的价值。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"价值与选择","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p10_cross_T08","questionId":"T08","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"反省自己的判断是修养的一部分。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"正确运用印象","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p10_cross_T15","questionId":"T15","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"与他人的关系也带来需要承担的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p10"],"locator":"适当行为","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p10","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"分清自己能掌握什么，把心力放在判断和行动上。"},{"id":"p11","name":"马可·奥勒留","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《沉思录》的斯多亚实践","matchScope":"内在判断与共同责任","intro":"广为人知的斯多亚实践与共同体责任","caution":"不与爱比克泰德复制成两个相同档案；资料不足时不能强分高下","reading":{"title":"《沉思录》关于共同体与日常实践的段落","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marcus-aurelius/"},"sourceIds":["source_p11"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p11_c1","questionId":"T15","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人与人需要合作，因此有责任关心共同生活。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"《沉思录》的斯多亚实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p11_c2","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"正直的价值不能只用快乐和名声衡量。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"《沉思录》的斯多亚实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p11_c3","questionId":"P04","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自己的判断由自己负责，别人怎样评价则无法完全控制。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"《沉思录》的斯多亚实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p11_cross_T11","questionId":"T11","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"良好品格不以外在的快乐和得失为标准。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"德性与外物","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p11_cross_T08","questionId":"T08","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不断检省自己的判断，有助于过好生活。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"《沉思录》的练习","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p11_cross_T13","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"减少无止境的欲望，使行动摆脱外在牵制。","sourceIds":["source_p11"],"locator":"欲望与自然","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p11","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"以理性面对变化，在共同生活中承担自己的责任。"},{"id":"p12","name":"塞克斯都·恩披里柯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"皮浪主义纲要的悬置判断","matchScope":"怀疑与日常生活","intro":"古代怀疑主义的关键文献代表","caution":"不将悬置判断等同“没有真理”或“什么都不相信”","reading":{"title":"《皮浪主义纲要》第一卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism-ancient/"},"sourceIds":["source_p12"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p12_c1","questionId":"T16","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"当双方理由难分高下时，可以暂时既不肯定也不否定。","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"locator":"皮浪主义纲要的悬置判断","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p12_c2","questionId":"K01","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对论证尚存疑问时，可以继续考察各方前提，对结论保留判断。","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"locator":"皮浪主义纲要的悬置判断","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p12_c3","questionId":"T132","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"关于事物本性的争论尚无定论，日常生活仍能依照感受、经验与习惯继续。","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"locator":"皮浪主义纲要的悬置判断","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p12_cross_T05","questionId":"T05","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"遇到难分高下的论证，不急于断言哪一方揭示了实在。","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"locator":"悬置判断","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p12","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"当相反的理由难分高下时，暂缓判断，仍可照常生活。"},{"id":"p13","name":"普罗提诺","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"古希腊与晚期古代","scope":"《九章集》中关于万物根源的论述","matchScope":"万物为何有共同根源","intro":"新柏拉图主义与晚期古代的重要承接者","caution":"只认同统一性不足以推出“一者”及流溢体系","reading":{"title":"《九章集》论一者与善","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plotinus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p13"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p13_c1","questionId":"T17","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"多样的事物最终依赖一个本身不再由不同部分组成的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"《九章集》的统一根源与返回","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p13_c2","questionId":"T106","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"万物的根源可以超出具体事物的形状。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"《九章集》的统一根源与返回","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p13_c3","questionId":"T18","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"反省自己的心灵，有助于认识超出个人欲望的真理与善。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"《九章集》的统一根源与返回","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p13_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理智能够通达超出感官经验的存在。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"理智与一者","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p13_cross_W04","questionId":"W04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"具体存在依赖更根本的统一来源。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"一者与流溢","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p13_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"灵魂不能归结为身体的物质组成。","sourceIds":["source_p13"],"locator":"灵魂与身体","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p13","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"万物来自共同的根源，心灵可以通过反省接近这一根源。"},{"id":"p14","name":"奥古斯丁","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"《忏悔录》等关于反省内心与恶的讨论","matchScope":"反省内心与恶的来源","intro":"意志、恶、内在性与信仰","caution":"不因内省或重视意志就推断信仰与神学立场","reading":{"title":"《忏悔录》第七卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/augustine/"},"sourceIds":["source_p14"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p14_c1","questionId":"T19","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"恶是原本应有的善受到损害或缺失。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"《忏悔录》等关于内在性与恶的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p14_c2","questionId":"T18","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"向内反省，可以认识不随个人喜好改变的真理与善。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"《忏悔录》等关于内在性与恶的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p14_c3","questionId":"T21","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人可以在信仰中继续寻找理由、增进理解。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"《忏悔录》等关于内在性与恶的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p14_cross_R02","questionId":"R02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"内在经验和信仰可以参与寻求真理。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"信仰与内在性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p14_cross_W04","questionId":"W04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"受造世界依赖更根本的存在。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"创造论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p14_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"灵魂不能归结为身体。","sourceIds":["source_p14"],"locator":"灵魂","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p14","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"恶是善的缺失，人的意志需要在信仰中重新找到方向。"},{"id":"p15","name":"安瑟尔谟","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"《宣讲篇》与信仰寻求理解","matchScope":"信仰与上帝存在的论证","intro":"信仰与理解、存在论论证的重要代表","caution":"必须呈现相关论证前提，不能用“相信逻辑”代替","reading":{"title":"《宣讲篇》第二至四章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anselm/"},"sourceIds":["source_p15"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p15_c1","questionId":"T20","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"作为“无法设想比它更伟大的存在”，上帝不可能只停留在想象中，而必然在现实中存在。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"《宣讲篇》与信仰寻求理解","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p15_c2","questionId":"T21","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"信仰可以成为进一步理解的起点。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"《宣讲篇》与信仰寻求理解","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p15_c3","questionId":"T23","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释存在时，需要追问是否有不依赖其他东西的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"《宣讲篇》与信仰寻求理解","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p15_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性论证可以讨论超出感官经验的存在。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"《宣讲篇》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p15_cross_T117","questionId":"T117","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"寻求理解是信仰活动的一部分。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"信仰寻求理解","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p15_cross_W04","questionId":"W04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"依赖他物的存在需要更根本的说明。","sourceIds":["source_p15"],"locator":"《独白篇》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p15","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"信仰需要理解，理性也能参与对上帝存在的追问。"},{"id":"p16","name":"阿维森纳","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"存在、本质与必然存在讨论","matchScope":"事物是什么、为何存在","intro":"存在与本质、必然性、心灵的重要交流节点","caution":"不按是否有宗教信仰筛选，也不抹去其自身思想语境","reading":{"title":"《治疗论·神学》相关章节","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ibn-sina/"},"sourceIds":["source_p16"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p16_c1","questionId":"T22","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"知道一种事物是什么，还没有说明它为什么实际存在。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"存在、本质与必然存在讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p16_c2","questionId":"T23","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"依靠别的条件才能存在的事物，需要追溯到不再依赖其他原因的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"存在、本质与必然存在讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p16_c3","questionId":"W04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释事物时，希望找到最终的根据。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"存在、本质与必然存在讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p16_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性可以从存在的概念推进对必然存在者的论证。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"形而上学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p16_cross_R01","questionId":"R01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"依赖条件的存在需要不依赖他物的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"必然存在与可能存在","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p16_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自我意识不能完全还原为身体感受。","sourceIds":["source_p16"],"locator":"飞人与灵魂","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p16","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"解释一样东西，要说清它是什么，也要回答它为什么会实际存在。"},{"id":"p17","name":"阿威罗伊","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"《决定性论述》的理性与宗教解释","matchScope":"哲学论证与经典解释","intro":"亚里士多德解释与哲学、宗教关系","caution":"不套用“同时接受相反真理”的双重真理刻板印象","reading":{"title":"《决定性论述》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ibn-rushd/"},"sourceIds":["source_p17"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p17_c1","questionId":"T24","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"可靠论证与经文字面冲突时，可以重新理解经文。","sourceIds":["source_p17"],"locator":"《决定性论述》的理性与宗教解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p17_c2","questionId":"T117","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理性研究也可以是信仰要求人认真去做的事。","sourceIds":["source_p17"],"locator":"《决定性论述》的理性与宗教解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p17_c3","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"严密的理性论证能帮助人认识世界。","sourceIds":["source_p17"],"locator":"《决定性论述》的理性与宗教解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p17_cross_T25","questionId":"T25","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性探究有自身能够把握的根据。","sourceIds":["source_p17"],"locator":"理性与启示","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p17_cross_T28","questionId":"T28","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对事物的认识涉及其真实的共同本质。","sourceIds":["source_p17"],"locator":"亚里士多德解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p17","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"哲学用论证追求真理，宗教经典也需要合理解释。"},{"id":"p18","name":"托马斯·阿奎那","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"《神学大全》的自然法与理性神学","matchScope":"理性、道德与信仰","intro":"经院哲学、自然法、理性与信仰","caution":"自然法不能被简化为“自然发生的都是好的”","reading":{"title":"《神学大全》第一集与法律论相关问题","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aquinas/"},"sourceIds":["source_p18"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p18_c1","questionId":"T25","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人可以凭理性认识共同生活所需要的道德要求。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"《神学大全》的自然法与理性神学","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p18_c2","questionId":"T23","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"解释依靠条件存在的事物，需要追问最终的存在根源。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"《神学大全》的自然法与理性神学","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p18_c3","questionId":"T117","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性研究与信仰可以相互配合。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"《神学大全》的自然法与理性神学","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p18_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人的自然认识从感官经验开始。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"感觉与理智","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p18_cross_L02","questionId":"L02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人的善有超出个人偏好的根据。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"自然法与目的","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p18_cross_T22","questionId":"T22","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"事物的本质与实际存在需要区分。","sourceIds":["source_p18"],"locator":"本质与存在","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p18","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"理性与信仰可以相互配合，人也能通过理性认识道德。"},{"id":"p19","name":"邓斯·司各脱","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"关于个体区别与意志自由的讨论","matchScope":"个体的区别与意志自由","intro":"个体性、意志与存在概念的重要人物","caution":"不把“喜欢独特”作为个体化理论的证据；更适合深入路线","reading":{"title":"司各脱个体化与自由意志问题导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/duns-scotus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p19"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p19_c1","questionId":"T26","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"共同特征还说不清一个东西为什么恰好是它自己，需要解释它独有的个体性。","sourceIds":["source_p19"],"locator":"个体化与意志自由讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p19_c2","questionId":"T27","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"即使知道怎样对自己最有利，人也可以选择追求公正。","sourceIds":["source_p19"],"locator":"个体化与意志自由讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p19_cross_Q10","questionId":"Q10","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"意志具有不被先前条件完全决定的选择能力。","sourceIds":["source_p19"],"locator":"意志与偶然性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p19_cross_F02","questionId":"F02","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由包含在相同条件下仍有另一种选择的可能。","sourceIds":["source_p19"],"locator":"同步偶然性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p19_cross_T28","questionId":"T28","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"共同本性有实在根据，不能只当作名字。","sourceIds":["source_p19"],"locator":"共同本性与个体化","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p19","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"每一个体都有独特性，意志也有选择的自由。"},{"id":"p20","name":"奥卡姆","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中世纪","scope":"共相与解释节约的讨论","matchScope":"共同概念与具体事物","intro":"共相、概念与解释节约","caution":"奥卡姆剃刀不是“越简单越正确”，也不能单凭偏好简洁匹配","reading":{"title":"奥卡姆共相论和逻辑著作导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ockham/"},"sourceIds":["source_p20"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p20_c1","questionId":"T28","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"具体事物和共同概念已经能够说明分类，独立的共同本质会增加额外假设。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"共相与解释节约的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p20_c2","questionId":"T118","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"共同概念用于归类具体事物，不需要另立一种真实的共同本质。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"共相与解释节约的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p20_c3","questionId":"T29","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"假设应与解释的需要相称，额外增加对象需要理由。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"共相与解释节约的讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p20_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"关于具体自然事物的知识需要经验。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"直观认识","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p20_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"直观认识从具体对象的经验开始。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"直观与抽象","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p20_cross_T25","questionId":"T25","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"启示与神的意志不能由自然理性完全替代。","sourceIds":["source_p20"],"locator":"神意与伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p20","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"共同概念用来理解具体事物，解释时应减少不必要的假设。"},{"id":"p21","name":"马基雅维利","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《君主论》与《论李维》的政治问题","matchScope":"政治责任与制度冲突","intro":"政治行动、制度与道德评价","caution":"不简化成“不择手段”；区分君主论述与共和思想","reading":{"title":"《君主论》与《论李维》对照阅读","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/machiavelli/"},"sourceIds":["source_p21"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p21_c1","questionId":"T30","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"政治行动要考虑公共责任，不能完全照搬私人交往中的道德判断。","sourceIds":["source_p21"],"locator":"《君主论》与《论李维》的政治问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p21_c2","questionId":"T31","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"社会冲突经过制度处理，有时能促成保护自由的法律。","sourceIds":["source_p21"],"locator":"《君主论》与《论李维》的政治问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p21_c3","questionId":"T45","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治制度需要结合当地的实际情况来判断。","sourceIds":["source_p21"],"locator":"《君主论》与《论李维》的政治问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p21_cross_T104","questionId":"T104","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"稳定政治不能只依赖统治者个人品德。","sourceIds":["source_p21"],"locator":"《君主论》《论李维》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p21_cross_H04","questionId":"H04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治成果可能失去，历史不保证持续进步。","sourceIds":["source_p21"],"locator":"命运与政治","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p21","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"政治责任不同于私人交往中的温良道德，看清权力的运作与秩序的代价才能稳住共同体。"},{"id":"p22","name":"弗朗西斯·培根","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《新工具》的研究方法","matchScope":"系统观察与偏见纠正","intro":"经验研究、偏见与知识方法","caution":"不等同所有经验主义，也不以“相信科学”作为唯一证据","reading":{"title":"《新工具》第一卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/francis-bacon/"},"sourceIds":["source_p22"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p22_c1","questionId":"T32","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人容易偏爱支持自己看法的例子，需要通过有计划的观察和反例来纠正偏见。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"《新工具》的研究方法","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p22_c2","questionId":"Q11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"认识自然需要观察，不能仅靠推理。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"《新工具》的研究方法","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p22_c3","questionId":"K02","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"反复遇到解释不了的现象，就应认真检查原来的想法。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"《新工具》的研究方法","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p22_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识自然需要感官材料与有组织的探究。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"《新工具》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p22_cross_T33","questionId":"T33","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"研究可以带着疑问开始，在纠正偏见的过程中逐步推进。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"四假相","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p22_cross_T67","questionId":"T67","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"结论需要持续检验，不能依赖一次成功。","sourceIds":["source_p22"],"locator":"归纳与实验","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p22","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"通过系统观察和实验积累知识，并纠正妨碍认识的偏见。"},{"id":"p23","name":"笛卡尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《第一哲学沉思集》的方法与心身区分","matchScope":"怀疑、思考与身体","intro":"方法怀疑、心身与知识基础","caution":"方法性怀疑不等于永久怀疑；时期与论证步骤要清楚","reading":{"title":"《第一哲学沉思集》第二、六沉思","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/descartes/"},"sourceIds":["source_p23"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p23_c1","questionId":"T33","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"只要此刻正在怀疑，就能确定自己正在思考。","sourceIds":["source_p23"],"locator":"《第一哲学沉思集》的方法与心身区分","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p23_c2","questionId":"T34","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"心灵和身体属于根本不同的两类存在。","sourceIds":["source_p23"],"locator":"《第一哲学沉思集》的方法与心身区分","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p23_c3","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有些知识可以由理性本身获得。","sourceIds":["source_p23"],"locator":"《第一哲学沉思集》的方法与心身区分","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p23_cross_FP01","questionId":"FP01","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"心灵与物质身体是不同类型的实体。","sourceIds":["source_p23"],"locator":"实体二元论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p23_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有些基本观念并不完全来自感觉。","sourceIds":["source_p23"],"locator":"天赋观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p23","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"从怀疑出发，用理性寻找可靠的知识。"},{"id":"p24","name":"霍布斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《利维坦》的秩序论证","matchScope":"安全、裁决与权威","intro":"权威、安全、契约与政治秩序","caution":"不因重视安全就贴“专制主义”标签","reading":{"title":"《利维坦》第十三至十八章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hobbes-moral/"},"sourceIds":["source_p24"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p24_c1","questionId":"T35","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"为了摆脱相互防备与冲突的处境，需要建立能作出并执行共同裁决的公共权威。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"《利维坦》的秩序论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p24_c2","questionId":"T31","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"群体冲突可能破坏秩序，需要共同权威协调。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"《利维坦》的秩序论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p24_c3","questionId":"T30","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治行动需要承担维护公共秩序的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"《利维坦》的秩序论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p24_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"思想与感觉需要由身体运动解释。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"唯物主义心理学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p24_cross_T104","questionId":"T104","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"制度与共同权威不能仅靠人的善意维系。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"主权与契约","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p24_cross_T59","questionId":"T59","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"持续的共同权威对于稳定和平不可缺少。","sourceIds":["source_p24"],"locator":"《利维坦》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p24","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"为了摆脱相互威胁，人们需要共同认可的权威来维持秩序。"},{"id":"p25","name":"斯宾诺莎","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《伦理学》的自然必然性与情感","matchScope":"理解原因与自由","intro":"必然性、自由、情感与自然","caution":"不能把必然性等同宿命论或消极放弃","reading":{"title":"《伦理学》第三至五部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spinoza/"},"sourceIds":["source_p25"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p25_c1","questionId":"T36","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解欲望和情绪的原因，可以减少自己被冲动支配。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"《伦理学》的自然必然性与情感","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p25_c2","questionId":"T37","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然的变化由自身的原因和规律展开，而非外在意志按目的安排。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"《伦理学》的自然必然性与情感","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p25_c3","questionId":"Q10","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然的变化由确定的原因和规律决定。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"《伦理学》的自然必然性与情感","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p25_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性认识能够把握事物的必然联系。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"充分观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p25_cross_T40","questionId":"T40","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"事物及其变化都有其必然原因。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"因果必然性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p25_cross_Q04","questionId":"Q04","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由需要理解并调整自己受情感支配的方式。","sourceIds":["source_p25"],"locator":"情感与自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p25","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人属于自然，理解支配自己的原因，才能获得更大的自由。"},{"id":"p26","name":"洛克","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《人类理解论》的经验与人格问题","matchScope":"经验、记忆与个人身份","intro":"经验、人格同一性与政治权利","caution":"认识论、人格理论与政治立场分别比较，不能连带推定","reading":{"title":"《人类理解论》第二卷第二十七章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke/"},"sourceIds":["source_p26","locke_personal_identity"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p26_c1","questionId":"T38","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个人是否延续，与意识和记忆的联系有关，不能只凭身体判断。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"《人类理解论》的经验与人格问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p26_c2","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"观念来自感官经验，以及对自己心中活动的觉察。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"《人类理解论》的经验与人格问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p26_c3","questionId":"Q11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识现实需要经验作为根据。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"《人类理解论》的经验与人格问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p26_c4","questionId":"Q03","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人格的延续与能否把过去的经历认作自己的经历有关，不能只凭身体仍在延续来判断。","sourceIds":["locke_personal_identity"],"locator":"《人类理解论》第二卷第二十七章","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p26_cross_T46","questionId":"T46","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不同信念应当获得宽容，不能以强制替代理由。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"宗教宽容","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p26_cross_T44","questionId":"T44","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治权力需要受到限制。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"有限政府","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p26_cross_W01","questionId":"W01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"外部事物的存在不由个体感知决定。","sourceIds":["source_p26"],"locator":"实在与观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p26","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"知识从经验出发，记忆与意识的延续构成个人身份。"},{"id":"p27","name":"莱布尼茨","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"充分理由与不可分辨者同一性","matchScope":"理由与个体区别","intro":"充分理由、必然与可能性","caution":"充分理由原则不直接等于简单因果决定论","reading":{"title":"《单子论》《形而上学谈》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/leibniz/"},"sourceIds":["source_p27"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p27_c1","questionId":"T40","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"每一件事实都应有理由说明为什么是这样，而不是别的样子。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"充分理由与不可分辨者同一性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p27_c2","questionId":"T41","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"如果两样东西毫无区别，就没有理由说它们是两个。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"充分理由与不可分辨者同一性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p27_c3","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理性可以认识一些不直接来自观察的原则。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"充分理由与不可分辨者同一性","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p27_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"经验会唤起认识，但一些原则有心灵自身的根据。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"天赋原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p27_cross_T133","questionId":"T133","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"个别苦难可能属于整体最优安排的一部分。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"神正论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p27_cross_W04","questionId":"W04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对偶然事物的解释需要充分理由。","sourceIds":["source_p27"],"locator":"充足理由律","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p27","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"事物的存在和发生都有充分理由，个体也各有不可替代的特点。"},{"id":"p28","name":"贝克莱","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《人类知识原理》的反物质实体论证","matchScope":"感知与事物的存在","intro":"感知、对象与物质概念","caution":"不概括为“闭眼世界就消失”；必须保留其论证与神学背景","reading":{"title":"《人类知识原理》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/berkeley/"},"sourceIds":["source_p28"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p28_c1","questionId":"T42","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"被感知的内容和它们的秩序，可以解释经验中的事物。","sourceIds":["source_p28"],"locator":"《人类知识原理》的反物质实体论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p28_c2","questionId":"T131","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"对象可以在无人观看时持续存在，因为上帝的感知不依赖任何个别的人。","sourceIds":["source_p28"],"locator":"《人类知识原理》的反物质实体论证","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p28_cross_W01","questionId":"W01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"感知对象的存在离不开心灵。","sourceIds":["source_p28"],"locator":"非物质论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p28_cross_FP01","questionId":"FP01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"可感世界不能被放在一切心灵之外解释。","sourceIds":["source_p28"],"locator":"观念与精神","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p28_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"关于可感对象的认识来自经验。","sourceIds":["source_p28"],"locator":"经验与观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p28","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"事物的存在离不开被感知，世界由心灵和观念构成。"},{"id":"p29","name":"休谟","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《人类理解研究》与道德情感讨论","matchScope":"经验、自由与道德情感","intro":"经验、因果推断、情感与道德","caution":"不将因果怀疑概括为否认一切因果或一切客观事实","reading":{"title":"《人类理解研究》第四、五、八节","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hume/"},"sourceIds":["source_p29"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p29_c1","questionId":"V03","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"过去反复发生的事能支持期待，却不能保证未来必然相同。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"《人类理解研究》与道德情感讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p29_c2","questionId":"T43","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"同情和情感参与道德判断；只知道事实，还不足以推动人行动。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"《人类理解研究》与道德情感讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p29_c3","questionId":"Q04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"只要能按照自己的意愿行动，自由就可以与因果规律并存。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"《人类理解研究》与道德情感讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p29_c4","questionId":"Q11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识现实需要依靠经验，不能无限超出经验所支持的范围。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"《人类理解研究》与道德情感讨论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p29_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"观念的基本材料来自经验。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"印象与观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p29_cross_T20","questionId":"T20","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"概念分析本身不能证明对象实际存在。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"存在与观念","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p29_cross_T109","questionId":"T109","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"经验中没有独立不变的自我实体。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"locator":"自我的束论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p29","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"知识从经验出发，道德判断离不开人的情感。"},{"id":"p30","name":"孟德斯鸠","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《论法的精神》的制度比较","matchScope":"权力制约与社会条件","intro":"权力制约、法律与社会条件","caution":"不以一道赞成分权题推出完整政治理论","reading":{"title":"《论法的精神》第十一卷及制度比较部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/montesquieu/"},"sourceIds":["source_p30"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p30_c1","questionId":"T44","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"权力应当受到其他权力的限制，不能只靠掌权者品德好。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"《论法的精神》的制度比较","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p30_c2","questionId":"T45","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解法律需要考虑当地的习惯和生活条件。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"《论法的精神》的制度比较","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p30_c3","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不同的生活条件会影响制度和观念怎样形成。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"《论法的精神》的制度比较","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p30_cross_T35","questionId":"T35","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"权力之间的制约能够防止共同权威变成威胁。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"政制与自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p30_cross_T104","questionId":"T104","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治秩序需要可靠的制度安排。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"法的精神","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p30_cross_FP02","questionId":"FP02","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解法律与观念需要结合多种社会和环境条件。","sourceIds":["source_p30"],"locator":"法律与社会条件","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p30","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"用权力制约权力，并结合社会条件理解法律。"},{"id":"p31","name":"伏尔泰","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"宽容与公共启蒙论述","matchScope":"宽容与批判","intro":"宽容、宗教批判与公共启蒙","caution":"不使用伪托名言，也不能从现代宽容偏好推出其全部立场","reading":{"title":"《论宽容》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/voltaire/"},"sourceIds":["source_p31","voltaire_lisbon"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p31_c1","questionId":"T46","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"即使不赞同一种信念，也应容许无害、非强迫的表达，不因信念不同而迫害人。","sourceIds":["source_p31"],"locator":"宽容与公共启蒙论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p31_c2","questionId":"T133","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"无辜者遭受苦难，使“一切都是最好的安排”这种说法难以成立。","sourceIds":["source_p31","voltaire_lisbon"],"locator":"《里斯本灾难诗》对“一切皆好”的质疑","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p31_cross_R03","questionId":"R03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"具体苦难构成需要正面回答的反对理由。","sourceIds":["source_p31"],"locator":"里斯本地震与乐观主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p31_cross_T65","questionId":"T65","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不能因为不赞同一种生活或信念就轻易禁止它。","sourceIds":["source_p31"],"locator":"宽容","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p31","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"以理性批判偏见，允许不同信仰和意见共存。"},{"id":"p32","name":"卢梭","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《社会契约论》的公民自由","matchScope":"共同制定规则与自由","intro":"自由、不平等、公意与社会形成","caution":"公意不等于多数人的即时偏好；不简化为反文明","reading":{"title":"《社会契约论》第一、二卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rousseau/"},"sourceIds":["source_p32"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p32_c1","questionId":"T47","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"规则应当面向公民的共同利益，而非只满足某些人的私利。","sourceIds":["source_p32"],"locator":"《社会契约论》的公民自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p32_c2","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"共同参与制定的制度，可以成为实现自由的条件。","sourceIds":["source_p32"],"locator":"《社会契约论》的公民自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p32_c3","questionId":"C01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"社会安排造成的差距需要接受检查。","sourceIds":["source_p32"],"locator":"《社会契约论》的公民自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p32_cross_T88","questionId":"T88","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"共同生活需要公民实际参与。","sourceIds":["source_p32"],"locator":"公意与公民","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p32_cross_T91","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"欲望也会被社会塑造，人可能对受限制的生活感到满意。","sourceIds":["source_p32"],"locator":"依赖与不平等","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p32","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人们共同制定自己服从的规则，才能在社会中保持自由。"},{"id":"p33","name":"玛丽·沃斯通克拉夫特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《女权辩护》的教育与德性","matchScope":"教育、平等与理性能力","intro":"女性平等、教育与理性主体","caution":"不把一般平等态度当作完整匹配；需要教育与德性方面证据","reading":{"title":"《女权辩护》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wollstonecraft/"},"sourceIds":["source_p33"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p33_c1","questionId":"T48","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"教育机会不同造成的能力差距，不能直接算作天生的差距。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"《女权辩护》的教育与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p33_c2","questionId":"T84","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"教育和社会对一个人的期待，会影响他实际能作出什么选择。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"《女权辩护》的教育与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p33_c3","questionId":"T11","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人应有发展能力的机会，而不只是学会讨好或依附别人。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"《女权辩护》的教育与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p33_cross_C01","questionId":"C01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"教育与社会机会不能由出身和性别预先决定。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"《女权辩护》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p33_cross_T43","questionId":"T43","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德能力包括能够独立使用理性。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"理性与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p33_cross_P02","questionId":"P02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"教育应培养独立判断和可靠的行为习惯。","sourceIds":["source_p33"],"locator":"教育","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p33","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"平等教育使女性发展理性能力，成为独立自主的人。"},{"id":"p34","name":"康德","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"文艺复兴至启蒙","scope":"《道德形而上学奠基》的实践原则","matchScope":"人人适用的原则与尊重他人","intro":"知识条件、自律、义务与目的","caution":"不以“守规则”概括义务论；区分知识论与伦理学证据","reading":{"title":"《道德形而上学奠基》第二章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-moral/"},"sourceIds":["source_p34"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p34_c1","questionId":"T49","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"行动依据的原则，应当也允许别人同样使用。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"《道德形而上学奠基》的实践原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p34_c2","questionId":"T50","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"每个人都有自己的目的，不能仅仅被当作实现别的目标的工具。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"《道德形而上学奠基》的实践原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p34_c3","questionId":"Q02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"结果好，还不足以使所有手段都变得正当。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"《道德形而上学奠基》的实践原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p34_c4","questionId":"E01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"承诺带来责任，不能只因为结果更好就轻易撤回。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"《道德形而上学奠基》的实践原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p34_c5","questionId":"FP04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"承诺使人承担责任，不能仅因另一边带来的好处更多，就把这份责任取消。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"《道德形而上学奠基》及义务与后果的区别","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p34_cross_T43","questionId":"T43","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德义务的根据不依赖一时的同情和欲望。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"实践理性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p34_cross_L02","questionId":"L02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德价值不由个人是否喜欢决定。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"善良意志","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p34_cross_T14","questionId":"T14","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"正直有独立于预期回报的价值。","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"locator":"义务与德性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p34","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"按人人都能遵守的原则行动，把人当作目的。"},{"id":"p35","name":"费希特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"耶拿时期知识学与自然法问题","matchScope":"自我、行动与彼此承认","intro":"自我活动、自由与德国唯心主义","caution":"不等同自我中心；需要对“自我”概念作语境说明","reading":{"title":"《全部知识学的基础》《自然法权基础》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/johann-fichte/"},"sourceIds":["source_p35"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p35_c1","questionId":"T51","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"可以从认识、行动和设定目标这些活动，理解“自我”是什么。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"耶拿时期知识学与自然法问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p35_c2","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人要实际拥有自由，也需要别人承认自己能自主行动。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"耶拿时期知识学与自然法问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p35_c3","questionId":"F02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人能够检查自己的愿望，并决定怎样行动。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"耶拿时期知识学与自然法问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p35_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自我是在实际的选择与活动中形成的。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"自我设定与实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p35_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识应从主体活动与对象的关系出发。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"知识学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p35_cross_Q04","questionId":"Q04","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自主包含反省和调整自身意愿的能力。","sourceIds":["source_p35"],"locator":"实践自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p35","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"自我通过行动认识自己，自由也需要人与人彼此承认。"},{"id":"p36","name":"谢林","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"早期自然哲学与先验唯心论时期","matchScope":"自然、心灵与艺术创作","intro":"自然、自由与德国唯心主义","caution":"分时期建档，不能把自然哲学和晚期思想平均化","reading":{"title":"《先验唯心论体系》及早期自然哲学导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/schelling/"},"sourceIds":["source_p36"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p36_c1","questionId":"T52","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然能主动形成和组织生命，不能只看成材料被动地拼在一起。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"早期自然哲学与先验唯心论时期","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p36_c2","questionId":"T119","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然与心灵可以是同一根源的不同表现。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"早期自然哲学与先验唯心论时期","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p36_c3","questionId":"T120","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"艺术创作既包含明确意图，也包含创作者无法完全掌握的过程。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"早期自然哲学与先验唯心论时期","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p36_cross_T07","questionId":"T07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"整体的组织能力不能从被动零件的拼装中消去。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"自然哲学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p36_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自然与精神需要由其共同的发展活动来理解。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"同一哲学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p36_cross_T04","questionId":"T04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解自然需要理解形成与变化。","sourceIds":["source_p36"],"locator":"自然的生产性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p36","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"自然与心灵有共同根源，艺术使两者的联系得以呈现。"},{"id":"p37","name":"黑格尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《法哲学原理》的自由与承认","matchScope":"社会中的自由","intro":"历史、承认、中介与自由","caution":"不使用“任何矛盾都正确”或“现实即合理”的口号式赋值","reading":{"title":"《法哲学原理》导论及伦理生活部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/"},"sourceIds":["source_p37"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p37_c1","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自由需要别人承认自己的权利，也需要实际行使权利的制度。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"《法哲学原理》的自由与承认","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p37_c2","questionId":"S02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人怎样认识自己，与同他人的交往有关。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"《法哲学原理》的自由与承认","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p37_c3","questionId":"H04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"历史可以显示人们对自由的认识怎样逐渐扩展。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"《法哲学原理》的自由与承认","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p37_cross_H01","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"思想与制度需要放回其历史生活条件中理解。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"精神与历史","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p37_cross_T47","questionId":"T47","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由也体现于共同制度中的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"伦理生活","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p37_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"个人身份与社会关系、历史生活相连。","sourceIds":["source_p37"],"locator":"承认与社会性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p37","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"自由在历史和社会关系中发展，需要相互承认与合理制度。"},{"id":"p38","name":"叔本华","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《作为意志和表象的世界》与伦理论文","matchScope":"欲望、痛苦与同情","intro":"意志、欲望、痛苦与同情","caution":"不以情绪低落或悲观性格推断其形而上学","reading":{"title":"《作为意志和表象的世界》第四篇","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/schopenhauer/"},"sourceIds":["source_p38"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p38_c1","questionId":"T54","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"满足一个欲望之后，往往又会出现新的不满足。","sourceIds":["source_p38"],"locator":"《作为意志和表象的世界》与伦理论文","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p38_c2","questionId":"T55","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"同情可以使人直接在乎他人的痛苦，成为道德行动的动力。","sourceIds":["source_p38"],"locator":"《作为意志和表象的世界》与伦理论文","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p38_c3","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"减少无止境的欲望，有助于减轻痛苦。","sourceIds":["source_p38"],"locator":"《作为意志和表象的世界》与伦理论文","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p38_cross_P04","questionId":"P04","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对自我的执著会加重欲望带来的束缚。","sourceIds":["source_p38"],"locator":"意志与自我","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p38_cross_T110","questionId":"T110","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"减少对欲望对象的紧抓，有助于减轻痛苦。","sourceIds":["source_p38"],"locator":"意志的否定","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p38","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人生常在欲望与倦怠之间摇摆，专注的审美与对他人的同情能让心灵暂得解脱。"},{"id":"p39","name":"费尔巴哈","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《基督教的本质》的人本解释","matchScope":"神的形象与人的理想","intro":"宗教批判与人的感性存在","caution":"不将无神论者直接匹配为费尔巴哈","reading":{"title":"《基督教的本质》导论","url":"https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/feuerbach/works/essence/ec01_1.htm"},"sourceIds":["source_p39"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p39_c1","questionId":"T56","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人把自身向往的能力想象得无限完美，再把它们归给神。","sourceIds":["source_p39"],"locator":"《基督教的本质》的人本解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p39_c2","questionId":"T121","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"把爱与智慧等理想带回人与人的实际相处中。","sourceIds":["source_p39"],"locator":"《基督教的本质》的人本解释","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p39_cross_FP01","questionId":"FP01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"应从有身体、有需要的人出发理解精神活动。","sourceIds":["source_p39"],"locator":"感性的人","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p39_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"心灵活动不能脱离有身体的人来解释。","sourceIds":["source_p39"],"locator":"对思辨哲学的批评","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p39_cross_T43","questionId":"T43","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人与人之间的感情和需要构成伦理生活的重要基础。","sourceIds":["source_p39"],"locator":"人本主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p39","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"神的形象寄托了人的理想，理解宗教也要理解人的需要。"},{"id":"p40","name":"马克思","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"1844年手稿及历史唯物主义问题","matchScope":"劳动、生活条件与社会","intro":"实践、异化、社会关系与历史","caution":"不从一次分配偏好推出整套马克思主义；按作品与时期区分","reading":{"title":"《1844年经济学哲学手稿》异化劳动部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marx/"},"sourceIds":["source_p40"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p40_c1","questionId":"T57","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"即使工资不低，劳动者无法决定劳动过程、支配成果，仍然是一个问题。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"1844年手稿及历史唯物主义问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p40_c2","questionId":"H03","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"改变不公平需要考察制度和资源分配，而不只劝个人调整态度。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"1844年手稿及历史唯物主义问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p40_c3","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解观念时，要考察它产生于怎样的生活条件。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"1844年手稿及历史唯物主义问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p40_c4","questionId":"T58","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生产方式和社会关系会影响历史中的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"1844年手稿及历史唯物主义问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p40_c5","questionId":"FP03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"劳动者应参与掌握生产资料与生产安排，改变生产成果由少数所有者支配的关系。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"《资本论》第一卷第三十二章；《共产党宣言》第二章","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p40_c6","questionId":"FP02","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"谋生和生产的方式会影响社会关系与观念，观念也会参与改变社会生活。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"《德意志意识形态》与历史唯物主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p40_cross_T59","questionId":"T59","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"国家有其历史条件，不是永恒不变的组织。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"国家与阶级","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p40_cross_T53","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由需要现实的社会条件。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"解放与社会关系","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p40_cross_T91","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"主观满意并不能取消实际的支配关系。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"异化与意识形态","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p40_contrast_T139","questionId":"T139","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"真正的自由离不开社会解放，人需要摆脱受支配的关系，实际掌握劳动与生活的条件。","sourceIds":["source_p40"],"locator":"社会解放与异化劳动","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p40","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"思想与制度植根于现实的生产和生活条件，真正的解放需要改变支配人的社会关系。"},{"id":"p41","name":"恩格斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《家庭、私有制和国家的起源》的问题框架","matchScope":"家庭、生产与历史组织","intro":"马克思主义的关键共同创作者与传播者","caution":"不与马克思生成重复档案；不把二人的每个具体主张视为一致","reading":{"title":"《家庭、私有制和国家的起源》1884年序言","url":"https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1884/origin-family/preface.htm"},"sourceIds":["source_p41"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p41_c1","questionId":"T58","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"研究家庭和亲属制度时，需要考察谋生、财产与继承的变化。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"《家庭、私有制和国家的起源》的问题框架","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p41_c2","questionId":"T59","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"国家是在一定历史条件下形成的，也可能随这些条件改变。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"《家庭、私有制和国家的起源》的问题框架","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p41_c3","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生活条件的变化会影响观念和制度。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"《家庭、私有制和国家的起源》的问题框架","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p41_cross_FP02","questionId":"FP02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生产与生计方式深刻影响社会制度。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"唯物史观","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p41_cross_FP03","questionId":"FP03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生产资料与劳动安排需要社会性的改变。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"社会主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p41_cross_T53","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由不能只理解为个人未受直接干涉。","sourceIds":["source_p41"],"locator":"社会解放","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p41","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"生产和生活方式的变化，会改变家庭、制度与社会关系。"},{"id":"p42","name":"克尔凯郭尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《恐惧与战栗》及相关的个人选择与信仰讨论","matchScope":"个人选择与信仰","intro":"个体、选择、信仰与存在","caution":"不把信仰简化为任性，也不能由一般冒险偏好推断","reading":{"title":"《恐惧与战栗》及存在问题导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kierkegaard/"},"sourceIds":["source_p42"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p42_c1","questionId":"T60","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"是否信任、信仰或承诺，需要本人作决定，客观证明无法代替。","sourceIds":["source_p42"],"locator":"存在承诺与信仰问题；保留署名和假名文本差别","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p42_c2","questionId":"R02","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"信仰是一份亲自承担的承诺，人可以在缺少知识证明时作出这种选择。","sourceIds":["source_p42"],"locator":"存在承诺与信仰问题；保留署名和假名文本差别","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p42_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人需要通过自己承担的选择成为自己。","sourceIds":["source_p42"],"locator":"个体与抉择","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p42_cross_L01","questionId":"L01","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"一个人可能为了自己承担的生活而接受艰难。","sourceIds":["source_p42"],"locator":"主观性与承诺","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p42_cross_T85","questionId":"T85","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"信仰回应人生意义的根本追问。","sourceIds":["source_p42"],"locator":"信仰与绝望","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p42","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人生的重要选择需要亲自承担，信仰也无法由旁人代劳。"},{"id":"p43","name":"尼采","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《道德谱系》《快乐的科学》等成熟期论述","matchScope":"道德的来历与价值创造","intro":"价值谱系、自我超越与道德批判","caution":"不等同反道德、自私或“强者有理”；关键解释争议需标注","reading":{"title":"《道德谱系》序言及第一篇","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nietzsche/"},"sourceIds":["source_p43"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p43_c1","questionId":"T61","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"评价一种道德，要考察它从何而来，又鼓励人怎样生活。","sourceIds":["source_p43"],"locator":"《道德谱系》《快乐的科学》等成熟期论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p43_c2","questionId":"T62","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"旧标准失去说服力后，需要尝试创造新的价值、改变自己的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p43"],"locator":"《道德谱系》《快乐的科学》等成熟期论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p43_c3","questionId":"L01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"一个人需要检查外界既定的评价，并选择自己愿意承担的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p43"],"locator":"《道德谱系》《快乐的科学》等成熟期论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p43_cross_T54","questionId":"T54","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不断超越已有目标可以体现生命的创造力。","sourceIds":["source_p43"],"locator":"自我超越","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p43_cross_H02","questionId":"H02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"追查道德如何形成，能够动摇其不证自明的地位。","sourceIds":["source_p43"],"locator":"谱系学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p43","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"追查传统道德背后的真实来历，在不断自我超越中为生命创造新的价值。"},{"id":"p44","name":"边沁","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"功利原则与制度评价","matchScope":"苦乐的平等考虑","intro":"功利原则、制度评估与痛苦","caution":"不把功利主义等同个人逐利；不能忽略总量与分配的不同问题","reading":{"title":"《道德与立法原理导论》第一、四章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bentham/"},"sourceIds":["source_p44"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p44_c1","questionId":"T63","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"评价制度时，应把所有人的快乐和痛苦算进去。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"功利原则与制度评价","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p44_c2","questionId":"T64","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"快乐的比较取决于强度、时长等因素，内容本身并不决定等级。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"功利原则与制度评价","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p44_c3","questionId":"T10","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"判断行动，要比较它对所有受影响者带来的结果。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"功利原则与制度评价","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p44_cross_FP04","questionId":"FP04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"伦理取舍需要比较受影响者的整体利益。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"效用原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p44_cross_T50","questionId":"T50","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"行为是否正当最终需要结合总体利害判断。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"效用与权利","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p44_cross_T55","questionId":"T55","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"同情可以提供动力，正当性仍要考虑总体效果。","sourceIds":["source_p44"],"locator":"快乐与痛苦","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p44","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"平等考虑每个人的苦乐，以行为带来的总体幸福判断好坏。"},{"id":"p45","name":"约翰·斯图亚特·密尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"十九世纪","scope":"《功利主义》《论自由》","matchScope":"快乐质量与个性自由","intro":"自由、个性与功利主义的发展","caution":"区分伤害原则、快乐质量与一般功利计算","reading":{"title":"《功利主义》第二章；《论自由》第三章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mill/"},"sourceIds":["source_p45"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p45_c1","questionId":"T64","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"快乐的类型和质量也重要，不能只比较有多快乐、持续多久。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《功利主义》《论自由》","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p45_c2","questionId":"T65","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"能自主负责的成年人，只要不伤害他人，就应能尝试自己的生活方式。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《功利主义》《论自由》","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p45_c3","questionId":"T63","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"熟人和陌生人的幸福，都应得到平等考虑。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《功利主义》《论自由》","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p45_c4","questionId":"FP04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"取舍时要平等考虑各方的幸福与痛苦，守约带来的后果也要一起权衡。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《功利主义》第二章、第五章","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p45_cross_T46","questionId":"T46","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"错误或不受欢迎的意见也需要表达空间。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《论自由》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p45_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对自然的认识以经验和归纳为基础。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《逻辑体系》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p45_cross_T55","questionId":"T55","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"伦理判断需要将同情与总体福祉联系起来。","sourceIds":["source_p45"],"locator":"《功利主义》","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p45","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"追求有质量的幸福，并保护个人发展与选择生活的自由。"},{"id":"p46","name":"皮尔士","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"实用主义与生命哲学","scope":"实用准则与可纠错探究","matchScope":"弄清概念与共同检验","intro":"实用主义起点、探究与可错性","caution":"不等于眼前有用即真，也不把真理交给当下多数票","reading":{"title":"《如何使我们的观念清楚》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/peirce/"},"sourceIds":["source_p46"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p46_c1","questionId":"T66","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"检查两个概念会带来怎样不同的观察或行动后果，才能弄清它们的区别。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"实用准则与可纠错探究","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p46_c2","questionId":"T67","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"眼前有用的想法，仍要经过持续的共同检验和纠错，才能判断它是否真实。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"实用准则与可纠错探究","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p46_c3","questionId":"K02","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"能解释更多现象的假说，值得继续研究。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"实用准则与可纠错探究","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p46_cross_T32","questionId":"T32","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"探究应主动寻找可能纠正自身判断的经验。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"可错论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p46_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"推理与经验在探究中相互检验。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"探究与推理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p46_cross_V01","questionId":"V01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理论需要在竞争解释与持续研究中接受修正。","sourceIds":["source_p46"],"locator":"探究共同体","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p46","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"看一个概念会带来怎样的实际后果，并在共同探究和纠错中不断检验信念。"},{"id":"p47","name":"威廉·詹姆斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"实用主义与生命哲学","scope":"《信仰的意志》与实用主义的限定情境","matchScope":"证据不足时怎样选择","intro":"实用主义、多元论与信念实践","caution":"不能省略“真正选择”等限定，不能泛化为想信什么就信什么","reading":{"title":"《信仰的意志》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/james/"},"sourceIds":["source_p47"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p47_c1","questionId":"T68","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"当选择真正可行、重大且无法回避，证据又不足时，希望与承诺可以参与决定。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"《信仰的意志》与实用主义的限定情境","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p47_c2","questionId":"R02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"个人经历和实际生活，可以成为形成信念的理由。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"《信仰的意志》与实用主义的限定情境","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p47_c3","questionId":"T69","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理论需要根据经验和实际效果不断修改。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"《信仰的意志》与实用主义的限定情境","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p47_cross_T60","questionId":"T60","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"某些重大选择无法等到客观证明消除一切风险。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"信仰意志","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p47_cross_Q07","questionId":"Q07","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"实际的投入与承诺能够参与人生意义的形成。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"实用主义与人生","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p47_cross_T66","questionId":"T66","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"概念的意义与可经验的实际后果有关。","sourceIds":["source_p47"],"locator":"实用主义方法","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p47","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"考察信念在生活中的实际作用，面对证据不足时的真实选择。"},{"id":"p48","name":"杜威","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"实用主义与生命哲学","scope":"探究、经验与民主实践","matchScope":"在问题中学习","intro":"探究、经验、教育与民主实践","caution":"不等同短期功利或没有原则的折中","reading":{"title":"《公众及其问题》《我们怎样思维》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dewey/"},"sourceIds":["source_p48"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p48_c1","questionId":"T69","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"实际遇到的困难，可能要求同时修改理论和对问题的理解。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"探究、经验与民主实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p48_c2","questionId":"T67","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"知识要在共同研究和纠正错误中不断发展。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"探究、经验与民主实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p48_c3","questionId":"H03","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"受影响的人参与讨论，有助于共同解决问题。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"探究、经验与民主实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p48_cross_T66","questionId":"T66","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"观念需要联系其实际作用来理解。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"工具主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p48_cross_T92","questionId":"T92","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"民主生活需要持续交流和共同探究。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"民主与教育","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p48_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"知识来自经验、推理与行动之间的循环。","sourceIds":["source_p48"],"locator":"探究论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p48","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"知识在解决问题中成长，学习与民主都需要共同参与。"},{"id":"p49","name":"柏格森","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"实用主义与生命哲学","scope":"《时间与自由意志》等关于绵延的论述","matchScope":"亲身经历的时间","intro":"绵延、生命与经验时间","caution":"不将主观时间感直接当作完整生命哲学证据","reading":{"title":"《时间与自由意志》第二章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bergson/"},"sourceIds":["source_p49"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p49_c1","questionId":"T70","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"亲身经历的时间是连续的，前一刻会影响后一刻，等长刻度说不清这种感受。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"《时间与自由意志》等关于绵延的论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p49_c2","questionId":"T52","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解生命如何形成，不能只把它看成材料被动地拼接。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"《时间与自由意志》等关于绵延的论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p49_c3","questionId":"T04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"变化的过程本身也可以被认识。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"《时间与自由意志》等关于绵延的论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p49_cross_T07","questionId":"T07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生命的组织和创造不能只由零件清单说明。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"创造进化","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p49_cross_T119","questionId":"T119","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"生命与心灵需要放回生成活动中理解。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"生命与物质","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p49_cross_T95","questionId":"T95","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"真正的新事物会在形成过程中带来新的差别。","sourceIds":["source_p49"],"locator":"绵延与创造","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p49","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"亲身经历的时间连续流动，无法完全变成钟表上的刻度。"},{"id":"p50","name":"弗雷格","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"关于逻辑、名称与数学的论述","matchScope":"逻辑、名称与意义","intro":"逻辑、意义与反心理主义","caution":"不将“喜欢逻辑”当作匹配依据；需要意义与客观性问题","reading":{"title":"《论意义与指称》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/frege/"},"sourceIds":["source_p50"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p50_c1","questionId":"T71","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"推理是否成立，不由人们事实上习惯怎样想决定。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"意义、指称与反心理主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p50_c2","questionId":"T72","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"不同名称可以让我们以不同方式认识同一个对象。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"意义、指称与反心理主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p50_c3","questionId":"W02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"数学中的真假不由个人随意决定。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"意义、指称与反心理主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p50_cross_T75","questionId":"T75","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"数的客观地位不取决于个人选择的表述方式。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"算术的基础","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p50_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"数学认识有独立于感官归纳的理性根据。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"逻辑主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p50_cross_T122","questionId":"T122","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"意义和正确使用不能仅靠私人感觉来保证。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"locator":"思想的客观性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p50","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"逻辑的真假超出个人心理，同一个对象也能以不同方式被理解。"},{"id":"p51","name":"罗素","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"1905—1912年前后的分析与摹状词问题","matchScope":"用逻辑分析语言","intro":"分析方法、知识与逻辑","caution":"不将其伦理、政治、认识论不同阶段拼成一个平均档案","reading":{"title":"《论指称》《哲学问题》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/russell/"},"sourceIds":["source_p51"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p51_c1","questionId":"T73","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"把一句话中“有什么存在”等隐含条件说清，能帮助判断它是否成立。","sourceIds":["source_p51"],"locator":"1905—1912年前后的分析与摹状词问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p51_c2","questionId":"T71","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"即使人人都习惯一种错误推理，它也不会因此正确。","sourceIds":["source_p51"],"locator":"1905—1912年前后的分析与摹状词问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p51_c3","questionId":"W01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"外部事物可以在无人观察时存在。","sourceIds":["source_p51"],"locator":"1905—1912年前后的分析与摹状词问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p51_cross_W02","questionId":"W02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"数学对象与关系不只是个人发明的规则。","sourceIds":["source_p51"],"locator":"逻辑主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p51_cross_T39","questionId":"T39","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"关于现实的知识需要经验材料。","sourceIds":["source_p51"],"locator":"经验与认识","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p51","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"用清晰的逻辑分析语言，分辨一句话究竟提出了什么主张。"},{"id":"p52","name":"维特根斯坦","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"晚期《哲学研究》中的词语用法与规则问题","matchScope":"用法与规则","intro":"语言、意义与哲学方法的重大转折","caution":"早晚期分档；本题只适合晚期相关路线，不能同时代表早期","reading":{"title":"《哲学研究》用法、规则和私人语言相关段落","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/"},"sourceIds":["source_p52"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p52_c1","questionId":"T74","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"回到词语的实际用法，可以看清困惑来自哪里。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"晚期《哲学研究》，不混入早期图像论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p52_c2","questionId":"T122","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"“我觉得用对了”还不够，需要有区分用对与用错的办法。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"晚期《哲学研究》，不混入早期图像论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p52_c3","questionId":"G01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解一句话，需要考虑共同生活中的用法和场景。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"晚期《哲学研究》，不混入早期图像论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p52_cross_T09","questionId":"T09","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"澄清一个概念需要考察它怎样被实际使用。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"语言游戏","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p52_cross_T126","questionId":"T126","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释总有到头的时候，最终让词义站稳的，是我们在共同生活中养成的使用习惯。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"规则遵循","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p52_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"讨论心灵和身体，要联系这些词在日常生活中的用法来理解。","sourceIds":["source_p52"],"locator":"晚期《哲学研究》§§304、308；3.6 Grammar and Form of Life","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p52","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"脱离具体生活去追问词的“本质”容易让人迷路，回到日常场景中看人们如何使用语言，才能解开困惑。"},{"id":"p53","name":"卡尔纳普","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"关于语言规则与存在问题的讨论","matchScope":"语言规则与存在问题","intro":"逻辑经验主义、框架与语言分析","caution":"不把逻辑经验主义一概概括为简单证实主义","reading":{"title":"《经验主义、语义学和本体论》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/carnap/"},"sourceIds":["source_p53"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p53_c1","questionId":"T75","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"在一套规则中问某种数是否存在，与决定要不要采用这套规则，是两种问题。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"语言框架与逻辑分析阶段","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p53_c2","questionId":"T71","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"推理是否成立，取决于采用的逻辑规则。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"语言框架与逻辑分析阶段","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p53_c3","questionId":"T29","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"假设只有在解释中发挥作用，才值得采用。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"语言框架与逻辑分析阶段","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p53_cross_W02","questionId":"W02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"数学中的对象问题需要结合采用的语言框架理解。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"语言框架","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p53_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"形式推导与经验检验承担不同工作。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"逻辑经验主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p53_cross_T126","questionId":"T126","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释应服务于明确的问题，不必寻找语言之外的终极起点。","sourceIds":["source_p53"],"locator":"语言分析","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p53","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"区分“在一套语言规则内部找答案”与“要不要采用这套语言框架”，许多哲学争论会随之澄清。"},{"id":"p54","name":"奎因","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"《经验主义的两个教条》等整体论","matchScope":"怎样检验相互关联的知识","intro":"知识整体性、自然化与本体论","caution":"不将整体性等同任何观点都能随意保留","reading":{"title":"《经验主义的两个教条》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/quine/"},"sourceIds":["source_p54"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p54_c1","questionId":"T76","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"实验常常同时检验理论、测量和辅助条件，不能直接断定哪一项出了错。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"《经验主义的两个教条》等整体论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p54_c2","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"推理与经验在实际认识中相互配合。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"《经验主义的两个教条》等整体论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p54_c3","questionId":"V01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"预测失败时，也需要检查测量和其他假设。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"《经验主义的两个教条》等整体论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p54_cross_W02","questionId":"W02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"成熟科学所需的数学对象具有本体论承诺。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"本体论承诺","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p54_cross_T33","questionId":"T33","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"探究无须在科学之外另找不可怀疑的基础。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"自然化认识论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p54_contrast_T137","questionId":"T137","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"知识之间彼此关联，经验检验的是整张信念之网，而非孤立的单个判断。","sourceIds":["source_p54"],"locator":"整体论与经验检验","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p54","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"知识彼此关联，经验通常检验的是一整套相互配合的信念。"},{"id":"p55","name":"克里普克","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"《命名与必然性》中关于名字与必然性的论证","matchScope":"名字指什么、事实能否不同","intro":"指称、必然性与模态问题","caution":"需要先解释“必然”与“先验”的差别，不能依赖术语熟悉度","reading":{"title":"《命名与必然性》第一、二讲","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rigid-designators/"},"sourceIds":["source_p55"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p55_c1","questionId":"T77","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个名字可以沿着最初命名和后来交流的联系，继续指向同一个人。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"locator":"《命名与必然性》的指称与模态问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p55_c2","questionId":"T78","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"水由其物质组成决定，另一种液体即使外观和用途相同，也不是同一种物质。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"locator":"《命名与必然性》的指称与模态问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p55_cross_T75","questionId":"T75","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"关于对象本性的真理不单由语言框架的选择决定。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"locator":"命名与必然性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p55_cross_W01","questionId":"W01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对象的存在不依赖我们如何描述它。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"locator":"实在论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p55_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"后天发现的事实也可能揭示必然关系。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"locator":"后验必然性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p55","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"名字通过命名与传递指向固定的对象；有些必须靠经验发现的事实，也具有必然性。"},{"id":"p56","name":"伊丽莎白·安斯康姆","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"《意向》及现代道德哲学批评","matchScope":"有意的行动与行为理由","intro":"意向行动与现代伦理学批评","caution":"不把理由问题化约为事后借口，也不根据单题推出完整伦理立场","reading":{"title":"《意向》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anscombe/"},"sourceIds":["source_p56"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p56_c1","questionId":"T79","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"要判断一个人有意做了什么，需要了解他当时知道什么、为什么行动。","sourceIds":["source_p56"],"locator":"《意向》及现代道德哲学批评","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p56_c2","questionId":"T50","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"总体结果更好，仍不能自动使任何手段都正当。","sourceIds":["source_p56"],"locator":"《意向》及现代道德哲学批评","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p56_cross_T10","questionId":"T10","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德判断需要理解行动者、意图与实际处境。","sourceIds":["source_p56"],"locator":"现代道德哲学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p56_cross_FP04","questionId":"FP04","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"好的取舍离不开实践判断和品格。","sourceIds":["source_p56"],"locator":"德性与实践推理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p56_cross_T136","questionId":"T136","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不能只凭预期利益为杀害无辜者辩护。","sourceIds":["source_p56"],"locator":"意图与禁止","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p56","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"理解有意的行动，要问行动者在做什么、为什么这样做。"},{"id":"p57","name":"波普尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"科学划界与批判理性主义","matchScope":"理论怎样接受检验","intro":"科学划界、批判与可错性","caution":"不把一次反例机械理解为必须立即抛弃所有理论","reading":{"title":"《猜想与反驳》第一章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/"},"sourceIds":["source_p57"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p57_c1","questionId":"V04","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"科学理论需要允许某种结果证明自己有错。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"科学划界与批判理性主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p57_c2","questionId":"V01","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"预测与可靠观察不符时，应检查理论，并设计新实验区分解释。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"科学划界与批判理性主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p57_c3","questionId":"T67","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"想法要持续接受公开批评和检验。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"科学划界与批判理性主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p57_cross_T32","questionId":"T32","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有力的检验需要主动寻找反驳。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"批判理性主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p57_cross_Q05","questionId":"Q05","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"预测成功尚不足以证明一个理论是真理。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"猜想与反驳","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p57_contrast_T137","questionId":"T137","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"科学理论必须拿得出可能被事实推翻的预测，并在公开批评中接受检验。","sourceIds":["source_p57"],"locator":"猜想与反驳","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p57","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"科学理论要允许被事实反驳，知识在批评与修正中前进。"},{"id":"p58","name":"托马斯·库恩","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"分析与科学哲学","scope":"《科学革命的结构》的范式问题","matchScope":"科学方法怎样变化","intro":"范式、常规科学与科学变革","caution":"不等同“科学只是主观意见”或否定一切进步","reading":{"title":"《科学革命的结构》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/thomas-kuhn/"},"sourceIds":["source_p58"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p58_c1","questionId":"T80","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"科学变化可能连带改变重要问题、典型做法和判断标准。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"《科学革命的结构》的范式问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p58_c2","questionId":"V01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一套成熟的研究方法，通常不会因为一次异常就被全部放弃。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"《科学革命的结构》的范式问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p58_c3","questionId":"T76","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"实验结果自己不会说话，我们总要借助已有的理论、仪器和研究传统才能解读它。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"《科学革命的结构》的范式问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p58_cross_H01","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"科学观念应结合研究传统与历史环境理解。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"科学史","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p58_cross_Q05","questionId":"Q05","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"预测成功本身不能充分决定理论之间的选择。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"理论选择","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p58_contrast_T137","questionId":"T137","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不同的研究传统，会塑造各自认为重要的问题、范例和评价标准。","sourceIds":["source_p58"],"locator":"范式与科学革命","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p58","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"科学会沿既有方法积累，也会在危机中改变基本的研究方式。"},{"id":"p59","name":"胡塞尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"关于意识与经验描述的现象学方法","matchScope":"感受与认识的过程","intro":"意向性、经验描述与现象学方法","caution":"悬搁不等于否认外部世界；区分方法与存在论","reading":{"title":"《观念I》方法部分及现象学导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/husserl/"},"sourceIds":["source_p59"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p59_c1","questionId":"T81","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"把“外物是否独立存在”的争论搁置起来，可以专注研究事物如何在经验中呈现。","sourceIds":["source_p59"],"locator":"现象学方法、意向性与经验结构","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p59_c2","questionId":"T113","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"知觉并非被动接收印象，意识会带着过去的经验与期待，把感官印象组织成完整的对象。","sourceIds":["source_p59"],"locator":"现象学方法、意向性与经验结构","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p59_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"研究心灵与世界，就要分析它们在经验中怎样联系。","sourceIds":["source_p59"],"locator":"意向性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p59_cross_M02","questionId":"M02","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"亲身体验有需要被描述的自身内容。","sourceIds":["source_p59"],"locator":"第一人称经验","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p59_cross_Q11","questionId":"Q11","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对认识的分析不能由一套自然因果说明包办。","sourceIds":["source_p59"],"locator":"现象学与自然主义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p59","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"仔细描述事物如何在经验中呈现，追问意识怎样认识对象。"},{"id":"p60","name":"海德格尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《存在与时间》中关于日常生活与生命有限性的讨论","matchScope":"日常生活与有限的一生","intro":"在世存在、有限性与存在问题","caution":"不用“热爱自然”或“追求真实自我”等套话替代；必要时分时期","reading":{"title":"《存在与时间》在世存在及向死而在部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heidegger/"},"sourceIds":["source_p60"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p60_c1","questionId":"T82","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人通过做事、使用工具和与他人相处，理解自己生活的世界。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"《存在与时间》的在世存在与有限性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p60_c2","questionId":"T123","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"意识到生命有限，会让人面对必须由自己作出的生活选择。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"《存在与时间》的在世存在与有限性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p60_c3","questionId":"T124","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解自己，需要了解自己在已有条件下选择了怎样生活。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"《存在与时间》的在世存在与有限性","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p60_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解人的存在，要把心灵、身体和所处的世界放在一起考察。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"在世存在","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p60_cross_T70","questionId":"T70","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"亲历的时间结构不能由钟表刻度穷尽。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"时间性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p60_cross_T86","questionId":"T86","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解总从已有的生活与历史处境出发。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"解释学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p60_contrast_T138","questionId":"T138","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人只有直面生命的有限，才能从日常的随波逐流中醒来，亲自承担这一生该如何度过。","sourceIds":["source_p60"],"locator":"时间性与本真性","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p60","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人从一开始就置身于具体生活之中，直面生命的有限，才能真正认清属于自己的选择。"},{"id":"p61","name":"萨特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《存在与虚无》及存在主义伦理入口","matchScope":"处境中的选择与责任","intro":"自由、处境、自欺与责任","caution":"自由不等于不受条件限制，更不能等同没有因果影响","reading":{"title":"《存在主义是一种人道主义》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sartre/"},"sourceIds":["source_p61"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p61_c1","questionId":"T83","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"身份和处境会限制选择，却不能自动免除个人的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"《存在与虚无》及存在主义伦理入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p61_c2","questionId":"L02","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"通过选择并投入行动，人逐渐形成自己生活的意义。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"《存在与虚无》及存在主义伦理入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p61_c3","questionId":"T60","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人生中的重要承诺，不能永远等到有充分证明才作出。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"《存在与虚无》及存在主义伦理入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p61_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人通过处境中的选择形成自己。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"存在先于本质","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p61_cross_T62","questionId":"T62","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"价值需要通过实际选择和行动承担。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"自由与价值","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p61_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人的意识与身体应结合其具体在世活动理解。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"现象学本体论","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p61_contrast_T138","questionId":"T138","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人通过具体处境中的选择和行动成为自己，并要为这些选择负起无法推卸的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"自由、处境与自我形成","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true},{"id":"p61_contrast_T139","questionId":"T139","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"哪怕处境再艰难，人依然拥有选择如何回应的自由，也必须承担由此带来的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p61"],"locator":"存在主义的自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p61","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人在具体处境中选择，也要承担自己选择的责任。"},{"id":"p62","name":"西蒙娜·德·波伏瓦","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《第二性》与《模糊性的伦理学》","matchScope":"教育、社会条件与自由","intro":"处境中的自由、他者化与性别","caution":"不只根据性别或赞成平等分配人物；保留伦理与社会结构依据","reading":{"title":"《模糊性的伦理学》《第二性》导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/beauvoir/"},"sourceIds":["source_p62"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p62_c1","questionId":"T84","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"规则允许作出选择，还不代表每个人实际上都有同样的自由。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"《第二性》与《模糊性的伦理学》","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p62_c2","questionId":"T48","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一些看似天生的差异，可能由教育和社会安排造成。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"《第二性》与《模糊性的伦理学》","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p62_c3","questionId":"T83","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"既要看到行动受到哪些限制，也要面对自己仍能作出的选择。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"《第二性》与《模糊性的伦理学》","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p62_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"一个人不能被固定的天性说明，生活通过实际选择展开。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"存在主义伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p62_cross_T53","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由需要能够实际运用的社会条件。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"处境与压迫","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p62_cross_T91","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"满意可能来自受压迫的生活适应，并不足以证明自由。","sourceIds":["source_p62"],"locator":"模糊性的伦理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p62","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人的自由受到社会处境影响，平等需要改变限制人的条件。"},{"id":"p63","name":"加缪","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《西西弗神话》《反抗者》的问题范围","matchScope":"人生意义与反抗的限度","intro":"荒诞、反抗与行动限度","caution":"不把荒诞等同虚无主义；此分组不强称其自认存在主义者","reading":{"title":"《西西弗神话》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/camus/"},"sourceIds":["source_p63"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p63_c2","questionId":"Q07","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"得不到最终的意义，也可以继续肯定生活。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"《西西弗神话》《反抗者》的问题范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p63_c3","questionId":"T136","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"反抗应当尊重人的生命，不能为了未来的理想而无限伤害眼前的人。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"《西西弗神话》《反抗者》的问题范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p63_c1","questionId":"T85","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"即使找不到人生最终的答案，仍然可以认真投入生活。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"《西西弗神话》《反抗者》的问题范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p63_cross_T60","questionId":"T60","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"无法得到最终证明，也仍须实际决定怎样生活。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"荒诞与行动","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p63_cross_L01","questionId":"L01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"艰难本身不足以取消生活与行动的价值。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"反抗","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p63_cross_H04","questionId":"H04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"历史没有保证通向完满结局的方向。","sourceIds":["source_p63"],"locator":"对历史绝对主义的批评","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p63","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"就算世界保持沉默、人生没有终极答案，人依然可以清醒地投入生活，并在反抗中守护具体的人。"},{"id":"p64","name":"梅洛-庞蒂","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《知觉现象学》的身体主体","matchScope":"身体怎样参与感知","intro":"身体、知觉与主体","caution":"不将具身经验直接等同某一种神经科学还原论","reading":{"title":"《知觉现象学》身体部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/merleau-ponty/"},"sourceIds":["source_p64"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p64_c1","questionId":"M04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"身体能做什么，会影响周围事物对我们的意义。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"《知觉现象学》的身体主体","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p64_c2","questionId":"Q09","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解感受，还需要考虑身体其他部分和所处环境。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"《知觉现象学》的身体主体","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p64_c3","questionId":"T82","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人通过实际使用、行动和交往，学会理解环境。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"《知觉现象学》的身体主体","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p64_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"心灵与身体应在具体感知和行动中共同理解。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"身体主体","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p64_cross_T113","questionId":"T113","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"经验从一开始就带有身体习惯和既有理解。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"知觉现象学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p64_cross_T124","questionId":"T124","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"经历与共同生活也参与构成一个人。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"主体间性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p64_contrast_T138","questionId":"T138","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人的主体性离不开身体习惯、知觉体验，以及与他人共处的现实环境。","sourceIds":["source_p64"],"locator":"身体主体与主体间性","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p64","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"我们通过身体感知和行动，身体与处境共同参与对世界的理解。"},{"id":"p65","name":"伽达默尔","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《真理与方法》的哲学解释学","matchScope":"历史处境中的理解","intro":"理解、传统与解释学","caution":"不等同所有解释一样好；不能把承认处境推成全面相对主义","reading":{"title":"《真理与方法》理解与历史效果部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/gadamer/"},"sourceIds":["source_p65"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p65_c1","questionId":"T86","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解总带着自己的时代和经验，但可以在阅读与对话中检查、修改已有看法。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"《真理与方法》的哲学解释学","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p65_c2","questionId":"G03","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"读者的经历会参与作品的理解。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"《真理与方法》的哲学解释学","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p65_c3","questionId":"H02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"需要检查自己是否把学来的观念，当成事物本来就该如此。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"《真理与方法》的哲学解释学","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p65_cross_G01","questionId":"G01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"意义需要结合共同语言与具体情境理解。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"语言与理解","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p65_cross_T105","questionId":"T105","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解文本不能只停留在字面，而要进入文本所要回应的问题与意义之中。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"解释学","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p65_cross_T33","questionId":"T33","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解可以从已有的经验和看法出发，在对话中逐步修正。","sourceIds":["source_p65"],"locator":"效果历史","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p65","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"理解总从自己的历史处境出发，并在对话中不断展开。"},{"id":"p66","name":"列维纳斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《总体与无限》等关于他者责任的入口","matchScope":"对陌生人的责任","intro":"他者、责任与伦理优先性","caution":"不将他者伦理简化为一般利他性或服从任何他人要求","reading":{"title":"《伦理与无限》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/levinas/"},"sourceIds":["source_p66"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p66_c1","questionId":"T87","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"他人的需要能够带来回应的责任，这种责任早于交换或承诺。","sourceIds":["source_p66"],"locator":"《总体与无限》等关于他者责任的入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p66_c2","questionId":"T50","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"他人有自己的生活，不能仅仅被当作完成我的计划的工具。","sourceIds":["source_p66"],"locator":"《总体与无限》等关于他者责任的入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p66_cross_T136","questionId":"T136","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不能以整体历史的名义抹去具体个人。","sourceIds":["source_p66"],"locator":"总体与无限","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p66","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"与他人的相遇使我们承担责任，伦理从回应他人开始。"},{"id":"p67","name":"汉娜·阿伦特","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《人的境况》的行动与公共空间","matchScope":"公共参与与共同行动","intro":"行动、公共空间、多元性与判断","caution":"不把全部思想缩成“平庸之恶”；不同作品中的问题分别标注","reading":{"title":"《人的境况》第五章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/arendt/"},"sourceIds":["source_p67"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p67_c1","questionId":"T88","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"政治生活包括公开表达不同意见、一起发起行动。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"《人的境况》的行动与公共空间","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p67_c2","questionId":"H03","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人们应有实际参与和发声的机会。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"《人的境况》的行动与公共空间","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p67_c3","questionId":"T83","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"担任某种职务，也仍需要自己判断并承担责任。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"《人的境况》的行动与公共空间","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p67_cross_T53","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"政治自由需要共同生活中的实际空间。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"公共自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p67_cross_C02","questionId":"C02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"共同事务需要让不同的人实际发声。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"多元性与判断","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p67_cross_T47","questionId":"T47","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"共同参与不只是保护私人生活的手段。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"行动与公民","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p67_contrast_T139","questionId":"T139","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由必须在公共空间中实现，意味着能与他人一起公开发声、共同发起行动。","sourceIds":["source_p67"],"locator":"行动、公共空间与自由","mappingStatus":"editorial_comparative_emphasis","comparison":true,"emphasis":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p67","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人们在公共空间共同说话和行动，才能实现政治自由。"},{"id":"p68","name":"瓦尔特·本雅明","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"技术复制与历史经验论述","matchScope":"复制、独特性与历史经验","intro":"艺术媒介、复制技术与历史经验","caution":"不以怀旧或喜欢原作简单推断其理论","reading":{"title":"《机械复制时代的艺术作品》","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/benjamin/"},"sourceIds":["source_p68"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p68_c1","questionId":"T89","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"复制技术会改变人在哪里、以什么方式接触作品，以及作品与传统的联系。","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"locator":"技术复制与历史经验论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p68_c2","questionId":"A02","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"复制品视觉上相同，也不会拥有原作的创作和流传经历。","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"locator":"技术复制与历史经验论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p68_c3","questionId":"H04","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"谈历史进步时，需要看见哪些人付出了代价。","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"locator":"技术复制与历史经验论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p68_cross_H01","questionId":"H01","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"艺术与观念的形成和社会历史条件相连。","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"locator":"历史与艺术","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p68_cross_T90","questionId":"T90","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"文化的生产和传播会塑造感受方式。","sourceIds":["source_p68"],"locator":"技术与大众","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p68","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"技术复制改变艺术的独特性，也改变人们经验历史的方式。"},{"id":"p69","name":"阿多诺","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"文化工业与否定辩证法的问题入口","matchScope":"喜好怎样形成、分类的限度","intro":"文化工业、同一性批判与艺术","caution":"不将喜欢大众文化的用户判为低级，也不等同反娱乐","reading":{"title":"《启蒙辩证法》文化工业部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/adorno/"},"sourceIds":["source_p69"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p69_c1","questionId":"T90","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"商业文化的制作和传播方式，也会逐渐培养观众的喜好。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"文化工业与否定辩证法的问题入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p69_c2","questionId":"T125","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个分类未必能说清每个具体事物的全部特征。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"文化工业与否定辩证法的问题入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p69_c3","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"即使人感到满意，仍需要检查他实际拥有怎样的选择。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"文化工业与否定辩证法的问题入口","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p69_cross_H02","questionId":"H02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"需要追问习以为常的观念如何形成。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"意识形态批判","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p69_cross_T136","questionId":"T136","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"具体个体的苦难不能被未来总体轻易抵销。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"对同一性思维的批判","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p69_cross_H04","questionId":"H04","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"历史并不自动保证走向更好的状态。","sourceIds":["source_p69"],"locator":"历史与灾难","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p69","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"审视社会怎样塑造需要和喜好，保留不能被统一分类的差异。"},{"id":"p70","name":"马尔库塞","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"《单向度的人》的需要与自由问题","matchScope":"满意、需要与社会限制","intro":"需要、技术理性与社会批判","caution":"不自动将他人需要判为虚假；需要说明规范判断依据","reading":{"title":"《单向度的人》第一章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marcuse/"},"sourceIds":["source_p70"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p70_c1","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个人的欲望可能受社会限制，因此感到满足也可能缺少自由。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"《单向度的人》的需要与自由问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p70_c2","questionId":"T90","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"反复接触某些文化形式，会影响人觉得自己需要什么。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"《单向度的人》的需要与自由问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p70_c3","questionId":"H03","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"检查习以为常的观念，有助于理解社会还能怎样改变。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"《单向度的人》的需要与自由问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p70_cross_D01","questionId":"D01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"欲望如何被制造，会影响一个人能否自主。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"单向度的人","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p70_cross_T84","questionId":"T84","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"形式许可并不保证实际的选择能力。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"压抑与解放","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p70_cross_T53","questionId":"T53","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"自由的实现与社会条件有关。","sourceIds":["source_p70"],"locator":"社会批判","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p70","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"社会也会塑造人的需要，人甚至可能在受支配的生活里感到满足。"},{"id":"p71","name":"哈贝马斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"话语伦理与交往理性","matchScope":"平等讨论与公共规则","intro":"交往、公共理由与正当性","caution":"不等同多数投票或“大家同意即真”","reading":{"title":"《道德意识与交往行为》相关论文","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/habermas/"},"sourceIds":["source_p71"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p71_c1","questionId":"T92","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"规则要向受影响者说明理由，并接受平等、免于强迫的讨论。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"话语伦理与交往理性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p71_c2","questionId":"E02","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"道德规则应当能被受影响的人在平等讨论中接受。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"话语伦理与交往理性","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p71_c3","questionId":"C02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"多数人赞成，也仍需要认真听取少数人的理由。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"话语伦理与交往理性","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p71_cross_T47","questionId":"T47","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"共同规则的正当性与公民参与相连。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"商谈政治","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p71_cross_T134","questionId":"T134","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"公共决定应当接受受影响者参与和监督。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"民主与合法性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p71_cross_T65","questionId":"T65","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"多元公共生活需要容纳不同的生活选择。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"交往与多元性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p71_cross_H03","questionId":"H03","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"受影响的人参与公共讨论，是形成正当制度的重要条件。","sourceIds":["source_p71"],"locator":"《在事实与规范之间》；4.1 The Two-Tracked Theory of Democracy","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p71","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"公共规则的正当性，需要平等参与者能够相互说明理由。"},{"id":"p72","name":"福柯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"谱系学与规训时期的权力知识问题","matchScope":"社会标准怎样影响人","intro":"权力、知识、规范与主体形成","caution":"不等同万事皆阴谋、真理不存在；按时期和问题区别","reading":{"title":"《规训与惩罚》及相关访谈","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/foucault/"},"sourceIds":["source_p72"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p72_c1","questionId":"T93","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"制度中的分类和评价，也会影响人怎样看待自己、要求自己改变。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"谱系学与规训时期的权力知识问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p72_c2","questionId":"H01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"要考察哪些权力和制度，使某种说法成为大家默认的标准。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"谱系学与规训时期的权力知识问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p72_c3","questionId":"H02","supports":["B","C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"追问观念的形成过程、谁从中受益，以及哪些想法被排除，有助于理解观念与权力的联系。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"谱系学与规训时期的权力知识问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p72_cross_D01","questionId":"D01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"形成欲望与身份的过程也可能包含支配。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"主体化","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p72_cross_T84","questionId":"T84","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"既有规范会限制实际的生活可能。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"权力与主体","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p72_cross_T91","questionId":"T91","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"本人感到满意，仍可能处在隐蔽的规范约束中。","sourceIds":["source_p72"],"locator":"规训","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p72","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"追问医院、学校和社会如何定义“正常”，揭示知识与权力怎样在日常规范中塑造人。"},{"id":"p73","name":"德里达","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"解构、差异与文本问题","matchScope":"概念的对立与相互依赖","intro":"文本、差异与概念对立的解构","caution":"不等同任意解释或“没有意义”；不能以玩文字游戏匹配","reading":{"title":"《论文字学》导论及解构入门","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/derrida/"},"sourceIds":["source_p73"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p73_c1","questionId":"T94","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"一个被视为更重要的概念，可能要靠被贬低的那一面才能解释清楚。","sourceIds":["source_p73"],"locator":"解构、差异与文本问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p73_c2","questionId":"T126","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"词语的意思需要通过与其他词的区别和联系来说明。","sourceIds":["source_p73"],"locator":"解构、差异与文本问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p73_cross_T125","questionId":"T125","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"具体事物不会被一个封闭分类完全穷尽。","sourceIds":["source_p73"],"locator":"解构与差异","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p73_cross_G03","questionId":"G03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"文本可以产生超出作者自觉意图的意义。","sourceIds":["source_p73"],"locator":"文本与意图","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":2,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p73","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"从互相对立的概念入手，揭示被排斥的一方如何影响另一方。"},{"id":"p74","name":"德勒兹","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"现象学与欧陆思想","scope":"差异、生成与创造问题","matchScope":"新事物怎样形成","intro":"差异、生成与创造","caution":"不将喜欢新奇、反对标签或一般创造力等同其哲学","reading":{"title":"《差异与重复》导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/deleuze/"},"sourceIds":["source_p74"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p74_c1","questionId":"T95","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"理解新事物时，要考察它怎样形成新的差别，而不只是给它归类。","sourceIds":["source_p74"],"locator":"差异、生成与创造问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p74_c2","questionId":"T52","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然能形成新的结构，不能只看成被动的材料拼装。","sourceIds":["source_p74"],"locator":"差异、生成与创造问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p74_c3","questionId":"T62","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"尝试创造新的生活可能和价值，而不只恢复原来的标准。","sourceIds":["source_p74"],"locator":"差异、生成与创造问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p74_cross_T04","questionId":"T04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"形成、变化与差异本身能够成为认识对象。","sourceIds":["source_p74"],"locator":"差异与重复","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p74_cross_T125","questionId":"T125","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"固定分类无法说尽实际生成的事物。","sourceIds":["source_p74"],"locator":"差异","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p74","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"从差异和变化出发，理解新事物怎样产生。"},{"id":"p75","name":"罗尔斯","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"当代政治哲学","scope":"《正义论》的公平正义","matchScope":"自由、机会与最困难者","intro":"公平、基本自由与制度正义","caution":"不等同收入完全相同；题目要区分基本自由、机会与分配原则","reading":{"title":"《正义论》原初状态与两原则部分","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rawls/"},"sourceIds":["source_p75"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p75_c1","questionId":"T96","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"设想不知道自己将处于什么地位，再选择保障自由、机会和最困难者的制度。","sourceIds":["source_p75"],"locator":"《正义论》的公平正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p75_c2","questionId":"C01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"制度应尽量避免出身决定一个人实际拥有的机会。","sourceIds":["source_p75"],"locator":"《正义论》的公平正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p75_c3","questionId":"C02","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"每个人的基本自由不能只为了增加总体好处就被牺牲。","sourceIds":["source_p75"],"locator":"《正义论》的公平正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p75_cross_T50","questionId":"T50","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"基本自由不能只为增加总体福利而牺牲。","sourceIds":["source_p75"],"locator":"正义的优先性","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p75_cross_T97","questionId":"T97","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"制度差距应当能够改善最不利者处境。","sourceIds":["source_p75"],"locator":"差别原则","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p75","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"保障平等的基本自由与公平机会，使制度也有利于最困难的人。"},{"id":"p76","name":"诺齐克","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"当代政治哲学","scope":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》的权利、持有正义与体验机器讨论","matchScope":"财产来历、个人权利与真实生活","intro":"权利、持有正义与国家限度","caution":"不能忽略正义取得、转让和矫正问题，也不能将富裕偏好视为证据","reading":{"title":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》第七章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nozick-political/"},"sourceIds":["source_p76","nozick_experience"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p76_c1","questionId":"T97","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"判断财产是否正当，需要考察最初如何取得、后来怎样转让，以及过去的侵害是否得到纠正。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》的持有正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p76_c2","questionId":"C01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"正当取得的财产和自愿转让，应受到尊重。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》的持有正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p76_c3","questionId":"C02","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"实现公共目标时，也需要尊重个人权利。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》的持有正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p76_c4","questionId":"FP03","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"正当取得和自愿交易产生的收益，应受权利保护，缩小差距本身不足以使强制再分配正当。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》第七章的资格理论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p76_c5","questionId":"Q01","supports":["B","C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"美好的感受之外，人还在意真实地做事、成为怎样的人，以及与现实的联系。","sourceIds":["nozick_experience"],"locator":"《无政府、国家与乌托邦》体验机器讨论，42—45页","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p76_cross_T50","questionId":"T50","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"个人权利对实现集体目标构成边界。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"权利边界","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p76_cross_T65","questionId":"T65","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不受他人伤害的个人生活应保有选择空间。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"个人权利","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p76_cross_T96","questionId":"T96","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"公平不能仅按最终分配模式判断。","sourceIds":["source_p76"],"locator":"持有正义","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p76","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"尊重个人权利与正当取得的财产，也在意感受之外真实发生的生活。"},{"id":"p77","name":"孔子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《论语》的仁礼与关系实践","matchScope":"关系中的责任与修养","intro":"仁、礼、修养与关系中的责任","caution":"不把重视家庭直接等同儒家；不能将具体语境原则无限外推","reading":{"title":"《论语》学而、颜渊等篇","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/confucius/"},"sourceIds":["source_p77"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p77_c1","questionId":"T98","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"练习恰当的礼节，有助于学会关心、尊重别人和把握相处分寸。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"《论语》的仁礼与关系实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p77_c2","questionId":"Q12","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"对家人、朋友等亲近的人，人有一份特别的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"《论语》的仁礼与关系实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p77_c3","questionId":"P02","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"好的品格可以在具体的人际关系中学习、培养。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"《论语》的仁礼与关系实践","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p77_cross_T10","questionId":"T10","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德判断需要结合具体关系中的分寸。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"仁与礼","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p77_cross_P01","questionId":"P01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"德性需要在日常实践中养成。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"学习与修养","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p77_cross_T104","questionId":"T104","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"治理者的道德示范对共同生活有重要作用。","sourceIds":["source_p77"],"locator":"为政以德","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p77","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"从日常关系中实践仁与礼，通过修养成为能够担当的人。"},{"id":"p78","name":"孟子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《孟子》的道德端绪与民生","matchScope":"道德萌芽与生活条件","intro":"道德萌芽、扩充与政治关怀","caution":"性善不等于人天然不会作恶；需保留发展与环境条件","reading":{"title":"《孟子》公孙丑上、梁惠王上","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mencius/"},"sourceIds":["source_p78"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p78_c1","questionId":"T99","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"自然产生的同情，可以进一步培养成稳定、广泛的道德关心。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"《孟子》的道德端绪与民生","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p78_c2","questionId":"T127","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"生活有保障，是道德成长的重要条件。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"《孟子》的道德端绪与民生","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p78_c3","questionId":"P02","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"教育可以保护和引导人已有的同情心。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"《孟子》的道德端绪与民生","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p78_cross_T55","questionId":"T55","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"同情之心能够成为道德成长的起点。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"恻隐之心","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p78_cross_T135","questionId":"T135","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人具有可以培养的道德端绪。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"四端","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p78_cross_T104","questionId":"T104","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"仁政需要治理者真实关心人的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p78"],"locator":"仁政","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p78","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"人有向善的萌芽，需要培养，也需要能够安定生活的条件。"},{"id":"p79","name":"荀子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《荀子》的礼义与学习","matchScope":"人为学习与欲望安排","intro":"礼、学习、欲望与人为实践","caution":"性恶不等于每个人都恶毒；“伪”不是现代虚伪之意","reading":{"title":"《荀子》劝学、礼论、性恶","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/xunzi/"},"sourceIds":["source_p79"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p79_c1","questionId":"T100","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人需要学习礼义和行为规范，才能形成良好秩序。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"《荀子》的礼义与学习","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p79_c2","questionId":"T98","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"学习和练习礼义，能逐渐引导人的情感、欲望与行为。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"《荀子》的礼义与学习","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p79_c3","questionId":"P02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"通过规矩和练习，可以形成可靠的习惯。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"《荀子》的礼义与学习","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p79_cross_T99","questionId":"T99","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"可靠的善行需要后天学习和人为培养。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"性恶与化性起伪","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p79_cross_T135","questionId":"T135","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德判断需要学习、积累和辨明事理。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"学习与心","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p79_cross_P01","questionId":"P01","supports":["C"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"习惯与教育有助于把认识落实为行动。","sourceIds":["source_p79"],"locator":"修身","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p79","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"通过学习、礼与实践安排欲望，人的品格可以后天养成。"},{"id":"p80","name":"墨子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《墨子》的兼爱与非攻论述","matchScope":"关心陌生人、反对侵略","intro":"兼爱、非攻与公共利害","caution":"不直接等同现代功利主义或取消一切关系差异","reading":{"title":"《墨子》兼爱、非攻","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mohism/"},"sourceIds":["source_p80"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p80_c1","questionId":"T101","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"考虑公共利益时，不能因关系疏远就轻视某些人。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"《墨子》的兼爱与非攻论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p80_c2","questionId":"T128","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"评价进攻战争，不能只算己方获利而忽略对他人的伤害。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"《墨子》的兼爱与非攻论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p80_c3","questionId":"T63","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不同人的痛苦都应受到认真考虑。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"《墨子》的兼爱与非攻论述","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p80_cross_FP04","questionId":"FP04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"公共取舍需要认真计算对人们的实际利害。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"兼爱与交利","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p80_cross_T12","questionId":"T12","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"礼仪与排场不应凌驾于实际民生。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"节用与非乐","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p80_cross_T55","questionId":"T55","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德主张应当接受公共利益的检验。","sourceIds":["source_p80"],"locator":"三表与实利","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p80","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"关心他人的利益不应只限亲近者，并反对带来伤害的侵略。"},{"id":"p81","name":"老子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《老子》中的无为与少欲","matchScope":"少欲与减少强制干预","intro":"道、无为、欲望与治理","caution":"无为不等于什么都不做；人物与文本形成问题要说明","reading":{"title":"《老子》第三十七、四十八、五十七章","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/laozi/"},"sourceIds":["source_p81"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p81_c1","questionId":"T102","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"过多的规定和干预，可能打乱生活原有的协调。","sourceIds":["source_p81"],"locator":"《老子》的无为与少欲；不作确切传记断言","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p81_c2","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人应当减少无止境的欲求和外界名利的驱使，回归知足与安宁。","sourceIds":["source_p81"],"locator":"《老子》的无为与少欲；不作确切传记断言","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p81_c3","questionId":"T12","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"淡泊名声与排场，减少对虚名的追逐。","sourceIds":["source_p81"],"locator":"《老子》的无为与少欲；不作确切传记断言","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p81_cross_P03","questionId":"P03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"过多刻意控制可能妨碍自然协调。","sourceIds":["source_p81"],"locator":"无为","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p81_cross_T106","questionId":"T106","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"万物的根源不必是有固定形状的具体物。","sourceIds":["source_p81"],"locator":"道与无","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p81","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"减少欲望和强制干预，让事物依其自身的方式生长。"},{"id":"p82","name":"庄子","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《庄子》内篇的视角与技艺问题","matchScope":"尺度、视角与熟练生活","intro":"视角、齐物、技艺与自由","caution":"不等同所有判断一样好，也不把逃避责任包装为逍遥","reading":{"title":"《庄子》齐物论、养生主","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zhuangzi/"},"sourceIds":["source_p82"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p82_c1","questionId":"T103","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"换个处境看问题，可以发现自己习惯的标准也有局限。","sourceIds":["source_p82"],"locator":"《庄子》内篇的视角与技艺问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p82_c2","questionId":"P03","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"经过充分练习的动作，可以不再紧盯每一步控制。","sourceIds":["source_p82"],"locator":"《庄子》内篇的视角与技艺问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p82_c3","questionId":"T04","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"理解事物可以从它怎样变化开始。","sourceIds":["source_p82"],"locator":"《庄子》内篇的视角与技艺问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p82_cross_T125","questionId":"T125","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"分类和言说难以穷尽实际生活。","sourceIds":["source_p82"],"locator":"名与实","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p82","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"不同视角各有局限，减少执着，在变化中自在生活。"},{"id":"p83","name":"韩非","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《韩非子》的制度、名实与赏罚","matchScope":"君主权力与官员考核","intro":"法、术、势与制度运行","caution":"法家之法不等同现代法治；不根据强硬性格进行匹配","reading":{"title":"《韩非子》定法、二柄等篇","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/chinese-legalism/"},"sourceIds":["source_p83"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p83_c2","questionId":"T129","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"核对实际表现与职责承诺，再按照制度赏罚。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"《韩非子》的制度、名实与赏罚","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p83_c3","questionId":"T134","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"统治者应保留赏罚和任免的权力，防止下属借权位反过来控制自己。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"《韩非子》的制度、名实与赏罚","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p83_c1","questionId":"T104","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"管理需要明确的制度、职责和职权，不能只依赖个人品德。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"《韩非子》的制度、名实与赏罚","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p83_cross_T98","questionId":"T98","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"治理秩序主要依赖制度化的赏罚。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"法术势","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p83_cross_T100","questionId":"T100","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"制度设计需要考虑人趋利避害的行为。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"人情与制度","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p83_cross_T35","questionId":"T35","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"集中而有效的政治权威是治理的前提。","sourceIds":["source_p83"],"locator":"君主与权势","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p83","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"以制度核对官员的职责和表现，由君主掌握赏罚与任免。"},{"id":"p84","name":"王弼","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《老子注》《周易略例》中关于字句、含义和万物根源的讨论","matchScope":"字句与含义、万物的根本","intro":"魏晋玄学、言意与本末","caution":"不把“无”简单解释成什么都没有；区分注释语境","reading":{"title":"《周易略例·明象》《老子注》","url":"https://iep.utm.edu/wangbi/"},"sourceIds":["source_p84"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p84_c1","questionId":"T105","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"字句和形象是理解意思的工具，不能只停在字面。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"《老子注》《周易略例》的解释与本末问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p84_c2","questionId":"T106","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"万物可以依赖一个没有具体形状的根源而存在。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"《老子注》《周易略例》的解释与本末问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p84_c3","questionId":"T102","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"过度干预可能妨碍事物原本的运转。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"《老子注》《周易略例》的解释与本末问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p84_cross_T17","questionId":"T17","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有形万物需要从统一而无形的本根理解。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"以无为本","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p84_cross_T13","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"减少外在欲求，有助于恢复自然协调。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"崇本息末","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p84_cross_P03","questionId":"P03","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"过度刻意施为可能妨碍自然发挥。","sourceIds":["source_p84"],"locator":"自然与无为","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p84","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"把握言辞背后的含义，从万物的共同根本理解具体差异。"},{"id":"p85","name":"朱熹","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"朱子格物穷理与修养论","matchScope":"求知道理与改进行为","intro":"理、格物与道德修养","caution":"不把格物等同现代实验科学，也不贴简单外在知识标签","reading":{"title":"《大学章句》《朱子语类》格物相关卷","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zhu-xi/"},"sourceIds":["source_p85"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p85_c1","questionId":"T107","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"认真研究具体事情的道理，可以帮助人改进行为。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"朱子格物穷理与修养论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p85_c2","questionId":"T98","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B","C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"在日常相处中认真践行礼节，有助于养成好品格。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"朱子格物穷理与修养论","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p85_c3","questionId":"Q07","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"有些事情本身值得做，不只因为自己当下喜欢。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"朱子格物穷理与修养论","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p85_cross_T135","questionId":"T135","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德直觉需要通过学习事理进一步澄清。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"格物致知","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p85_cross_P01","questionId":"P01","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识与践行有联系，也有需要分别用功之处。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"知先行后","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p85_cross_P02","questionId":"P02","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"长期的礼义学习和练习能够改变品格。","sourceIds":["source_p85"],"locator":"居敬与穷理","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p85","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"通过考察事物求知道理，并在日常实践中改善品格。"},{"id":"p86","name":"王阳明","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"中国哲学","scope":"《传习录》的知行与良知问题","matchScope":"是非觉察与知行合一","intro":"良知、知行与道德实践","caution":"知行合一不等同效率口号；心即理不等同任意主观偏好","reading":{"title":"《传习录》知行合一与良知段落","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wang-yangming/"},"sourceIds":["source_p86"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p86_c1","questionId":"P01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"真正知道应当怎样做，会在行动中表现出来；知与行不能割裂。","sourceIds":["source_p86"],"locator":"《传习录》的知行与良知问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p86_c2","questionId":"T130","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"内心既然已经觉察是非，就不应再用借口遮蔽良知，真知必然落实在当下的行动上。","sourceIds":["source_p86"],"locator":"《传习录》的知行与良知问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p86_c3","questionId":"T107","supports":["B"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不能一直等到从外面学够了道理，才开始行动。","sourceIds":["source_p86"],"locator":"《传习录》的知行与良知问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p86_c4","questionId":"T135","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"人心有分辨是非的良知，修养在于去除私欲的遮蔽并切实行动。","sourceIds":["source_p86"],"locator":"《传习录》的知行与良知问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p86_cross_T116","questionId":"T116","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"道德领会需要落实在日常行动中。","sourceIds":["source_p86"],"locator":"知行合一","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p86","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"内心能觉察是非，真正的知道应当落实为行动。"},{"id":"p87","name":"释迦牟尼","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"佛教思想","scope":"早期佛教经典中的无常、无我与苦的教说","matchScope":"变化、执着与自我","intro":"苦、无常、无我与缘起的核心入口","caution":"不将全部佛教后期理论归于历史佛陀；必须限定文本传统与教说范围","reading":{"title":"早期经典的五蕴、四谛与无我相关教说","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/buddha/"},"sourceIds":["source_p87"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p87_c1","questionId":"T109","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"身体与经验的变化可以得到解释，即使其中没有一个独立不变的主宰。","sourceIds":["source_p87"],"locator":"早期佛教教说档案，非全部后世佛教","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p87_c2","questionId":"T110","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"看清事物会变化，以及紧抓不放怎样带来痛苦。","sourceIds":["source_p87"],"locator":"早期佛教教说档案，非全部后世佛教","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p87_c3","questionId":"P04","supports":["B"],"opposes":[],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"别人的评价之所以让人烦恼，往往是因为我们太执着于一个固定的“自我”形象。","sourceIds":["source_p87"],"locator":"早期佛教教说档案，非全部后世佛教","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p87_cross_T13","questionId":"T13","supports":["A"],"opposes":["C"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"持续扩大欲求并不能带来稳定安宁。","sourceIds":["source_p87"],"locator":"苦与渴爱","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p87_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"人可以从身心相依的过程理解。","sourceIds":["source_p87"],"locator":"五蕴与非我","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p87","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"一切依条件而生、不断变化，减少执着可以减轻痛苦。"},{"id":"p88","name":"龙树","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"佛教思想","scope":"《中论》的缘起、空与二谛问题","matchScope":"事物依靠条件而存在","intro":"中观、缘起、空与二谛","caution":"空不等于不存在，不归入一条简单西方反实在论轴","reading":{"title":"《中论》第二十四章及相关释读","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nagarjuna/"},"sourceIds":["source_p88"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p88_c1","questionId":"T111","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"事物由相互依赖的条件形成，没有脱离条件的固定本性，仍能生长和发挥作用。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"《中论》的缘起、空与二谛问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p88_c2","questionId":"T112","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"“空”说明事物没有独立不变的本性；它本身也不能被当成独立的东西。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"《中论》的缘起、空与二谛问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p88_c3","questionId":"T109","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"不把独立不变的自我当作解释经验的前提。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"《中论》的缘起、空与二谛问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p88_cross_T106","questionId":"T106","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"万物都靠条件彼此相依而生，说清这些关系就够了，不必在万物背后另找一个独立的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"缘起性空","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p88_cross_W04","questionId":"W04","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"解释不必以独立不变的最终实体为终点。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"中观","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p88_cross_T110","questionId":"T110","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"对固定本性的执著与痛苦相连。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"locator":"空与解脱","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p88","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"事物依赖条件而存在，没有独立不变的本性。"},{"id":"p89","name":"世亲","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"佛教思想","scope":"以《唯识二十论》相关认识问题为范围","matchScope":"经验怎样形成","intro":"阿毗达磨与唯识的重要思想家","caution":"作品归属、阶段与解释有争议；不把唯识等同“只有我存在”","reading":{"title":"《唯识二十论》及学术导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/vasubandhu/"},"sourceIds":["source_p89"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p89_c1","questionId":"T113","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"记忆、习惯和认识活动，参与了经验怎样形成。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"以《唯识二十论》相关认识问题为范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p89_c2","questionId":"T114","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"经验中出现某个对象，还不能直接证明它在心识之外独立存在。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"以《唯识二十论》相关认识问题为范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p89_c3","questionId":"T109","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"经验可以延续，支撑它的未必是一个独立不变的自我。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"以《唯识二十论》相关认识问题为范围","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p89_cross_T34","questionId":"T34","supports":["C"],"opposes":["A","B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"认识应从身心经验的形成过程分析。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"识的转变","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p89_cross_T131","questionId":"T131","supports":["C"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"就算我们每次看到的经验都很稳定，也不能直接证明心外有独立的实体。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"唯识","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p89_cross_T110","questionId":"T110","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"改变对自我与对象的执著是修行的重要内容。","sourceIds":["source_p89"],"locator":"转依","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p89","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"经验由多种条件共同形成，认识世界也要考察心识的作用。"},{"id":"p90","name":"慧能","kind":"philosopher","epoch":"佛教思想","scope":"《坛经》中的见性与日常修行教说","matchScope":"顿悟与日常修行","intro":"禅宗、见性与修行方式的重要代表","caution":"不将顿悟等同不必学习修行；《坛经》文本层累需标注","reading":{"title":"《坛经》相关段落及禅宗学术导论","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/buddhism-chan/"},"sourceIds":["source_p90"],"matchLabel":"在这个议题上局部接近","claims":[{"id":"p90_c1","questionId":"T115","supports":["A"],"opposes":[],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"对事物的领会可能突然发生，并改变原来的看法。","sourceIds":["source_p90"],"locator":"《坛经》相关教说档案；保留文本层累问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p90_c2","questionId":"T116","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":2,"core":true,"position":"领会应当在吃饭、做事和待人等日常行动中体现。","sourceIds":["source_p90"],"locator":"《坛经》相关教说档案；保留文本层累问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_core_analogy"},{"id":"p90_c3","questionId":"T109","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"修行不以维持一个独立不变的自我为目标。","sourceIds":["source_p90"],"locator":"《坛经》相关教说档案；保留文本层累问题","mappingStatus":"editorial_supporting_analogy"},{"id":"p90_cross_P01","questionId":"P01","supports":["B"],"opposes":["A"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"领会需要在行动中体现。","sourceIds":["source_p90"],"locator":"定慧一体","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true},{"id":"p90_cross_T110","questionId":"T110","supports":["A"],"opposes":["B"],"weight":1,"core":false,"position":"修养需要减少对固定自我与事物的执著。","sourceIds":["source_p90"],"locator":"无住","mappingStatus":"editorial_cross_comparison","comparison":true}],"minSupported":2,"minCoreSupported":2,"minAnswered":3,"minAgreement":0.65,"routeId":"compare_p90","mappingStatus":"editorial_demo","coverageNotice":"只比较档案列出的局部问题，不代表这个人物的全部哲学。","summary":"觉悟可以当下发生，修行也体现在日常生活中。"}]},"routes":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","baseOrder":["FP01","W01","Q09","Q11","V03","FP02","H01","FP03","C01","FP04","Q02","Q08","Q04","Q10","Q07","A01","FP05"],"maxShortFollowups":6,"topicBatchSize":4,"legacyFollowupRoutes":[{"id":"L","title":"生活与意义","entry":["Q01","Q07"],"questions":["L01","L02"]},{"id":"E","title":"道德与理由","entry":["Q02","Q08"],"questions":["E01","E02"]},{"id":"S","title":"自我与关系","entry":["Q03"],"questions":["S01","S02"]},{"id":"F","title":"自由与责任","entry":["Q04","Q10"],"questions":["F01","F02"]},{"id":"K","title":"知识与证据","entry":["Q05","Q11"],"questions":["K01","K02"]},{"id":"C","title":"公平与共同生活","entry":["Q06","Q12"],"questions":["C01","C02"]}],"topicRoutes":[{"id":"topic_L","topic":"L","title":"生活与意义","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":4,"questions":["Q07","Q01","L01","L02","T08","T11","T12","T13","T14","T54","T60","T62","T64","T85","T110","T138"],"refinementPrompt":"快乐、成就和意义，哪一种更值得追求？它们冲突时怎么选？"},{"id":"topic_E","topic":"E","title":"道德与理由","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":5,"questions":["FP04","Q02","Q08","E01","E02","T10","T25","T43","T49","T50","T55","T61","T63","T79","T87","T101","T136"],"refinementPrompt":"为了好结果，可以越过哪些底线？面对不同的人，责任是否也不同？"},{"id":"topic_S","topic":"S","title":"自我与关系","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":3,"questions":["Q03","S01","S02","T38","T51","T70","T82","T109","T123","T124"],"refinementPrompt":"记忆、身体和关系都在变，什么让你仍然是你？"},{"id":"topic_F","topic":"F","title":"自由与责任","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":4,"questions":["Q04","Q10","F01","F02","D01","D02","D03","D04","T27","T36","T53","T83","T84","T91","T139"],"refinementPrompt":"如果选择早有原因，人还能自由吗？做错事又该承担什么责任？"},{"id":"topic_K","topic":"K","title":"知识与证据","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":4,"questions":["Q11","Q05","K01","K02","T09","T16","T29","T33","T39","T67","T132"],"refinementPrompt":"什么样的理由值得相信？亲眼见过、推理得出，还是经得起怀疑？"},{"id":"topic_C","topic":"C","title":"公平与共同生活","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":5,"questions":["FP03","C01","Q06","Q12","C02","T15","T30","T31","T35","T44","T45","T46","T47","T48","T65","T88","T92","T96","T97","T102","T104","T127","T128","T129","T134"],"refinementPrompt":"怎样才算公平？机会、基本生活和个人财产，发生冲突时怎么选？"},{"id":"topic_M","topic":"M","title":"意识与心灵","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":3,"questions":["Q09","M01","M02","M03","M04","T34","T81","T113","T114"],"refinementPrompt":"讲清大脑怎样运转，就讲清了感受吗？身体和环境又起什么作用？"},{"id":"topic_W","topic":"W","title":"世界与存在","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":5,"questions":["FP01","W01","W02","W03","W04","T01","T02","T03","T04","T05","T06","T07","T17","T22","T26","T28","T37","T40","T41","T42","T52","T78","T95","T106","T111","T112","T119","T131"],"refinementPrompt":"世界在我们看不见时是什么样？数学里的东西又算不算真实存在？"},{"id":"topic_V","topic":"V","title":"科学与解释","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":4,"questions":["V03","V01","V02","V04","T32","T69","T76","T80","T137"],"refinementPrompt":"科学理论为什么可信？预测成功，就说明它讲出了世界的真相吗？"},{"id":"topic_G","topic":"G","title":"语言与理解","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":3,"questions":["G01","G02","G03","G04","T66","T71","T72","T73","T74","T75","T77","T86","T94","T105","T118","T122","T125","T126"],"refinementPrompt":"一句话的意思来自哪里？词语怎样指向世界里的事物？"},{"id":"topic_A","topic":"A","title":"美与艺术","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":3,"questions":["A01","A02","A03","A04","T89","T90","T120"],"refinementPrompt":"美只是个人口味吗？评价一件作品，需要知道它的时代吗？"},{"id":"topic_P","topic":"P","title":"修养与行动","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":4,"questions":["P01","P02","P03","P04","T98","T99","T100","T103","T107","T115","T116","T130","T135"],"refinementPrompt":"怎样才能过好这一生？从管理欲望、待人处事，还是认识自己开始？"},{"id":"topic_R","topic":"R","title":"信仰与终极问题","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":3,"questions":["FP05","R01","R02","R03","R04","T18","T19","T20","T21","T23","T24","T56","T68","T117","T121","T133"],"refinementPrompt":"相信或不相信神，各自需要什么理由？科学能够回答到哪一步？"},{"id":"topic_H","topic":"H","title":"历史与社会","entryMode":"user_opt_in","batchSize":5,"questions":["FP02","H01","H02","H03","H04","T57","T58","T59","T93"],"refinementPrompt":"观念为什么会改变？是生活条件、思想，还是权力在起作用？"}],"comparisonRoutes":[{"id":"compare_p01","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p01","title":"和泰勒斯聊聊：自然解释与共同本原","questions":["T01","T02","T37"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p02","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p02","title":"和赫拉克利特聊聊：变化中的秩序","questions":["T03","T04","W03","T05","T02","T37"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p03","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p03","title":"和巴门尼德聊聊：推理与不变的存在","questions":["T05","T04","Q11"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p04","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p04","title":"和德谟克利特聊聊：构成、排列与感觉","questions":["T06","T07","T01","FP01","T34","W01"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p05","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p05","title":"和苏格拉底聊聊：反省与德性知识","questions":["T08","T09","P01","T14","T43","Q07"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p06","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p06","title":"和柏拉图聊聊：稳定知识与价值根据","questions":["T04","Q07","L02","Q11","T28","T14"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p07","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p07","title":"和亚里士多德聊聊：品格、判断与生命的解释","questions":["T10","T11","P01","FP04","T07","L02","P02","T43"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p08","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p08","title":"和第欧根尼（犬儒学派）聊聊：自足与惯例批判","questions":["T12","T13","T08","T14","P04","Q07"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p09","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p09","title":"和伊壁鸠鲁聊聊：安宁、欲望与快乐","questions":["T11","T13","L02","T14","FP01","T37"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p10","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p10","title":"和爱比克泰德聊聊：判断与可掌握之事","questions":["P04","T14","T11","L02","T08","T15"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p11","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p11","title":"和马可·奥勒留聊聊：内在判断与共同责任","questions":["T15","T14","P04","T11","T08","T13"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p12","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p12","title":"和塞克斯都·恩披里柯聊聊：怀疑与日常生活","questions":["T16","K01","T132","T05"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p13","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p13","title":"和普罗提诺聊聊：多样性与统一根源","questions":["T17","T106","T18","Q11","W04","T34"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p14","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p14","title":"和奥古斯丁聊聊：内在性与恶的缺失解释","questions":["T19","T18","T21","R02","W04","T34"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p15","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p15","title":"和安瑟尔谟聊聊：信仰、理解与存在论论证","questions":["T20","T21","T23","Q11","T117","W04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p16","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p16","title":"和阿维森纳聊聊：本质与存在根据","questions":["T22","T23","W04","Q11","R01","T34"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p17","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p17","title":"和阿威罗伊聊聊：哲学论证与经典解释","questions":["T24","T117","Q11","T25","T28"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p18","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p18","title":"和托马斯·阿奎那聊聊：理性、自然法与存在根据","questions":["T25","T23","T117","T39","L02","T22"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p19","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p19","title":"和邓斯·司各脱聊聊：个体性与意志","questions":["T26","T27","Q10","F02","T28"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p20","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p20","title":"和奥卡姆聊聊：共相与概念","questions":["T28","T118","T29","Q11","T39","T25"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p21","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p21","title":"和马基雅维利聊聊：政治责任与制度冲突","questions":["T30","T31","T45","T104","H04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p22","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p22","title":"和弗朗西斯·培根聊聊：系统观察与偏见纠正","questions":["T32","Q11","K02","T39","T33","T67"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p23","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p23","title":"和笛卡尔聊聊：怀疑起点与思考主体","questions":["T33","T34","Q11","FP01","T39"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p24","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p24","title":"和霍布斯聊聊：安全、裁决与权威","questions":["T35","T31","T30","T34","T104","T59"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p25","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p25","title":"和斯宾诺莎聊聊：理解原因与自由","questions":["T36","T37","Q10","Q11","T40","Q04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p26","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p26","title":"和洛克聊聊：经验与意识连续性","questions":["T38","T39","Q11","Q03","T46","T44","W01"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p27","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p27","title":"和莱布尼茨聊聊：理由与个体区别","questions":["T40","T41","Q11","T39","T133","W04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p28","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p28","title":"和贝克莱聊聊：感知与对象","questions":["T42","T131","W01","FP01","T39"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p29","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p29","title":"和休谟聊聊：因果期待、自由与道德情感","questions":["V03","T43","Q04","Q11","T39","T20","T109"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p30","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p30","title":"和孟德斯鸠聊聊：权力制约与社会条件","questions":["T44","T45","H01","T35","T104","FP02"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p31","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p31","title":"和伏尔泰聊聊：宽容与批判","questions":["T46","T133","R03","T65"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p32","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p32","title":"和卢梭聊聊：共同立法与自由","questions":["T47","T53","C01","T88","T91"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p33","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p33","title":"和玛丽·沃斯通克拉夫特聊聊：教育、平等与理性能力","questions":["T48","T84","T11","C01","T43","P02"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p34","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p34","title":"和康德聊聊：普遍化与人格尊重","questions":["T49","T50","Q02","E01","FP04","T43","L02","T14"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p35","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p35","title":"和费希特聊聊：自我活动与相互承认","questions":["T51","T53","F02","T124","T34","Q04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p36","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p36","title":"和谢林聊聊：自然生成与艺术","questions":["T52","T119","T120","T07","T34","T04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p37","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p37","title":"和黑格尔聊聊：社会中的自由","questions":["T53","S02","H04","H01","T47","T124"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p38","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p38","title":"和叔本华聊聊：欲望、痛苦与同情","questions":["T54","T55","T13","P04","T110"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p39","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p39","title":"和费尔巴哈聊聊：神圣投射与人的关系","questions":["T56","T121","FP01","T34","T43"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p40","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p40","title":"和马克思聊聊：异化与社会关系","questions":["T57","H03","H01","T58","FP03","FP02","T59","T53","T91","T139"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p41","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p41","title":"和恩格斯聊聊：家庭、生产与历史组织","questions":["T58","T59","H01","FP02","FP03","T53"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p42","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p42","title":"和克尔凯郭尔聊聊：个人承担与信仰","questions":["T60","R02","T124","L01","T85"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p43","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p43","title":"和尼采聊聊：价值来历与自我超越","questions":["T61","T62","L01","T54","H02"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p44","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p44","title":"和边沁聊聊：苦乐的平等考虑","questions":["T63","T64","T10","FP04","T50","T55"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p45","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p45","title":"和约翰·斯图亚特·密尔聊聊：快乐质量与个性自由","questions":["T64","T65","T63","FP04","T46","Q11","T55"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p46","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p46","title":"和皮尔士聊聊：概念意义与共同探究","questions":["T66","T67","K02","T32","Q11","V01"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p47","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p47","title":"和威廉·詹姆斯聊聊：证据未决时的信念承诺","questions":["T68","R02","T69","T60","Q07","T66"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p48","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p48","title":"和杜威聊聊：在问题中学习","questions":["T69","T67","H03","T66","T92","Q11"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p49","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p49","title":"和柏格森聊聊：生活时间与生成","questions":["T70","T52","T04","T07","T119","T95"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p50","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p50","title":"和弗雷格聊聊：逻辑与认识方式","questions":["T71","T72","W02","T75","Q11","T122"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p51","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p51","title":"和罗素聊聊：逻辑分析","questions":["T73","T71","W01","W02","T39"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p52","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p52","title":"和维特根斯坦聊聊：用法与规则","questions":["T74","T122","G01","T09","T126","T34"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p53","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p53","title":"和卡尔纳普聊聊：框架内外的问题","questions":["T75","T71","T29","W02","Q11","T126"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p54","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p54","title":"和奎因聊聊：知识的整体检验","questions":["T76","Q11","V01","W02","T33","T137"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p55","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p55","title":"和克里普克聊聊：名字与后验必然性","questions":["T77","T78","T75","W01","Q11"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p56","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p56","title":"和伊丽莎白·安斯康姆聊聊：行动描述与意向","questions":["T79","T50","T10","FP04","T136"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p57","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p57","title":"和波普尔聊聊：可反驳性与检验","questions":["V04","V01","T67","T32","Q05","T137"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p58","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p58","title":"和托马斯·库恩聊聊：研究传统与科学变化","questions":["T80","V01","T76","H01","Q05","T137"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p59","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p59","title":"和胡塞尔聊聊：经验描述与悬搁","questions":["T81","T113","T34","M02","Q11"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p60","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p60","title":"和海德格尔聊聊：在世生活与自身可能性","questions":["T82","T123","T124","T34","T70","T86","T138"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p61","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p61","title":"和萨特聊聊：处境中的选择与责任","questions":["T83","L02","T60","T124","T62","T34","T138","T139"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p62","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p62","title":"和西蒙娜·德·波伏瓦聊聊：处境中的自由与他者化","questions":["T84","T48","T83","T124","T53","T91"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p63","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p63","title":"和加缪聊聊：荒诞与有界限的坚持","questions":["Q07","T136","T85","T60","L01","H04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p64","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p64","title":"和梅洛-庞蒂聊聊：具身知觉","questions":["M04","Q09","T82","T34","T113","T124","T138"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p65","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p65","title":"和伽达默尔聊聊：历史处境中的理解","questions":["T86","G03","H02","G01","T105","T33"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p66","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p66","title":"和列维纳斯聊聊：超出交换关系的责任","questions":["T87","T50","T136"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p67","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p67","title":"和汉娜·阿伦特聊聊：公共行动与多元性","questions":["T88","H03","T83","T53","C02","T47","T139"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p68","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p68","title":"和瓦尔特·本雅明聊聊：复制、独特性与历史经验","questions":["T89","A02","H04","H01","T90"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p69","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p69","title":"和阿多诺聊聊：文化需要与概念的限度","questions":["T90","T125","T91","H02","T136","H04"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p70","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p70","title":"和马尔库塞聊聊：满意、需要与社会限制","questions":["T91","T90","H03","D01","T84","T53"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p71","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p71","title":"和哈贝马斯聊聊：公共理由与平等参与","questions":["T92","E02","C02","T47","T134","T65","H03"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p72","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p72","title":"和福柯聊聊：规范如何塑造主体","questions":["T93","H01","H02","D01","T84","T91"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p73","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p73","title":"和德里达聊聊：概念对立与意义关系","questions":["T94","T126","T125","G03"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p74","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p74","title":"和德勒兹聊聊：差异与生成","questions":["T95","T52","T62","T04","T125"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p75","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p75","title":"和罗尔斯聊聊：基本自由、机会与最不利者","questions":["T96","C01","C02","T50","T97"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p76","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p76","title":"和诺齐克聊聊：取得、转让与权利","questions":["T97","C01","C02","FP03","Q01","T50","T65","T96"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p77","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p77","title":"和孔子聊聊：关系中的责任与修养","questions":["T98","Q12","P02","T10","P01","T104"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p78","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p78","title":"和孟子聊聊：道德萌芽与生活条件","questions":["T99","T127","P02","T55","T135","T104"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p79","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p79","title":"和荀子聊聊：人为学习与欲望安排","questions":["T100","T98","P02","T99","T135","P01"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p80","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p80","title":"和墨子聊聊：普遍关切与反对侵攻","questions":["T101","T128","T63","FP04","T12","T55"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p81","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p81","title":"和老子聊聊：少欲与减少强制干预","questions":["T102","T13","T12","P03","T106"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p82","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p82","title":"和庄子聊聊：尺度、视角与熟练生活","questions":["T103","P03","T04","T125"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p83","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p83","title":"和韩非聊聊：制度化职责与考核","questions":["T129","T134","T104","T98","T100","T35"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p84","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p84","title":"和王弼聊聊：言意与无形根本","questions":["T105","T106","T102","T17","T13","P03"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p85","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p85","title":"和朱熹聊聊：穷理与道德学习","questions":["T107","T98","Q07","T135","P01","P02"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p86","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p86","title":"和王阳明聊聊：知行与去除自欺","questions":["P01","T130","T107","T135","T116"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p87","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p87","title":"和释迦牟尼（早期佛教教说档案）聊聊：无常、执取与无我","questions":["T109","T110","P04","T13","T34"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p88","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p88","title":"和龙树聊聊：缘起与无自性","questions":["T111","T112","T109","T106","W04","T110"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p89","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p89","title":"和世亲聊聊：经验对象与认识活动","questions":["T113","T114","T109","T34","T131","T110"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"},{"id":"compare_p90","kind":"profile_comparison","profileId":"p90","title":"和慧能（《坛经》相关教说档案）聊聊：直接领会与日常实践","questions":["T115","T116","T109","P01","T110"],"entryMode":"user_opt_in","notice":"从人物页主动进入的定向比较；与测试自动发现分开展示。选项不提示人物会怎么选。"}],"refinementSeeds":[{"topic":"W","answer":"FP01.A","profiles":["p25","p04","p01"]},{"topic":"W","answer":"FP01.B","profiles":["p28","p37","p27"]},{"topic":"W","answer":"FP01.C","profiles":["p23"]},{"topic":"W","answer":"W01.B","profiles":["p28","p59"]},{"topic":"W","answer":"W02.A","profiles":["p06","p50"]},{"topic":"W","answer":"W04.A","profiles":["p27","p16"]},{"topic":"H","answer":"FP02.A","profiles":["p40","p41"]},{"topic":"H","answer":"FP02.B","profiles":["p37"]},{"topic":"H","answer":"FP02.C","profiles":["p67","p48"]},{"topic":"H","answer":"H01.C","profiles":["p72"]},{"topic":"H","answer":"H02.C","profiles":["p72"]},{"topic":"K","answer":"Q11.A","profiles":["p23","p27","p34"]},{"topic":"K","answer":"Q11.B","profiles":["p26","p29","p22"]},{"topic":"K","answer":"Q11.C","profiles":["p54","p48"]},{"topic":"K","answer":"K01.C","profiles":["p12"]},{"topic":"K","answer":"K02.C","profiles":["p46","p48"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"FP04.A","profiles":["p45","p44","p80"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"FP04.B","profiles":["p34"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"FP04.C","profiles":["p07","p56","p77"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"Q02.A","profiles":["p45","p44"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"Q02.B","profiles":["p34"]},{"topic":"E","answer":"E02.C","profiles":["p71"]},{"topic":"C","answer":"FP03.A","profiles":["p40","p41"]},{"topic":"C","answer":"FP03.B","profiles":["p75","p71"]},{"topic":"C","answer":"FP03.C","profiles":["p76"]},{"topic":"C","answer":"C01.B","profiles":["p75","p32"]},{"topic":"C","answer":"Q12.A","profiles":["p77"]},{"topic":"M","answer":"Q09.A","profiles":["p04"]},{"topic":"M","answer":"Q09.B","profiles":["p23","p59"]},{"topic":"M","answer":"Q09.C","profiles":["p64"]},{"topic":"F","answer":"Q04.A","profiles":["p29"]},{"topic":"F","answer":"Q04.B","profiles":["p61"]},{"topic":"F","answer":"Q04.C","profiles":["p25","p35"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"Q07.A","profiles":["p61"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"Q07.B","profiles":["p06","p07"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"Q07.C","profiles":["p63"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"Q01.A","profiles":["p09","p44"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"L02.A","profiles":["p09","p45"]},{"topic":"L","answer":"L01.C","profiles":["p43","p61"]},{"topic":"V","answer":"V03.A","profiles":["p29"]},{"topic":"V","answer":"V01.A","profiles":["p57"]},{"topic":"V","answer":"V01.B","profiles":["p58","p54"]},{"topic":"A","answer":"A01.C","profiles":["p68","p69"]},{"topic":"A","answer":"A02.B","profiles":["p68"]},{"topic":"R","answer":"FP05.A","profiles":["p18","p14","p15"]},{"topic":"R","answer":"FP05.B","profiles":["p39","p29"]},{"topic":"R","answer":"FP05.C","profiles":["p12"]},{"topic":"R","answer":"R02.B","profiles":["p47"]},{"topic":"R","answer":"R02.C","profiles":["p42"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P01.B","profiles":["p05","p86"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P01.C","profiles":["p07","p79"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P02.A","profiles":["p78"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P02.C","profiles":["p77"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P03.A","profiles":["p82"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P04.A","profiles":["p10","p11"]},{"topic":"P","answer":"P04.B","profiles":["p87"]},{"topic":"S","answer":"Q03.B","profiles":["p26"]},{"topic":"S","answer":"S02.B","profiles":["p37"]},{"topic":"G","answer":"G01.B","profiles":["p52"]},{"topic":"G","answer":"G03.C","profiles":["p65"]},{"topic":"G","answer":"G04.A","profiles":["p67"]}],"topicBridges":[{"from":"W","to":"K","text":"我们怎样认识世界，也会影响我们认为什么是真实的。下面会追问理性和经验各能告诉我们什么。"},{"from":"W","to":"M","text":"心灵和物质是什么关系？意识问题能进一步区分你对世界的看法。"},{"from":"W","to":"F","text":"如果自然万物都有原因，人的选择会怎样发生？这也是理解斯宾诺莎世界观的一条线索。"},{"from":"W","to":"G","text":"语言怎样指向事物，会影响我们对“存在”的理解。接下来会用名字和描述来讨论这个问题。"},{"from":"W","to":"S","text":"人怎样处在世界中，也涉及身体、经验和自我。接下来会从这些角度继续问。"},{"from":"W","to":"H","text":"理解黑格尔的世界观，还需要看看他怎样理解历史中的变化。"},{"from":"M","to":"S","text":"同一个人为什么还是同一个人？关于自我的回答，也能帮助我们理解意识。"},{"from":"M","to":"K","text":"我们如何知道自己正在思考？这个问题把意识和知识联系在一起。"},{"from":"L","to":"E","text":"什么样的生活值得追求，也会影响我们认为该怎样行动。"},{"from":"L","to":"C","text":"密尔既讨论快乐的价值，也讨论个人自由。接下来会看看你怎样划定社会干预的界限。"},{"from":"E","to":"L","text":"怎样行动与怎样过好一生有时是同一个问题的两面。接下来会谈生活中值得追求的东西。"},{"from":"E","to":"C","text":"道德判断也会遇到社会规则：个人能决定什么，社会又能要求什么？"},{"from":"E","to":"F","text":"一个人能否为行为负责，与他有怎样的选择能力有关。"},{"from":"C","to":"H","text":"理解社会怎样运作，也要问它是怎样形成和改变的。"},{"from":"C","to":"E","text":"社会制度要怎样对待人，也涉及我们对权利、责任和伤害的判断。"},{"from":"K","to":"M","text":"理性怎样带来知识，与我们怎样理解思考的心灵有关。"},{"from":"K","to":"G","text":"知识要通过语言表达，语言的含义和边界也会影响我们能说清什么。"},{"from":"K","to":"V","text":"科学是认识世界的一种重要方式。接下来会问科学解释能让我们知道什么。"},{"from":"E","to":"P","text":"德性伦理学关心怎样成为一个好的人，这也需要讨论品格如何在日常行动中养成。"},{"from":"H","to":"C","text":"生产方式的变化，也会改变人们怎样工作、分享成果。下面聊聊谁来决定生产和分配。"}]},"sources":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","reviewDate":"2026-09-26","items":[{"id":"philpapers2020","title":"PhilPapers Survey 2020：议题与问卷设计","url":"https://survey2020.philpeople.org/survey/design/questions","publisher":"PhilPapers / PhilPeople","type":"survey_design","review":"已查阅议题和结构；不是人格测量或本项目背书。"},{"id":"philpapers_caveats","title":"PhilPapers Survey 2020：编辑对选项与传统覆盖的反思","url":"https://survey2020.philpeople.org/survey/design/thoughts","publisher":"PhilPapers / PhilPeople","type":"methodology","review":"已查阅非互斥、非穷尽及传统偏向的说明。"},{"id":"source_p01","title":"泰勒斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/presocratics/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p02","title":"赫拉克利特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heraclitus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p03","title":"巴门尼德：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/parmenides/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p04","title":"德谟克利特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/democritus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p05","title":"苏格拉底：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/socrates/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p06","title":"柏拉图：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plato-ethics/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p07","title":"亚里士多德：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-ethics/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p08","title":"第欧根尼（犬儒学派）：Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://iep.utm.edu/cynics/","publisher":"Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p09","title":"伊壁鸠鲁：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epicurus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p10","title":"爱比克泰德：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epictetus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p11","title":"马可·奥勒留：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marcus-aurelius/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p12","title":"塞克斯都·恩披里柯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism-ancient/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p13","title":"普罗提诺：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plotinus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p14","title":"奥古斯丁：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/augustine/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p15","title":"安瑟尔谟：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anselm/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p16","title":"阿维森纳：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ibn-sina/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p17","title":"阿威罗伊：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ibn-rushd/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p18","title":"托马斯·阿奎那：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aquinas/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p19","title":"邓斯·司各脱：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/duns-scotus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p20","title":"奥卡姆：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ockham/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p21","title":"马基雅维利：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/machiavelli/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p22","title":"弗朗西斯·培根：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/francis-bacon/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p23","title":"笛卡尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/descartes/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p24","title":"霍布斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hobbes-moral/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p25","title":"斯宾诺莎：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spinoza/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p26","title":"洛克：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p27","title":"莱布尼茨：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/leibniz/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p28","title":"贝克莱：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/berkeley/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p29","title":"休谟：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hume/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p30","title":"孟德斯鸠：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/montesquieu/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p31","title":"伏尔泰：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/voltaire/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p32","title":"卢梭：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rousseau/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p33","title":"玛丽·沃斯通克拉夫特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wollstonecraft/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p34","title":"康德：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-moral/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p35","title":"费希特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/johann-fichte/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p36","title":"谢林：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/schelling/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p37","title":"黑格尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p38","title":"叔本华：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/schopenhauer/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p39","title":"费尔巴哈：原著公开文本","url":"https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/feuerbach/works/essence/ec01_1.htm","publisher":"Marxists Internet Archive","type":"primary_text","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p40","title":"马克思：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marx/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p41","title":"恩格斯：原著公开文本","url":"https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1884/origin-family/preface.htm","publisher":"Marxists Internet Archive","type":"primary_text","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p42","title":"克尔凯郭尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kierkegaard/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p43","title":"尼采：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nietzsche/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p44","title":"边沁：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bentham/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p45","title":"约翰·斯图亚特·密尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mill/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p46","title":"皮尔士：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/peirce/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p47","title":"威廉·詹姆斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/james/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p48","title":"杜威：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dewey/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p49","title":"柏格森：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bergson/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p50","title":"弗雷格：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/frege/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p51","title":"罗素：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/russell/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p52","title":"维特根斯坦：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p53","title":"卡尔纳普：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/carnap/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p54","title":"奎因：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/quine/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p55","title":"克里普克：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rigid-designators/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p56","title":"伊丽莎白·安斯康姆：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anscombe/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p57","title":"波普尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p58","title":"托马斯·库恩：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/thomas-kuhn/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p59","title":"胡塞尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/husserl/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p60","title":"海德格尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heidegger/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p61","title":"萨特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sartre/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p62","title":"西蒙娜·德·波伏瓦：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/beauvoir/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p63","title":"加缪：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/camus/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p64","title":"梅洛-庞蒂：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/merleau-ponty/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p65","title":"伽达默尔：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/gadamer/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p66","title":"列维纳斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/levinas/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p67","title":"汉娜·阿伦特：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/arendt/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p68","title":"瓦尔特·本雅明：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/benjamin/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p69","title":"阿多诺：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/adorno/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p70","title":"马尔库塞：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marcuse/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p71","title":"哈贝马斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/habermas/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p72","title":"福柯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/foucault/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p73","title":"德里达：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/derrida/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p74","title":"德勒兹：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/deleuze/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p75","title":"罗尔斯：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rawls/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p76","title":"诺齐克：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nozick-political/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p77","title":"孔子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/confucius/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p78","title":"孟子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mencius/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p79","title":"荀子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/xunzi/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p80","title":"墨子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mohism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p81","title":"老子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/laozi/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p82","title":"庄子：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zhuangzi/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p83","title":"韩非：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/chinese-legalism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p84","title":"王弼：Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://iep.utm.edu/wangbi/","publisher":"Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p85","title":"朱熹：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zhu-xi/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p86","title":"王阳明：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wang-yangming/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p87","title":"释迦牟尼（早期佛教教说档案）：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/buddha/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p88","title":"龙树：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nagarjuna/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p89","title":"世亲：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/vasubandhu/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_p90","title":"慧能（《坛经》相关教说档案）：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/buddhism-chan/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"已核对条目或文本的相关主题；人物对原创选项的映射为本项目编辑解释，未获作者或机构认证。"},{"id":"source_wellbeing","title":"幸福与体验机器：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/well-being/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"source_scirealism","title":"科学实在论：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-realism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"source_moralrealism","title":"道德实在论：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-realism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"source_physicalism","title":"物理主义：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/physicalism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"source_determinism","title":"因果决定论：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/determinism-causal/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"source_epistemology","title":"理性主义与经验主义：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"2026-09-30：用于结果页议题入门解读。"},{"id":"mill_liberty","title":"密尔《论自由》英文原著","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/34901","publisher":"Project Gutenberg","type":"primary_text","review":"公版作品，供用户展开阅读。"},{"id":"mill_utilitarianism","title":"密尔《功利主义》英文原著","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/11224","publisher":"Project Gutenberg","type":"primary_text","review":"公版作品，供用户展开阅读。"},{"id":"source_idealism","title":"唯心主义：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/idealism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"encyclopedia"},{"id":"source_atheism","title":"无神论与不可知论：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"encyclopedia"},{"id":"source_socialism","title":"社会主义：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/socialism/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"encyclopedia"},{"id":"source_beauty","title":"美与审美判断：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/beauty/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"encyclopedia"},{"id":"voltaire_lisbon","title":"伏尔泰：《里斯本灾难诗》（英译）","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/files/64858/64858-h/64858-h.htm#Page_255","publisher":"Project Gutenberg","type":"primary_text_translation","review":"2026-10-13 核对原作英译中对“一切皆好”的质疑。"},{"id":"evil_sep","title":"恶的问题：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/evil/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"用于介绍恶的问题及主要回应，不据此推定用户的宗教身份。"},{"id":"source_p07_nature","title":"亚里士多德的生物学：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-biology/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"资料支持相关思想；题目选项与人物立场的对应为编辑解释。"},{"id":"locke_personal_identity","title":"洛克的个人同一性问题：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke-personal-identity/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"资料支持相关思想；现代情境与人物立场的对应为编辑解释。"},{"id":"nozick_experience","title":"幸福与体验机器：Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/well-being/","publisher":"Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","type":"scholarly_reference","review":"资料支持相关思想；现代情境与人物立场的对应为编辑解释。"}]},"traditions":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","items":[{"id":"compatibilism","name":"相容论","kind":"tradition","topic":"F","all":["Q04.A","F02.A"],"description":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。","nextQuestion":"T36","sourceIds":["source_p29","philpapers2020","source_p35"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"相容论者","shareSummary":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。"},{"id":"consequence","name":"后果主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"E","all":["Q02.A","E01.A"],"description":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。","nextQuestion":"T63","sourceIds":["source_p44","source_p45"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"后果主义者","shareSummary":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。"},{"id":"duty","name":"义务论","kind":"tradition","topic":"E","all":["Q02.B","E01.B"],"description":"判断对错要看应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。","nextQuestion":"T49","sourceIds":["source_p34"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"义务论者","shareSummary":"判断对错要看应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。"},{"id":"virtue","name":"德性伦理学","kind":"tradition","topic":"P","all":["T10.A","P01.C"],"description":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。","nextQuestion":"T11","sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p44","source_p05","source_p06"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"德性修习者","shareSummary":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。","dimension":"ethics"},{"id":"moral_objective","name":"道德实在论","kind":"tradition","topic":"E","all":["Q08.A","E02.A"],"description":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。","nextQuestion":"T25","sourceIds":["source_moralrealism"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"道德实在论者","shareSummary":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。"},{"id":"body_identity","name":"身体连续性理论","kind":"tradition","topic":"S","all":["Q03.A","T38.B"],"description":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。","nextQuestion":"T38","sourceIds":["philpapers2020"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"生命延续派","shareSummary":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。"},{"id":"experience_value","name":"享乐主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"L","all":["Q01.A","L02.A"],"description":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。","nextQuestion":"T13","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","source_p06","source_p09","source_p61"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"享乐主义者","shareSummary":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。","dimension":"wellbeing"},{"id":"scientific_realism","name":"科学实在论","kind":"tradition","topic":"K","all":["Q05.A","V02.A"],"description":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。","nextQuestion":"V01","sourceIds":["source_scirealism"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"科学实在论者","shareSummary":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。","dimension":"science"},{"id":"instrumental","name":"科学工具主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"K","all":["Q05.B","V02.B"],"description":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。","nextQuestion":"V04","sourceIds":["source_p12","philpapers2020"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"工具主义者","shareSummary":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。","dimension":"science"},{"id":"opportunity","name":"机会平等主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"C","all":["Q06.B","C01.B"],"description":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。","nextQuestion":"T96","sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p75","source_p76"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"公平倡导者","shareSummary":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。","dimension":"distribution"},{"id":"basic_security","name":"充足主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"C","all":["Q06.C","C01.C"],"description":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。","nextQuestion":"T127","sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p75","source_p76"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"生活守护者","shareSummary":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。","dimension":"distribution"},{"id":"embodied","name":"具身认知","kind":"tradition","topic":"M","all":["Q09.C","M04.A"],"description":"思考与感知受身体、行动和环境共同塑造。","nextQuestion":"T82","sourceIds":["source_p59","source_p64","philpapers2020"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"身体体验派","shareSummary":"思考与感知受身体、行动和环境共同塑造。"},{"id":"suspension","name":"怀疑主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"K","all":["T16.A","K01.C"],"description":"当理由不足以确定真假时，暂缓判断。","nextQuestion":"T09","sourceIds":["source_p12"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"怀疑者","shareSummary":"当理由不足以确定真假时，暂缓判断。"},{"id":"dependent","name":"中观学派","kind":"tradition","topic":"W","all":["T111.A","T112.A"],"description":"一切事物依条件而存在，没有独立不变的本性。","nextQuestion":"T109","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"中观行者","shareSummary":"一切事物依条件而存在，没有独立不变的本性。"},{"id":"historical","name":"历史主义","kind":"tradition","topic":"H","all":["H01.B","H02.B"],"description":"理解思想与制度，要把它们放回形成和变化的历史中。","nextQuestion":"T58","sourceIds":["source_p30","source_p40","source_p41","source_p72","source_p65"],"relation":"依据回答给出的宽范围倾向，非唯一所属或人格类型","shareTitle":"历史解读者","shareSummary":"理解思想与制度，要把它们放回形成和变化的历史中。","dimension":"historicalContext"}]},"tension_rules":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","rules":[{"id":"freedom_conditions","all":["Q04.B","Q10.A","F01.A"],"title":"只能这样做，还该负责吗","description":"你觉得“当时真能选别的”才算自由，也承认“同样的条件下人只能作出同样的选择”，但到了追责时，你依然赞成让当事人担责。","bridge":"如果一个人从头到尾都没法选别的路，我们凭什么还要追究他的责任呢？","nextQuestion":"D04","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"value_experience","all":["Q01.A","L02.B"],"title":"感觉幸福，就足够了吗","description":"你一边愿意钻进能提供完美幻觉的“幸福体验机”，另一边又觉得“有些事就算没人喜欢，本身也值得去做”。","bridge":"既然机器里只有虚拟的快乐感受，那些“本身值得做的事”，还需要真正在现实里发生吗？","nextQuestion":"L01","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"rules_exception","all":["T49.A","E01.A"],"title":"这次破例，别人也可以吗","description":"你一边反感“只给自己留特权、不准别人破例”，另一边却愿意为了帮人免受损失而打破自己许下的保密承诺。","bridge":"如果换作别人遇到同样的情况，你也会允许所有人像你这样把保密诺言作废吗？","nextQuestion":"T50","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"rights_distribution","all":["T97.A","C01.B"],"title":"财产来得正当，还要调整吗","description":"你重视正当取得和转让的财产，也希望减弱出身造成的机会差距。如果改善机会需要向这些财产征税，两种要求就可能发生冲突：财产权应当保护到什么程度，改善机会又能要求人承担多少？","bridge":"如果改善机会需要向拥有更多财产的人征税，你会把界限划在哪里？","nextQuestion":"T96","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"meaning_limits","all":["T126.A","G03.B"],"title":"作者的原意，能决定全部含义吗","description":"你认为词语的含义依赖其他表达，也觉得理解作品时应该重视作者原意。","bridge":"作者原意是帮助理解的一条线索，还是决定所有读法的最后标准？","nextQuestion":"T86","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"privacy_public","all":["Q12.A","T101.A"],"title":"亲近者与普遍关切","description":"你在私人帮忙时，会优先照顾身边的朋友；但在制定公共政策时，又主张把远方陌生人的痛苦看得同样重要。","bridge":"当私人人情与公共利益撞在一起时，那条“先顾自己人”与“一视同仁”的界线，你会划在哪里？","nextQuestion":"C02","kind":"scope_clarification","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"dualism_physicalism","all":["FP01.C","T34.B"],"title":"心灵与身体，需要再分清","description":"在一道题里，你认为心灵和肉体是截然不同的两类东西；可在另一道题里，你又觉得思想说到底就是大脑和身体的活动。","bridge":"在你看来，人的意识究竟是大脑运转的产物，还是某种独立于肉体之外的存在？","nextQuestion":"Q09","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"},{"id":"materialism_dualism","all":["FP01.A","T34.A"],"title":"意识来自身体，还是另有一种存在？","description":"你一边赞同顺着星球、生命和身体的演化就能解释思想的诞生，另一边却又认为心灵和身体属于两类根本不同的存在，不能互相还原。","bridge":"既然意识是从物质和身体里长出来的，它是怎样获得那种“无法被物质解释”的独特地位的呢？","nextQuestion":"Q09","kind":"possible_tension","sourceStatus":"本项目跨题讨论规则，未宣称形式矛盾"}]},"result_rules":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","status":"体验原型；描述规则，不是经过验证的量表或人物匹配器","rules":[{"id":"historical_materialism","topic":"H","dimension":"history","all":["FP02.A","H01.B"],"title":"历史唯物主义","description":"人们怎样生产和生活，构成了社会制度与思想发展的基础。","question":"同样的经济条件下，为什么仍会出现不同的制度与观念？","explore":"历史唯物主义","shareTitle":"历史唯物主义者","shareSummary":"人们怎样生产和生活，构成了社会制度与思想发展的基础。"},{"id":"freedom_compat","topic":"F","all":["Q04.A","Q10.A"],"title":"相容论","description":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。","explore":"相容论","question":"如果愿望是别人悄悄植入的，照着愿望行动还算自由吗？","tagline":"自己愿意，就算自由。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"相容论者","shareSummary":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。"},{"id":"freedom_open","topic":"F","all":["Q04.B","Q10.B"],"title":"自由意志论","description":"人有自由意志，能够作出未被过去和自然规律预先决定的选择。","explore":"自由意志与其他可能性","question":"怎样区分“我选择了另一条路”和“事情随机发生了变化”？","tagline":"能选另一条路，才算自由。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"自由意志派","shareSummary":"人有自由意志，能够作出未被过去和自然规律预先决定的选择。"},{"id":"freedom_doubt","topic":"F","all":["Q04.B","Q10.A","F01.B"],"title":"自由意志怀疑论","description":"人是否拥有足以让自己应得奖惩的自由意志，值得怀疑。","explore":"自由意志怀疑与责任","question":"如果一个人没有别的选择，还应怎样回应受害者，让伤害得到弥补？","tagline":"阻止伤害，并帮助做错事的人改变。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"因果追问者","shareSummary":"人是否拥有足以让自己应得奖惩的自由意志，值得怀疑。"},{"id":"ethics_exception","topic":"E","all":["Q02.A","E01.A"],"title":"后果主义","description":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。","explore":"后果与道德约束","question":"有没有一种边界，即使结果更好，你也不愿越过？","tagline":"在这两道题里，你愿意为减少伤害破例。","dimension":"ethics","shareTitle":"后果主义者","shareSummary":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。"},{"id":"ethics_limit","topic":"E","all":["Q02.B","E01.B"],"title":"义务论","description":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。","explore":"义务与承诺","question":"如果守住承诺会伤害无辜的人，你会怎样决定？","tagline":"好结果，未必足以让你撤回承诺。","dimension":"ethics","shareTitle":"义务论者","shareSummary":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。"},{"id":"ethics_independent","topic":"E","all":["Q08.A","E02.A"],"title":"道德实在论","description":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。","explore":"道德判断的客观性","question":"如果共识不能保证正确，我们怎样识别更好的道德理由？","tagline":"大家都赞同，也不能替你完成判断。","dimension":"metaethics","shareTitle":"道德实在论者","shareSummary":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。"},{"id":"life_experience","topic":"L","all":["Q01.A","L02.A"],"title":"享乐主义","description":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。","explore":"幸福与体验价值","question":"如果一个幸福体验始终建立在误解上，它还缺少什么吗？","tagline":"幸福的感受，在你这里有很大分量。","dimension":"wellbeing","shareTitle":"享乐主义者","shareSummary":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。"},{"id":"life_real","topic":"L","all":["Q01.B","L01.A"],"title":"非享乐主义","description":"好的人生还需要快乐以外的东西，例如真实经历或有价值的行动。","explore":"真实经历与生活价值","question":"哪些值得做的事，可以让你接受不那么快乐的一生？","tagline":"感觉很好，还不足以说服你。","dimension":"wellbeing","shareTitle":"真实生活家","shareSummary":"好的人生还需要快乐以外的东西，例如真实经历或有价值的行动。"},{"id":"knowledge_instrument","topic":"K","all":["Q05.B","V02.B"],"title":"科学工具主义","description":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。","explore":"科学工具主义","question":"一个工具为什么能如此稳定地预测我们没见过的现象？","tagline":"理论有效，未必说明世界就是它描述的样子。","dimension":"science","shareTitle":"工具主义者","shareSummary":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。"},{"id":"knowledge_real","topic":"K","all":["Q05.A","V02.A"],"title":"科学实在论","description":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。","explore":"科学实在论","question":"过去也有成功却后来被替代的理论，我们应相信其中哪些部分？","tagline":"理论的成功，让你更愿意相信它说中了什么。","dimension":"science","shareTitle":"科学实在论者","shareSummary":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。"},{"id":"society_opportunity","topic":"C","all":["Q06.B","C01.B"],"title":"机会平等主义","description":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。","explore":"机会平等","question":"要让机会更接近，我们愿意调整多少已经形成的差距？","tagline":"同样的努力，也受起点影响。","dimension":"distribution","shareTitle":"公平倡导者","shareSummary":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。"},{"id":"society_floor","topic":"C","all":["Q06.C","C01.C"],"title":"充足主义","description":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。","explore":"基本保障与分配正义","question":"如果每个人的基本生活都有保障，巨大的贫富差距还需要调整吗？","tagline":"每个人都应有基本生活保障。","dimension":"distribution","shareTitle":"生活守护者","shareSummary":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。"},{"id":"self_continuity","topic":"S","all":["Q03.A","T38.B"],"title":"身体连续性理论","description":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。","explore":"个人同一性与身体连续性","question":"如果身体仍在，但所有共同经历的记忆都消失了，你会怎样理解这个人的变化？","tagline":"记忆可以改变，但你没有轻易换掉那个“人”。","dimension":"self","shareTitle":"生命延续派","shareSummary":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。"},{"id":"mind_experience","topic":"M","all":["Q09.B","M02.A"],"title":"意识的解释鸿沟","description":"知道大脑怎样运转，仍未说明它为什么会产生亲身感受。","explore":"主观经验与意识解释","question":"熟知颜色全部物理知识、却从没见过颜色的科学家，第一次看到红色时，算不算知道了新事实？","tagline":"知道怎样发生，仍不等于亲自感受到。","dimension":"mind","shareTitle":"心灵追问者","shareSummary":"知道大脑怎样运转，仍未说明它为什么会产生亲身感受。"},{"id":"world_independent","topic":"W","all":["W01.A","W02.A"],"title":"实在论","description":"事物的存在与性质，并不取决于我们怎样认识它们。","explore":"实在与数学对象","question":"山是一种具体事物，数字却不是。它们的存在可以用同一种理由说明吗？","tagline":"你更像是在发现世界，而不只是给它命名。","dimension":"external","shareTitle":"实在论者","shareSummary":"事物的存在与性质，并不取决于我们怎样认识它们。"},{"id":"language_context","topic":"G","all":["G01.B","G03.C"],"title":"语言语境主义","description":"一句话的意思，要结合它被说出和使用的具体情境来理解。","explore":"语言使用与解释","question":"如果意义会随处境变化，怎样区分新理解和误读？","tagline":"一句话的意思，会带着它所在的生活。","dimension":"language","shareTitle":"会意者","shareSummary":"一句话的意思，要结合它被说出和使用的具体情境来理解。"},{"id":"art_context","topic":"A","all":["A01.C","A02.C"],"title":"艺术语境主义","description":"作品的艺术价值，要结合它所处的文化、时代和创作背景来理解。","explore":"艺术的历史语境","question":"如果完全不知道背景，我们会错过作品的多少价值？","tagline":"作品从哪里来，也是你欣赏它的一部分。","dimension":"aesthetics","shareTitle":"艺术语境派","shareSummary":"作品的艺术价值，要结合它所处的文化、时代和创作背景来理解。"},{"id":"practice_habit","topic":"P","all":["P01.C","P02.B"],"title":"德性伦理学","description":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。","explore":"习惯与德性养成","question":"一个习惯很好的人，还需要能讲清自己为什么这样做吗？","tagline":"讲得明白之后，你还在等行动跟上。","dimension":"ethics","shareTitle":"德性修习者","shareSummary":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。"},{"id":"faith_suspend","topic":"R","all":["R01.B","R02.A"],"title":"证据主义","description":"相信一件事，应当有与信念相称的证据。","explore":"信念的证据与论证","question":"所有重要的生活承诺，都需要同一种证据吗？","tagline":"面对终极解释，你仍想把理由问清楚。","dimension":"beliefReasons","shareTitle":"求证者","shareSummary":"相信一件事，应当有与信念相称的证据。"},{"id":"history_context","topic":"H","all":["H01.B","H02.B"],"title":"历史主义","description":"理解思想与制度，要把它们放回形成和变化的历史中。","explore":"观念与历史条件","question":"看清一个想法从哪里来之后，还需要怎样判断它是否成立？","tagline":"你开始检查那些习以为常的想法。","dimension":"historicalContext","shareTitle":"历史解读者","shareSummary":"理解思想与制度，要把它们放回形成和变化的历史中。"}],"singleAnswerPositions":[{"answer":"FP01.A","dimension":"world","title":"唯物主义","description":"物质是世界的基础，意识由物质活动产生。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"唯物主义者","shareSummary":"物质是世界的基础，意识由物质活动产生。","conflictsWith":["T34.A"]},{"answer":"FP01.B","dimension":"world","title":"唯心主义","description":"精神或意识是世界的根本，物质世界依赖于它。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"唯心主义者","shareSummary":"精神或意识是世界的根本，物质世界依赖于它。"},{"answer":"FP01.C","dimension":"world","title":"心物二元论","description":"心灵与物质是两类根本不同的存在。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"心物二元论者","shareSummary":"心灵与物质是两类根本不同的存在。","conflictsWith":["T34.B"]},{"answer":"FP02.A","dimension":"history","title":"历史唯物主义","description":"人们怎样生产和生活，构成了社会制度与思想发展的基础。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"历史唯物主义者","shareSummary":"人们怎样生产和生活，构成了社会制度与思想发展的基础。"},{"answer":"FP02.B","dimension":"history","title":"观念主导的历史观","description":"思想和观念是推动历史变化的主要力量。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"观念推动者","shareSummary":"思想和观念是推动历史变化的主要力量。"},{"answer":"FP02.C","dimension":"history","title":"多因素历史解释","description":"历史由经济、制度和思想等多种力量共同推动。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"历史探索者","shareSummary":"历史由经济、制度和思想等多种力量共同推动。"},{"answer":"FP03.A","dimension":"politics","title":"社会主义取向","description":"生产资源应由社会共同掌握，劳动者应参与生产和分配的决定。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"社会主义者","shareSummary":"生产资源应由社会共同掌握，劳动者应参与生产和分配的决定。"},{"answer":"FP03.B","dimension":"politics","title":"社会民主主义取向","description":"保留市场经济，同时以公共服务、劳动保障和再分配促进平等。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"社会民主主义者","shareSummary":"保留市场经济，同时以公共服务、劳动保障和再分配促进平等。"},{"answer":"FP03.C","dimension":"politics","title":"自由至上主义取向","description":"个人自由与正当财产权应受到严格保护，国家的强制干预应受限制。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"自由至上主义者","shareSummary":"个人自由与正当财产权应受到严格保护，国家的强制干预应受限制。"},{"answer":"FP04.A","dimension":"ethics","title":"后果主义","description":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"后果主义者","shareSummary":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。"},{"answer":"FP04.B","dimension":"ethics","title":"义务论","description":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"义务论者","shareSummary":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。"},{"answer":"FP04.C","dimension":"ethics","title":"德性伦理学","description":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"德性修习者","shareSummary":"道德关乎成为怎样的人，以及如何养成品格、作出恰当判断。"},{"answer":"FP05.A","dimension":"religion","title":"有神论","description":"神存在，并且是世界存在的根源。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"有神论者","shareSummary":"神存在，并且是世界存在的根源。"},{"answer":"FP05.B","dimension":"religion","title":"无神论","description":"神并不存在，世界可以从自然本身来理解。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"无神论者","shareSummary":"神并不存在，世界可以从自然本身来理解。"},{"answer":"FP05.C","dimension":"religion","title":"不可知论","description":"神是否存在，目前无法确定。","foundational":true,"shareTitle":"不可知论者","shareSummary":"神是否存在，目前无法确定。"},{"answer":"W01.A","dimension":"external","title":"外部世界实在论","description":"外部世界独立存在，即使无人感知，也依然存在。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"实在论者","shareSummary":"外部世界独立存在，即使无人感知，也依然存在。"},{"answer":"W01.B","dimension":"external","title":"悬置对外部世界的判断","description":"对外部世界保留判断，因为“超出一切经验的存在”含义尚不清楚。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"存疑者","shareSummary":"对外部世界保留判断，因为“超出一切经验的存在”含义尚不清楚。"},{"answer":"W01.C","dimension":"external","title":"实在论与概念建构","description":"世界独立存在，但我们划分和理解事物的方式包含人为的概念。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"世界解读者","shareSummary":"世界独立存在，但我们划分和理解事物的方式包含人为的概念。"},{"answer":"Q11.C","dimension":"knowledge","title":"经验与理性相结合","description":"认识世界既需要经验提供材料，也需要理性进行理解和判断。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"综合探索者","shareSummary":"认识世界既需要经验提供材料，也需要理性进行理解和判断。"},{"answer":"Q09.B","dimension":"mind","title":"意识的解释鸿沟","description":"知道大脑怎样运转，仍未说明它为什么会产生亲身感受。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"心灵追问者","shareSummary":"知道大脑怎样运转，仍未说明它为什么会产生亲身感受。"},{"answer":"Q07.A","dimension":"meaning","title":"人生意义的主体论","description":"人生的意义来自自己重视的事，以及对它们的投入。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"人生作者","shareSummary":"人生的意义来自自己重视的事，以及对它们的投入。"},{"answer":"Q07.B","dimension":"meaning","title":"人生意义的客观论","description":"有些事本身值得追求，其意义不取决于个人是否喜欢。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"理想追寻者","shareSummary":"有些事本身值得追求，其意义不取决于个人是否喜欢。"},{"answer":"Q07.C","dimension":"meaning","title":"荒诞主义","description":"人渴望人生的答案，世界却保持沉默；我们仍能清醒地生活和反抗。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"荒诞主义者","shareSummary":"人渴望人生的答案，世界却保持沉默；我们仍能清醒地生活和反抗。"},{"answer":"A01.A","dimension":"aesthetics","title":"审美主观主义","description":"美取决于欣赏者的感受和评价。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"随心鉴赏家","shareSummary":"美取决于欣赏者的感受和评价。"},{"answer":"A01.B","dimension":"aesthetics","title":"审美客观主义取向","description":"美有超出个人喜好的依据，作品的优劣可以讨论和判断。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"美的求索者","shareSummary":"美有超出个人喜好的依据，作品的优劣可以讨论和判断。"},{"answer":"A01.C","dimension":"aesthetics","title":"艺术语境主义","description":"作品的艺术价值，要结合它所处的文化、时代和创作背景来理解。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"艺术语境派","shareSummary":"作品的艺术价值，要结合它所处的文化、时代和创作背景来理解。"},{"answer":"Q04.C","dimension":"freedom","title":"反思自主性","description":"自由在于能审视自己的理由，并据此决定怎样行动。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"自省者","shareSummary":"自由在于能审视自己的理由，并据此决定怎样行动。"},{"answer":"Q04.A","title":"相容论","description":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"相容论者","shareSummary":"自由意志可以与因果决定并存：有原因的选择，也可以出于自愿。"},{"answer":"Q04.B","title":"不相容论","description":"如果每个选择早已由过去和自然规律决定，人就没有自由意志。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"自由追问者","shareSummary":"如果每个选择早已由过去和自然规律决定，人就没有自由意志。"},{"answer":"Q09.A","title":"物理主义","description":"一切存在最终都是物理的，意识也依赖于物理过程。","dimension":"mind","shareTitle":"物理主义者","shareSummary":"一切存在最终都是物理的，意识也依赖于物理过程。"},{"answer":"Q09.C","title":"具身认知","description":"思考与感知受身体、行动和环境共同塑造。","dimension":"mind","shareTitle":"身体体验派","shareSummary":"思考与感知受身体、行动和环境共同塑造。"},{"answer":"Q11.A","title":"理性主义","description":"有些知识可以凭理性获得，无须依靠感官经验。","dimension":"knowledge","shareTitle":"理性主义者","shareSummary":"有些知识可以凭理性获得，无须依靠感官经验。"},{"answer":"Q11.B","title":"经验主义","description":"关于世界的知识，最终要以感官经验为依据。","dimension":"knowledge","shareTitle":"经验主义者","shareSummary":"关于世界的知识，最终要以感官经验为依据。"},{"answer":"Q05.A","title":"科学实在论","description":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。","dimension":"science","shareTitle":"科学实在论者","shareSummary":"科学理论能够认识真实世界，包括电子这类无法直接看见的事物。"},{"answer":"Q05.B","title":"科学工具主义","description":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。","dimension":"science","shareTitle":"工具主义者","shareSummary":"科学理论是预测和解释现象的工具，用得好也未必意味着它说出了世界真相。"},{"answer":"Q08.A","title":"道德实在论","description":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。","dimension":"metaethics","shareTitle":"道德实在论者","shareSummary":"存在客观的道德对错，即使所有人赞成，也可能判断错误。"},{"answer":"Q02.A","title":"后果主义","description":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。","dimension":"ethics","shareTitle":"后果主义者","shareSummary":"行动的对错，取决于它带来的整体后果。"},{"answer":"Q02.B","title":"义务论","description":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。","dimension":"ethics","shareTitle":"义务论者","shareSummary":"判断对错要依据应尽的义务；好结果也未必能使一种做法正当。"},{"answer":"Q06.A","title":"程序正义","description":"公平取决于决定事情的规则和过程是否公正。","dimension":"distribution","shareTitle":"规则守护者","shareSummary":"公平取决于决定事情的规则和过程是否公正。"},{"answer":"Q06.B","title":"机会平等主义","description":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。","dimension":"distribution","shareTitle":"公平倡导者","shareSummary":"每个人都应有公平的发展机会，出身不应决定前途。"},{"answer":"Q06.C","title":"充足主义","description":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。","dimension":"distribution","shareTitle":"生活守护者","shareSummary":"分配的关键，是每个人都拥有足够的生活条件。"},{"answer":"Q01.A","title":"享乐主义","description":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。","dimension":"wellbeing","shareTitle":"享乐主义者","shareSummary":"快乐本身使生活变好，痛苦本身使生活变坏。生活的好坏最终取决于二者。"},{"answer":"Q01.B","title":"非享乐主义","description":"好的人生还需要快乐感受之外的真实经历，以及与真实世界的联系。","dimension":"wellbeing","shareTitle":"真实生活家","shareSummary":"好的人生还需要快乐以外的东西，例如真实经历或有价值的行动。"},{"answer":"Q01.C","title":"非享乐主义","description":"好的人生不止于被动的愉快感受，亲自行动并改变现实本身就有价值。","dimension":"wellbeing","shareTitle":"真实生活家","shareSummary":"好的人生还需要快乐以外的东西，例如真实经历或有价值的行动。"},{"answer":"Q03.A","title":"身体连续性理论","description":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。","dimension":"self","shareTitle":"生命延续派","shareSummary":"你之所以仍是原来的你，在于身体和生命一直延续。"},{"answer":"Q03.B","title":"心理连续性理论","description":"记忆、性格和意图之间的延续，使你仍是原来的你。","dimension":"self","shareTitle":"记忆延续派","shareSummary":"记忆、性格和意图之间的延续，使你仍是原来的你。"},{"answer":"Q10.A","title":"因果决定论","description":"过去的状态和自然规律，决定了接下来唯一可能发生的事。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"因果决定论者","shareSummary":"过去的状态和自然规律，决定了接下来唯一可能发生的事。"},{"answer":"Q10.B","title":"非决定论","description":"即使过去的条件和自然规律完全相同，未来也并非只有唯一结果，人仍可能走向另一条路。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"可能性探索者","shareSummary":"同样的过去和自然规律，可以容许不止一种未来。"},{"answer":"Q10.C","title":"非决定论","description":"同样的过去未必只有唯一结果，但这种不确定究竟来自主动选择还是随机变化，仍需区分。","dimension":"freedom","shareTitle":"可能性探索者","shareSummary":"同样的过去和自然规律，可以容许不止一种未来。"},{"answer":"T34.A","dimension":"world","title":"心物二元论","description":"心灵与物质是两类根本不同的存在。","foundational":false,"shareTitle":"心物二元论者","shareSummary":"心灵与物质是两类根本不同的存在。"},{"answer":"T34.B","title":"物理主义","description":"一切存在最终都是物理的，意识也依赖于物理过程。","dimension":"mind","shareTitle":"物理主义者","shareSummary":"一切存在最终都是物理的，意识也依赖于物理过程。"}],"dimensionLabels":{"world":"世界的根本","external":"外部世界","mind":"意识与身体","knowledge":"知识从哪里来","history":"历史与社会","politics":"社会与财产","ethics":"判断对错的依据","metaethics":"道德是否客观","freedom":"自由意志","meaning":"人生意义","self":"自我与身份","science":"科学与解释","language":"语言与理解","aesthetics":"美与艺术","practice":"修养与行动","religion":"神与信仰","causation":"因果与归纳","historicalContext":"观念与时代","wellbeing":"好的人生","distribution":"分配公平","beliefReasons":"信仰的理由"},"dimensionOrder":["world","history","knowledge","ethics","politics","mind","external","metaethics","meaning","wellbeing","religion","freedom","causation","self","science","language","aesthetics","practice","historicalContext","distribution","beliefReasons"]},"learning":{"schemaVersion":1,"contentVersion":"0.4.5","editorialDate":"2026-10-13","items":[{"profileId":"p01","title":"从自然里找原因","body":"据后世记载，泰勒斯认为万物的根本是水。他尝试用同一种自然材料，解释形态不同的事物。冰和水外观不同，却能互相转化；由同一种材料形成的东西，也可以有很不一样的样子。","sourceIds":["source_p01"]},{"profileId":"p02","title":"变化也能有秩序","body":"一把弓靠弓身和弦之间相反的拉力维持张紧；如果拉力完全消失，它也就不能射箭。赫拉克利特用弓这样的例子说明，对立有时正是整体能够成立的条件。他因此把世界的变化与秩序联系起来：变化可以按照一定的关系发生，而非完全混乱。","sourceIds":["source_p02"]},{"profileId":"p03","title":"推理能走到哪里","body":"巴门尼德认为，真正的存在不可能从完全的“无”中产生：如果那里什么都没有，就无法说明有什么能使它产生。他也认为，存在不能变成完全的不存在。因此，他把真正的存在理解为不生不灭。感官明明告诉我们事物在变化，他却更相信这套推理；感官与推理发生冲突时该相信哪一个，正是他的哲学留下的难题。","sourceIds":["source_p03"]},{"profileId":"p04","title":"感觉背后的排列","body":"德谟克利特认为，世界由原子和虚空构成：原子是不可再分的微小物体，虚空给它们留下运动的空间。不同原子的形状、排列和运动，可以形成不同事物，也会使感官产生不同的颜色和味道。这是古代原子论解释自然的办法。","sourceIds":["source_p04"]},{"profileId":"p05","title":"把习以为常的想法问清楚","body":"一个人可能很会使用“勇敢”“正义”这些词，却说不清它们是什么意思。苏格拉底通过追问和反例，让人发现自己意见中的困难。他看重这种检验，因为生活中的选择会受到这些未经检查的想法支配。","sourceIds":["source_p05"]},{"profileId":"p06","title":"我们凭什么判断好坏","body":"纸上画出的圆总有误差，我们却能理解什么是一个完美的圆。柏拉图把“圆本身”这类稳定的对象称为“理念”，认为它们独立于具体事物和个人想法而存在。我们用它来判断画出的圆是否准确。他也用类似思路理解美和正义：人们判断一件事是否公正，需要一个比眼前个例和个人好恶更稳定的标准。","sourceIds":["source_p06"]},{"profileId":"p07","title":"好品格是怎样练出来的","body":"知道勇敢是什么意思，遇到危险时也可能退缩。亚里士多德认为，勇敢、节制等好品格需要通过反复行动来养成，他把这些稳定的好品格称为“德性”。但一味往前冲也可能是鲁莽：面对怎样的危险、为了什么目的、是否值得冒险，都需要判断。他把在具体处境中作出恰当判断的能力称为“实践智慧”。","sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p07_nature"],"topics":[{"id":"p07_ethics","title":"好品格是怎样练出来的","questionIds":["T10","T11","P01","FP04"],"body":"知道勇敢是什么意思，遇到危险时也可能退缩。亚里士多德认为，勇敢、节制等好品格需要通过反复行动来养成，他把这些稳定的好品格称为“德性”。但一味往前冲也可能是鲁莽：面对怎样的危险、为了什么目的、是否值得冒险，都需要判断。他把在具体处境中作出恰当判断的能力称为“实践智慧”。"},{"id":"p07_nature","title":"一棵树为什么这样生长","questionIds":["T07"],"body":"亚里士多德认为，解释一棵树的生长，既要说明它由什么组成，也要说明它怎样组织成一个整体，各部分有什么作用。根吸收养分、叶片参与生长，这些部分之间的联系不能从解释中省去。他把形式和目的也列为自然研究需要追问的原因。","sourceIds":["source_p07_nature"]}]},{"profileId":"p08","title":"少需要一点，就少受制一点","body":"越依赖名声、财富和排场，越容易为了保住它们而迁就别人。第欧根尼用极简的生活挑战当时的习俗：许多被当成必需品的东西，其实可以舍弃。减少这些依赖，是犬儒学派追求自由的一条路。","sourceIds":["source_p08"]},{"profileId":"p09","title":"快乐也有眼前与长远之别","body":"伊壁鸠鲁把快乐看作生活的目标，但追求快乐需要会作选择：一时的享受可能带来更长的痛苦，无止境地追求名声和财富也会使人焦虑。他因此重视容易满足的基本需要、身体少受痛苦、心中安宁，以及可靠的友谊。","sourceIds":["source_p09"]},{"profileId":"p10","title":"把力气放在哪里","body":"爱比克泰德区分我们能决定的事与不能决定的事。比如，参加比赛时，你能认真准备、诚实面对表现，却无法保证获胜或得到赞扬。如果把生活的好坏全押在胜负上，就会被结果牵着走。他更重视自己怎样判断和行动，因为这些才是自己应当负责的部分。","sourceIds":["source_p10"]},{"profileId":"p11","title":"怎样面对不如意的人和事","body":"马可·奥勒留认为，别人的评价和事情的结果常常不由自己决定，自己的判断与行动却值得认真对待。面对冒犯时，理解自己为何愤怒，有助于决定怎样回应。他同时认为，人需要彼此合作，所以照顾他人、承担公共责任，也是过好生活的一部分。","sourceIds":["source_p11"]},{"profileId":"p12","title":"暂时不下结论，也能生活","body":"当支持和反对的理由同样有力时，塞克斯都主张对争论保留判断，继续考察，这叫作“悬置判断”。判断悬而未决，日子照样能过：饿了吃饭，冷了添衣，人依照眼前的感受和习惯行动。他认为，执意为争议问题找出定论，常常使人烦扰；悬置判断则可能带来安宁。","sourceIds":["source_p12"]},{"profileId":"p13","title":"世界怎样从“一”产生","body":"一个整体包含许多部分，还需要解释这些部分为什么能成为一个整体。普罗提诺把这个终极源头称为“太一”（或“一者”）：它是世间万物的共同源泉，本身纯粹完满，不再由任何更小的部分拼成。在他看来，如果最终来源仍是复杂的东西，就还需要解释它的统一从何而来。他也把反省自己的心灵，看作认识这个根源的途径。","sourceIds":["source_p13"]},{"profileId":"p14","title":"恶为什么被说成一种缺失","body":"奥古斯丁把恶理解为善的受损或缺失。以疾病为例，我们说身体生病，是因为原本应有的健康功能遭到了破坏；如果完全没有生命，也就无所谓疾病。类似地，他认为恶意是意志偏离了应当追求的善。他因此承认恶会造成伤害，但认为它是好东西遭到破坏，而不是另一种与善对抗的独立存在。","sourceIds":["source_p14"]},{"profileId":"p15","title":"已经相信，为什么还要论证","body":"安瑟尔谟把上帝理解为“无法设想比它更伟大的存在”。他的推理是：如果这个存在只在思想中，那么我们就能设想一个既在思想中、又真实存在的对象，并认为后者更伟大。这就与最初的定义冲突，所以他认为上帝必须真实存在。这通常被称为上帝存在的“本体论论证”。争议就在这一步：仅仅分析一个概念，能否证明现实中一定有它对应的东西？","sourceIds":["source_p15"]},{"profileId":"p16","title":"知道是什么，还没解释为什么存在","body":"我们可以说清一种生物具有什么特征，却仍不知道现实中有没有它。阿维森纳把事物“是什么”称为本质，并把它与“实际存在”区分开。如果一个东西必须依靠其他条件才能存在，知道它是什么，还没有解释它为何会存在。他进一步提出“必然存在者”，指不依赖其他原因、本身就必须存在的根源。","sourceIds":["source_p16"]},{"profileId":"p17","title":"当论证与经文字面冲突","body":"阿威罗伊认为，宗教经典要求人思考世界，而严密的哲学论证正是一种思考方式。如果可靠的论证与经文的字面意思冲突，就可能需要用比喻等方式理解经文。例如，一段描述可能是在帮助人领会道理，而非逐字描述一个物理过程。在他看来，这样解释经典可以使理性研究与信仰相互配合。","sourceIds":["source_p17"]},{"profileId":"p18","title":"理性怎样参与道德生活","body":"阿奎那认为，人能够通过理性认识保护生命、追求知识、共同生活等基本需要，并由此理解应当怎样行动。他称这种凭理性认识的道德要求为“自然法”。例如，共同生活需要信任，所以人有理由避免欺骗和伤害。信仰不同的人，也能够理解这些理由。","sourceIds":["source_p18"]},{"profileId":"p19","title":"是什么让你成为这一个人","body":"两个人都具有人的共同特征，却仍是两个不同的人。司各脱认为，除了共同的性质，每个个体身上还有一种让它成为“这一个”而非“那一个”的独特底子，哲学上称为“此性”（这一个性）。这个概念要解释的是：为什么眼前这个人是他自己，而不只是“人”这个类别中的一个例子。在行动问题上，司各脱也重视意志的选择能力：看出一件事对自己有利，并不意味着自己只能选择它。","sourceIds":["source_p19"]},{"profileId":"p20","title":"具体的树之外，还有“树本身”吗","body":"我们把许多不同的植物都称为“树”。奥卡姆认为，具体的树和指向它们的共同概念，已经能够解释这种分类。如果还要认为有一个独立存在的“树本身”，就得说明它究竟帮助解释了什么。他主张让假设与解释的需要相称，已有解释足够时，额外增加对象反而显得多余。","sourceIds":["source_p20"]},{"profileId":"p21","title":"政治为什么离不开冲突","body":"马基雅维利认为，政治生活中不同群体有不同的利益，冲突很难完全消除。他在讨论罗马时指出，平民与贵族的冲突有时反而推动了保护自由的制度。因此，判断一场冲突需要考察它形成了怎样的权力安排，以及谁能约束掌权者。","sourceIds":["source_p21"]},{"profileId":"p22","title":"别只收集证明自己对的例子","body":"人很容易注意到符合期待的现象，把相反的例子放在一边。培根把这种倾向当作认识自然的障碍。他要求有组织地比较观察结果，尤其认真处理不符合解释的情况，让经验反过来修正想法。","sourceIds":["source_p22"]},{"profileId":"p23","title":"有什么是怀疑时也绕不过去的","body":"笛卡尔尝试怀疑一切可能出错的认识：感官有时会误导人，梦境也可能看起来像现实。但只要此刻正在怀疑，就一定正在思考；即使想否认自己的存在，这个否认仍需要有人在想。这就是“我思故我在”的基本推理。他想由此找到一个怀疑也无法推翻的起点，再重新建立知识。","topics":[{"questionIds":["T33"],"title":"有什么是怀疑时也绕不过去的","body":"笛卡尔尝试怀疑一切可能出错的认识：感官有时会误导人，梦境也可能看起来像现实。但只要此刻正在怀疑，就一定正在思考；即使想否认自己的存在，这个否认仍需要有人在想。这就是“我思故我在”的基本推理。他想由此找到一个怀疑也无法推翻的起点，再重新建立知识。"},{"questionIds":["T34"],"title":"心灵与身体，是两种东西吗？","body":"笛卡尔认为，身体的根本特征是占据空间，心灵的根本特征则是思考。他试图论证，两者可以分开存在，因此属于两类不同的东西。这就是他的心物二元论。但如果两者如此不同，想抬手的念头又怎样使手动起来？说明心灵与身体如何相互影响，是这一立场要面对的难题。"}],"sourceIds":["source_p23"]},{"profileId":"p24","title":"没有共同裁决者，会发生什么","body":"如果没有共同执行规则的权威，即使你无意伤害别人，也可能担心受到攻击而抢先动手。霍布斯认为，这种相互恐惧会使合作和承诺变得不可靠。他主张建立能够裁决争端、执行规则的公共权威，使人们的安全得到共同保障。","sourceIds":["source_p24"]},{"profileId":"p25","title":"理解原因，怎样让人更自由","body":"斯宾诺莎认为，欲望和情绪也有原因。比如，你以为自己只是“想赢过同事”，后来发现，自己一直把他人的赞扬当作衡量价值的标准。弄清这个原因，就有机会重新考虑怎样行动。在他看来，自由可以随着这种理解而增加：人越能理解自己为何这样想，就越有机会按理性的认识生活。","sourceIds":["source_p25"]},{"profileId":"p26","title":"经验、记忆与同一个人","body":"洛克认为，颜色、声音等观念来自感官；我们也能觉察自己在思考、怀疑或作决定，从而认识心中的活动，他把这种认识来源叫作“反省”。讨论一个人为什么仍是原来的那个人时，洛克重视意识能否连接过去与现在：一个人能够把过去的经历认作自己的，就能把当时的自己与现在的自己联系起来。这也成为后来心理连续性理论的重要来源。","sourceIds":["source_p26","locke_personal_identity"]},{"profileId":"p27","title":"为什么偏偏是这样","body":"莱布尼茨认为，每一件事实都应有充分的理由说明：为什么是这样，而不是别的样子。我们可能还不知道理由，但不能仅因暂时找不到，就断定它没有理由。另一条相关原则是，如果两个东西的全部特征都毫无区别，就没有理由把它们认作两个不同的东西。这些原则帮助他说明世界为何如此安排，以及个体如何彼此区别。","sourceIds":["source_p27"]},{"profileId":"p28","title":"桌子存在，究竟意味着什么","body":"贝克莱指出，我们认识桌子时，接触的是颜色、触感等被感知的内容。他质疑的是：在这些内容背后，是否还有一种永远无法被感知的物质？他用被感知的内容及其秩序来解释经验中的对象，并用上帝的持续感知说明世界为何能持续存在。","sourceIds":["source_p28"]},{"profileId":"p29","title":"过去如此，明天就一定如此吗","body":"太阳过去每天升起，我们自然会期待明天也如此。休谟指出，过去的重复并不能在逻辑上保证未来必然一样：要用过去证明未来，又已经假定了未来会延续过去的规律。他认为习惯在形成这种期待时起着重要作用。我们依靠这些期待生活，但对其确定程度需要有清楚的认识。","sourceIds":["source_p29"],"topics":[{"questionIds":["V03"],"title":"过去如此，明天就一定如此吗","body":"太阳过去每天升起，我们自然会期待明天也如此。休谟指出，过去的重复并不能在逻辑上保证未来必然一样：要用过去证明未来，又已经假定了未来会延续过去的规律。他认为习惯在形成这种期待时起着重要作用。我们依靠这些期待生活，但对其确定程度需要有清楚的认识。"},{"questionIds":["T43"],"title":"知道别人会痛苦，为什么会想帮他","body":"休谟认为，知道一件事会使别人痛苦，是关于事实的认识；要因此想帮助对方，还需要同情或关心。一个完全不在乎他人的人，即使把后果算得很清楚，也未必产生帮助的意愿。因此，在他的道德哲学中，情感参与了道德判断，也使人愿意行动。"},{"questionIds":["Q04"],"title":"选择有原因，也可以自由","body":"休谟认为，人的行为有原因，与人能自由行动可以同时成立。例如，你因为喜欢音乐而决定去听演奏，这个愿望有形成的经历，但只要没人强迫你，你仍可以按照自己的意愿行动。他用这种自由观区分自愿行为与受胁迫的行为。"},{"questionIds":["Q11"],"title":"认识现实为什么需要经验","body":"休谟认为，要知道现实中发生什么、什么会导致什么，需要依靠经验。只分析概念，无法代替观察。例如，仅靠推理不能确定某个陌生物体会不会燃烧；我们需要实际见过它怎样变化，才有依据作出判断。"}]},{"profileId":"p30","title":"让权力受到约束","body":"孟德斯鸠担心，拥有权力的人容易不断扩大自己的权力。因此，制度要让权力受到其他权力的约束。他也强调，法律要放在当地的习惯、社会条件和政体中理解，不能只凭抽象条文判断。","sourceIds":["source_p30"]},{"profileId":"p31","title":"为什么要给异见留位置","body":"人可能在最确信的时候犯错，不同信仰也不该成为迫害的理由。伏尔泰借宗教冲突和不公案件批评狂热。他关注无辜者遭受的苦难，也由此追问：面对这样的遭遇，宣称一切安排都最好，究竟解释了什么？","sourceIds":["source_p31","voltaire_lisbon"]},{"profileId":"p32","title":"共同生活怎样仍然自由","body":"卢梭认为，自由可以包含共同制定并遵守规则。公民不只问“这对我眼下是否有利”，也要考虑大家作为平等成员共同需要什么。他把这种面向共同利益的意志称为“公意”。如果规则真正出自这样的共同立法，服从它就可以理解为参与管理自己的社会，而非单纯听命于某个人。","sourceIds":["source_p32"]},{"profileId":"p33","title":"所谓天性，会不会是培养的结果","body":"如果女孩从小只被教导讨人喜欢，长大后又因为缺乏独立能力而受轻视，把这种欠缺当成天性，就漏掉了教育在其中起的作用。沃斯通克拉夫特要求女性获得发展理性和品格的机会。平等因此也关乎人被允许成长为什么样的人。","sourceIds":["source_p33"]},{"profileId":"p34","title":"好结果能让手段正当吗","body":"康德要求人检查自己行动时所依据的原则：能否也让别人照着同一原则行动？如果为了方便就随意许下假承诺，承诺赖以成立的信任也会被破坏。他还强调，每个人都有自己的目的，不能只被拿来完成别人的计划。","sourceIds":["source_p34"]},{"profileId":"p35","title":"从行动理解自我","body":"费希特从人的活动来理解“自我”：我们认识事物、设定目标，也在遇到阻碍时尝试改变处境。人在与他人的交往中，还会把自己理解为能选择、能承担责任的人。他因此重视“相互承认”，也就是我把你当作能自主行动的人，同时要求你这样对待我。","sourceIds":["source_p35"]},{"profileId":"p36","title":"自然与心灵的联系","body":"早期谢林认为，自然有形成和组织生命的能力，心灵也在自然的发展中出现。他希望用同一个理论说明自然与心灵的联系。艺术为他提供了一个例子：创作有明确的计划，却也会产生艺术家没有预料到、无法完全说清的结果。","sourceIds":["source_p36"]},{"profileId":"p37","title":"自由需要怎样的制度","body":"一个人想签订合同，但社会不承认他的法律身份，他就无法真正行使这个权利。黑格尔认为，自由需要这样的社会条件：人们承认彼此的权利，制度也提供实际行使权利的办法。因此，他把家庭、经济生活和国家制度都纳入自由的讨论，考察人在共同生活中怎样成为能够自主行动的人。","sourceIds":["source_p37"]},{"profileId":"p38","title":"欲望为什么总让人不满足","body":"叔本华认为，欲望使人不断感到欠缺：想要时难受，得到后满足常常很短，又会无聊或追求下一个目标。人由此反复处在痛苦与厌倦之间。他认为，专注欣赏艺术时，人可能暂时忘记个人欲望；同情则让人注意到别人的痛苦，不再只围着自己的得失行动。","sourceIds":["source_p38"]},{"profileId":"p39","title":"人在神圣形象中看见了什么","body":"费尔巴哈认为，人把自己向往的爱、智慧和力量想象成无限完美的样子，再把这些品质归给神。这样一来，本来是人对美好能力的向往，却被理解为来自人之外的神圣力量。他希望人重新认识这些品质与自己的关系，在现实中发展爱的能力，而不只把爱寄托于神。","sourceIds":["source_p39"]},{"profileId":"p40","title":"工作为什么会让人感到不像自己","body":"一个工人生产出商品，却不能决定生产什么、怎样生产，劳动成果也由别人支配。马克思用“异化”分析这种处境：本来属于人的劳动能力和创造物，反过来成为控制人的力量。因此，即使工资提高，劳动者仍可能觉得工作只是为了活下去而被迫完成的事。要理解这种问题，还得弄清谁拥有生产资料、谁能够决定劳动过程。","sourceIds":["source_p40"]},{"profileId":"p41","title":"家庭、财产与继承","body":"恩格斯把家庭的变化与谋生、财产和继承方式联系起来考察。例如，谁拥有财产、财产传给谁，会影响婚姻和亲属关系怎样安排。他也认为，国家是在特定历史条件下形成的，可以随着这些条件改变。在他看来，家庭和国家都有各自形成、变化的历史。","sourceIds":["source_p41"]},{"profileId":"p42","title":"信仰为什么需要亲自选择","body":"克尔凯郭尔认为，有些选择无法等到一切都被证明之后再作出。一个人可以了解很多关于信仰的论证，却仍要亲自决定是否信仰，并承担这一选择对生活的影响。他关注的是这种无法由旁人代劳的承诺，以及作出承诺的人怎样生活。","sourceIds":["source_p42"]},{"profileId":"p43","title":"道德观念的来历","body":"尼采会追查一种道德最初由谁提出、在什么处境中形成，又鼓励人怎样生活。例如，一种被赞美的克制，究竟来自主动的自我要求，还是来自无力行动后的怨恨？他认为，了解这些来历，才能更充分地评价这种道德。当旧标准失去说服力，人也需要尝试建立自己愿意承担的新价值。","sourceIds":["source_p43"]},{"profileId":"p44","title":"每个人的苦乐都要算进去","body":"边沁用快乐和痛苦评价行动与制度，希望把不同人的利益放在同一张账上。一个人的出身或地位，不该让他的痛苦自动更轻。做决定时，需要比较影响的强度、持续时间和范围等因素。","sourceIds":["source_p44"]},{"profileId":"p45","title":"人需要选择自己的生活","body":"密尔重视个性的发展。人只有亲自选择、尝试和修正生活，判断力才有机会成长。因此，对能够自主负责的成年人，仅仅觉得他的生活方式不好，还不足以成为强制干预的理由；是否伤害他人，是重要的界限。","sourceIds":["source_p45","mill_liberty","mill_utilitarianism"],"topics":[{"questionIds":["T64"],"title":"快乐还有质量之分吗？","body":"密尔认为，比较快乐不能只数它有多强、持续多久。有些快乐会运用人的思考、想象和情感能力；充分体验过两种快乐的人，可能宁愿承担更多辛苦，也不愿放弃其中一种。他用这种比较来说明快乐还有质量之分。","example":"举个今天的例子：看懂一本难书很费力，你却仍愿意花这个时间。密尔会问，这种满足要不要单独算一算，还是折成轻松愉快的分钟数就够了。"},{"questionIds":["T65"],"title":"别人看不惯，为什么还不够？","body":"密尔认为，亲自选择、尝试和修正生活，是人成长的一部分。如果社会把所有不合习惯的生活都压下去，个人失去练习判断的机会，大家也难以发现其他可能。对于能够自主负责的成年人，防止伤害他人是强制干预的重要理由。","example":"比如朋友选了一份你觉得没有前途的工作。你可以劝他、讨论风险，但仅仅觉得他选错了，还不足以替他作主。"},{"questionIds":["T63"],"title":"谁的幸福应该算进去？","body":"密尔的功利主义要求把受影响者的幸福都纳入考虑。一个人是熟人还是陌生人、地位高还是低，不该直接决定他的幸福有多重要。这让道德判断需要超出眼前的个人偏好，认真考察行动对所有相关者的影响。","example":"分配有限的帮助时，每个人受到的影响都应算在内，亲近关系并不使陌生人的处境变得次要。"}]},{"profileId":"p46","title":"两个说法到底差在哪里","body":"皮尔士认为，要弄懂两个概念有何不同，可以问两件事：如果一个说法成立，我们会观察到什么，又会怎样行动？换成另一个说法，这些地方会不会不一样？如果所有可设想的后果都相同，争论就可能只是用词不同。他也重视共同检验：一个想法要不断面对别人的观察和批评，错误才能被发现和纠正。","sourceIds":["source_p46"]},{"profileId":"p47","title":"有些决定等不到证据齐全","body":"有时，等待证据本身也是一种选择。例如，一段关系只有在双方愿意信任时才可能建立；坚持要对方证明自己绝对可信，可能让这段关系失去机会。詹姆斯认为，当选择真正可行、重大而且无法回避，证据又不足以决定时，希望和愿意承担的承诺也可以参与决定。","sourceIds":["source_p47"]},{"profileId":"p48","title":"在解决问题时修改想法","body":"杜威认为，思考常从具体困难开始。我们试着理解问题、提出办法，并在实践中检验效果；意料之外的困难既可能来自办法不合适，也可能说明问题一开始就理解错了。教育和公共讨论应当给人参与、尝试和修正的机会，让人学会共同解决问题。","sourceIds":["source_p48"]},{"profileId":"p49","title":"为什么同样十分钟感觉不同","body":"听一段旋律时，前面的音还留在记忆里，影响你怎样听到后面的音。如果把每个音完全拆开，就不再是原来的旋律。柏格森用类似的经验解释“绵延”：亲身经历的时间彼此连续，过去会留在现在之中。钟表能把时间分成等长的单位，却无法单靠刻度说明这种经历。","sourceIds":["source_p49"]},{"profileId":"p50","title":"两个名字为什么能带来新知识","body":"“晨星”和“暮星”都指金星，但一个人可能知道晨星，却不知道它就是傍晚见到的暮星。弗雷格由此区分“指称”和“涵义”：指称是说到的那个对象，涵义是我们理解、认识它的方式。两个名称可以指向同一个对象，却有不同的涵义，所以“晨星就是暮星”仍能告诉我们新东西。","sourceIds":["source_p50"],"topics":[{"questionIds":["T72"],"title":"两个名字为什么能带来新知识","body":"“晨星”和“暮星”都指金星，但一个人可能知道晨星，却不知道它就是傍晚见到的暮星。弗雷格由此区分“指称”和“涵义”：指称是说到的那个对象，涵义是我们理解、认识它的方式。两个名称可以指向同一个对象，却有不同的涵义，所以“晨星就是暮星”仍能告诉我们新东西。"},{"questionIds":["T71"],"title":"逻辑来自思维习惯吗","body":"人习惯怎样想，和一个理由能否支持结论，是同一个问题吗？弗雷格认为，两者应当分开：人会受习惯影响，也会推错，但这些心理事实不能决定推理的对错。因此，逻辑要研究哪些推论成立，心理学则研究人实际上怎样思考。这就是他反对把逻辑建立在心理规律上的理由。"},{"questionIds":["W02"],"title":"数学的真假由谁决定","body":"弗雷格认为，数学中的真假不依赖某个人的想法。例如，一个人算错了，别人能够说明并纠正这个错误，是因为计算有共同的、可以检验的根据。他试图通过逻辑来解释算术为什么能够客观成立，而不把数看成每个人脑中各自的想象。"}]},{"profileId":"p51","title":"一句话的表面形式会误导人","body":"“当今法国国王是秃头。”法国没有国王，这句话究竟在说谁？罗素把它分析成三个判断：存在一位法国国王、只有一位法国国王，而且他是秃头。第一个判断不成立，因此整句话为假。这就是他的摹状词理论：把句子的逻辑结构说清楚，就能分析对不存在之物的描述，而不把“法国国王”当成某个神秘对象的名字。","sourceIds":["source_p51"]},{"profileId":"p52","title":"词语放回生活里才看得清","body":"后期维特根斯坦会问，一个词是在什么活动中被使用的。承诺、命令和描述各有自己的用法，脱离场景却要求它们都按同一模式工作，就容易产生困惑。理解规则，也需要了解人们怎样共同学习和纠正用法。","sourceIds":["source_p52"]},{"profileId":"p53","title":"不同的问题，依靠不同的语言规则","body":"卡尔纳普所说的“语言框架”，是一套谈论某类事物的词语和规则。例如，采用整数的规则后，我们可以直接计算有没有大于一百的质数，这是规则内部的问题。而要不要用这套语言描述某个实际问题，则取决于它是否方便、有用。他认为，两种问题的判断方法不同，不能混在一起。","sourceIds":["source_p53"]},{"profileId":"p54","title":"一次实验究竟在检验什么","body":"一次实验的预测，除了所检验的理论，还依赖仪器准确、实验条件符合要求等假定。如果结果不合预期，出问题的可能是理论，也可能是这些辅助假定。奎因由此强调，我们的信念相互联系，经验检验往往涉及整组信念，不能总凭一次失败就确定该放弃哪一句话。","sourceIds":["source_p54"]},{"profileId":"p55","title":"怎么发现，与是否必然不同","body":"我们靠实验才知道水是 H₂O。克里普克认为，这个事实虽然需要经验才能发现，却具有必然性：如果另一种液体外观和水完全一样，成分却不同，它也只是像水的另一种东西。这里区分的是两个问题：我们怎样知道一件事，以及这件事是否可能是另一种样子。","sourceIds":["source_p55"],"topics":[{"questionIds":["T77"],"title":"认错了事迹，还在说同一个人吗","body":"克里普克认为，一个名字通常通过最初的命名，以及人们后来的交流，继续指向同一个对象。假如我们发现一位作家的著作其实由别人完成，也未必把这个名字转给真正的作者；我们可能仍在说原来那个人，只是发现自己过去对他的认识有误。因此，名字指谁，不能完全等同于我们知道他做过什么。"},{"questionIds":["T78"],"title":"像水一样，就还是水吗","body":"我们通常凭颜色、味道和用途认出水，但这些特征是否决定了水是什么？克里普克认为，水的物质组成才是关键。假如另一种液体看起来、用起来都一样，组成却完全不同，那仍是另一种物质。发现水是 H₂O 需要实验，但他认为这不表示水本来可以由另一种物质构成。他把这种需要经验才能知道、却仍必然成立的真理称为“后验必然”。"}]},{"profileId":"p56","title":"同一个动作，可能在做不同的事","body":"一个人按下开关，灯亮了，同时惊动了窗外的人。他可能有意开灯，却完全不知道窗外有人。安斯康姆由此区分一个动作造成的后果与一个人有意做的事：要知道他在做什么，还得了解他当时知道什么、为了什么而行动。这些区别也会影响我们怎样判断他的责任。","sourceIds":["source_p56"]},{"profileId":"p57","title":"好理论要冒被事实推翻的风险","body":"如果无论发生什么，一种说法都能宣称自己正确，我们就很难真正检验它。波普尔要求理论面对可能反驳自己的结果，并接受严格批评。科学知识的成长依赖发现和纠正错误，而不是积累永远成功的解释。","sourceIds":["source_p57"]},{"profileId":"p58","title":"科学家为什么不会遇到反例就换理论","body":"库恩用“范式”指科学共同体共享的理论、典型解题方法和判断标准。遇到异常结果时，科学家通常会用已有办法处理，因为这些办法在许多问题上仍然有效。但当困难长期得不到解决，又出现了有力的新办法，研究问题的提法和评价解释的标准也可能一起改变，这就是他讨论的科学革命。","sourceIds":["source_p58"]},{"profileId":"p59","title":"经验中的事物怎样呈现","body":"从不同方向看一个杯子，眼前的形状会变，我们却始终把它认作同一个杯子。胡塞尔研究这类经验怎样形成：眼前看到的部分、记住的部分，以及对还没看到的部分的期待，如何联系在一起。他把对对象是否独立存在的判断暂时搁置，称为“悬搁”，借此专注于认识的过程。","sourceIds":["source_p59"]},{"profileId":"p60","title":"人在生活中理解世界","body":"熟练使用锤子时，人通常专注于修好东西，很少把锤子的形状和材料当作研究对象。海德格尔认为，我们与世界的关系往往从实际使用和共同生活中展开，事物的意义也与正在做的事情有关。他还关心人怎样面对有限的一生：生命终将结束，使那些必须由自己作出的生活选择变得突出。","sourceIds":["source_p60"]},{"profileId":"p61","title":"处境能解释选择，却不能代替选择","body":"萨特认为，人总是在具体处境中行动，但对处境采取什么态度，也构成自己的生活。把一切都归给角色、性格或环境，可能遮住自己仍在作的选择。因此，自由与承担行动的责任紧密相连。","sourceIds":["source_p61"]},{"profileId":"p62","title":"有许可，为什么还可能不自由","body":"规则给了女性选择职业的权利，实际机会还取决于她们身处的生活条件。如果一个女孩从小被教育成“这种工作不适合你”，又没有经济上的独立条件，她能选择的生活就会受到限制。波伏瓦把自由放在这些具体条件里讨论，也因此重视改变阻碍别人自主生活的教育、经济和社会安排。","sourceIds":["source_p62"]},{"profileId":"p63","title":"没有终极答案，生活还能继续吗","body":"人渴望知道人生最终有什么意义，世界却没有给出满意的答案。加缪把这种冲突称为“荒诞”。他认为，人可以承认这种处境，仍然投入生活、反抗压迫。但反抗也需要尊重具体的人：如果为了未来的理想就允许无限伤害眼前的人，反抗便可能造成新的压迫。","sourceIds":["source_p63"]},{"profileId":"p64","title":"身体怎样参与理解世界","body":"同一个台阶，对能轻松迈过去的人和行动受限的人，会有不同的意义。梅洛-庞蒂认为，我们总是带着身体的能力和习惯感知环境。熟练抓握、躲避或行走时，身体直接回应周围的情况，很少需要逐步计算。身体能做什么，也就影响着一个人怎样经历世界。","sourceIds":["source_p64"]},{"profileId":"p65","title":"带着过去，怎样理解别人","body":"读一本古书时，我们总会带着自己的语言习惯和生活经验。伽达默尔认为，这些已有认识帮助我们开始阅读，也可能使我们误解。遇到与预想不符的段落时，就需要重新检查自己的理解，确认文本是否支持它。理解在这样的反复比较中改变，读者也可能因此发现自己原先忽略的问题。","sourceIds":["source_p65"]},{"profileId":"p66","title":"为什么陌生人也会向我提出要求","body":"看到陌生人受苦时，我们可能已经觉得应该回应，尽管双方从未订过约定，他也未必能回报。列维纳斯称这样的他人为“他者”：他有自己的生活与需要，无法被我的目的和判断完全概括。在列维纳斯看来，对他人的责任比交换好处的约定更为根本。","sourceIds":["source_p66"]},{"profileId":"p67","title":"在公共生活中发言与行动","body":"阿伦特认为，政治生活还包括人们公开表达意见、一起发起行动。一个社会即使管理高效，如果人们无法参与决定共同生活的事，仍缺少重要的自由。不同的人能在公共场合互相回应，才有机会提出原先没有的想法、开始新的共同事业。","sourceIds":["source_p67"]},{"profileId":"p68","title":"复制一幅画，复制了什么","body":"原作有特定的创作时间、地点和流传经历，一张复制图片即使看起来相同，也无法重现这段经历。本雅明用“灵韵”讨论原作这种独特的在场与权威。技术复制让人在远处也能观看作品，使艺术进入报刊、电影等新的传播环境，改变了观看方式和艺术与公众的关系。","sourceIds":["source_p68"]},{"profileId":"p69","title":"我们的喜欢是怎样形成的","body":"阿多诺认为，反复接触那些套路相似的商业文化产品，会逐渐塑造观众的期待和喜好。批评文化因此需要考察作品怎样制作、宣传和传播，以及人们是否有机会接触不同的表达。他也反对用一个分类就概括对象的全部，认为这样容易忽略具体差别。","sourceIds":["source_p69"]},{"profileId":"p70","title":"感到满意，就说明生活自由吗","body":"马尔库塞认为，社会可能一面满足人的消费需要，一面限制人想象其他生活的能力。如果广告和工作安排不断告诉你应该追求什么，满足这些欲望也未必使你更能自主选择。他因此主张检查需要是怎样形成的：一个人有没有机会了解、比较并尝试另一种生活。","sourceIds":["source_p70"]},{"profileId":"p71","title":"一条规则凭什么让人接受","body":"哈贝马斯认为，一项规则应当能向受影响的人说明理由。他们需要有平等的机会发问、反对并得到回应，而不是因为害怕惩罚才表示同意。讨论也要允许原来的决定因更好的理由而改变。在他看来，这样形成的认可，比单靠权力或人数压倒反对者更有说服力。","sourceIds":["source_p71"]},{"profileId":"p72","title":"谁在规定什么算正常","body":"福柯研究学校、医院、监狱怎样观察和评价人。例如，考试、排名和日常监督，会让人学着按照某套标准检查自己、调整行为。标准不只是描述人，也在影响人成为什么样的人。他通过研究这些做法怎样形成，说明看起来天经地义的“正常”，也有具体的历史。","sourceIds":["source_p72"]},{"profileId":"p73","title":"一个概念靠什么站稳","body":"我们常把两个概念对立起来，并认为其中一个更重要。比如，说理性应当完全摆脱感性时，又需要借助“感性”才能说明理性是什么。德里达会仔细检查这种关系：被放在次要位置的一方，可能正参与了另一方的定义。这样的阅读称为“解构”，它要找出文本中那些被简单对立掩盖的联系。","sourceIds":["source_p73"]},{"profileId":"p74","title":"事物的差别怎样产生","body":"面对一种新的生活方式，只问它属于哪个已有类别，可能会错过它为什么会出现。德勒兹更关注事物怎样在相互作用中发生变化、形成新的差别。他用“生成”来讨论这种持续形成的过程，哲学也需要创造合适的概念，才能理解旧分类尚未说清的变化。","sourceIds":["source_p74"]},{"profileId":"p75","title":"不知道自己是谁，会怎样定规则","body":"罗尔斯提出“无知之幕”：假设你要制定社会规则，却不知道自己会出生在什么家庭、有什么能力、处于什么地位，你会选择怎样的制度？这样一来，就很难只为自己眼下的优势制定规则。他主张保障平等的基本自由和公平机会，并要求社会经济差距能够改善处境最不利者的生活。","sourceIds":["source_p75"]},{"profileId":"p76","title":"分配公平吗？财产从哪里来","body":"诺齐克认为，判断一个人的财产是否正当，需要考察它最初怎样取得、后来是否自愿转让，以及过去的侵害是否得到纠正。如果人们能够自由交易和赠送，原本相等的财产也会逐渐不等。为了让每个人一直保持同样多，就得不断干预这些选择。他因此重视取得和转让的过程，而非只比较最后的分配是否相等。","sourceIds":["source_p76","nozick_experience"],"topics":[{"id":"p76_property","title":"分配公平吗？财产从哪里来","body":"诺齐克认为，判断一个人的财产是否正当，需要考察它最初怎样取得、后来是否自愿转让，以及过去的侵害是否得到纠正。如果人们能够自由交易和赠送，原本相等的财产也会逐渐不等。为了让每个人一直保持同样多，就得不断干预这些选择。他因此重视取得和转让的过程，而非只比较最后的分配是否相等。","questionIds":["T97","C01","C02","FP03"]},{"id":"p76_experience","title":"幸福的感受之外","questionIds":["Q01"],"body":"体验机器能让人感到一生幸福，却让实际经历停留在虚构中。诺齐克认为，我们还在意真实地做事、成为怎样的人，以及与现实发生联系。因此，单有美好的感受还不足以概括人生中值得追求的东西。","sourceIds":["nozick_experience"]}]},{"profileId":"p77","title":"关心别人为什么也需要练习","body":"孔子把修养放在具体关系中：怎样对待父母、朋友和共同生活的人。礼为表达尊重与关怀提供可练习的形式，人也要逐渐学会其中的分寸。好的品格就在学习、反省与日常相处中形成。","sourceIds":["source_p77"]},{"profileId":"p78","title":"一瞬间的恻隐，怎样变成品格","body":"孟子用孩子快要掉进井里的例子说明，人可能来不及计算得失，就自然生出担心和不忍。他把这种同情称为“恻隐之心”，看作能够进一步培养的道德起点。一次同情还需要通过学习和实践，逐渐扩展为对更多人的关心。他也认为，生活没有保障会妨碍道德成长，因此治理者应当重视人的生计。","sourceIds":["source_p78"]},{"profileId":"p79","title":"欲望如何受到约束","body":"荀子认为，人有追求好处、满足欲望的自然倾向，若任其发展，就容易因资源有限而发生争夺。他重视先王圣人制定的礼义，让人通过学习和练习，学会怎样安排欲望、与别人相处。“性恶”强调道德需要后天的培养和人为努力；良好的秩序与品格不会自行形成。","sourceIds":["source_p79"]},{"profileId":"p80","title":"为什么不能只算自己人的利益","body":"墨子认为，只关心自己人会使各方彼此侵害。如果希望自己的家庭和国家得到善待，也要把关切扩展到别人。他批评侵攻时，尤其要求人把伤亡和损害算清楚，不能只为胜利者记上一笔好处。","sourceIds":["source_p80"]},{"profileId":"p81","title":"越用力控制，为什么有时越乱","body":"《老子》用“无为”说明一种减少强行干预的做法。例如，管理者不停增加命令，可能打乱人们原本能自行协调的生活；减少多余规定，反而能让事情运转。它也主张减少对名声、财富和过度享受的追逐，因为这些欲望容易使人不断争夺、难以安定。","sourceIds":["source_p81"]},{"profileId":"p82","title":"我们用的尺子，会不会太窄","body":"庄子常让人从别的生命和处境看问题：人觉得舒适的地方，未必适合鱼或鸟，自己习惯的标准也未必处处适用。他还用庖丁解牛说明熟练的技艺怎样形成。庖丁熟悉牛的结构，能顺着骨节间的空隙运刀，动作也从刻意控制变得从容。","sourceIds":["source_p82"]},{"profileId":"p83","title":"制度为什么要经得住换人","body":"韩非认为，管理不能只依赖个人品德。官员承担什么职责、许诺做到什么，要与实际表现核对，再据此赏罚。他还特别担心大臣掌握过多权力：一旦赏罚和任免都由下属决定，君主就可能失去控制。因此，他主张由君主牢牢掌握这些权力。这里的“法”与“术”服务于君主集权和驭臣，与现代用来约束最高权力的“法治”有根本区别。","sourceIds":["source_p83"]},{"profileId":"p84","title":"从字句读到意思","body":"王弼认为，字句和形象是帮助人领会意思的工具。他借“得鱼忘筌”的比喻说明：捕鱼的竹器叫筌，目的是得到鱼；读书也要抓住所表达的意思，而不只是停在字面。\n\n解释《老子》时，他用“无”谈万物的根本。这个根本不带某一种固定的形状，因此能够使不同形状的事物成立；如果它只是某一种具体东西，就还不能解释其他不同事物。","sourceIds":["source_p84"]},{"profileId":"p85","title":"理解道理怎样帮助人变好","body":"朱熹用“理”说明事物的道理和待人处事应遵循的准则。从具体事情入手，读书、考察并逐渐理解这些道理，是他所说的“格物致知”。他也强调“敬”：做事专注，认真约束自己。明白孝敬父母的道理之后，还要在日常相处中实践；求知与修养都需要持续用功。","sourceIds":["source_p85"]},{"profileId":"p86","title":"知道应该做，为什么还没有做","body":"王阳明把人对是非的内在觉察称为“良知”。一个人明明觉得欺骗不对，却为自己找借口，就需要认真面对这份觉察，并在眼前的行为中改正。他也主张“知行合一”：是否真的理解一个道理，行动上看得出来。如果总把行动推到以后，就应检查自己到底有没有真正理解。","sourceIds":["source_p86"]},{"profileId":"p87","title":"为什么越抓紧，越容易不安","body":"早期佛教把事物都会随条件变化称为“无常”。身体会衰老，快乐的感受也会过去；如果要求它们永远不变、完全听从自己，就容易失望和痛苦。这种一定要抓住不放的态度叫作“执取”。修行要逐渐看清变化，减少贪求和伤害，让自己不再总被得失牵着走。","sourceIds":["source_p87"]},{"profileId":"p88","title":"依赖条件，为什么叫空","body":"一株植物需要种子、土壤、水和阳光，无法脱离这些条件独自存在。龙树用这种相互依赖来解释“空”：事物没有一种不依赖任何条件、从自身就能成立的本性，这种被否定的本性叫作“自性”。说植物是空的，仍然承认它会生长、能开花；恰恰因为它依赖条件，浇水或缺水才会使它改变。","sourceIds":["source_p88"],"topics":[{"questionIds":["T111"],"title":"依赖条件，为什么叫空","body":"一株植物需要种子、土壤、水和阳光，无法脱离这些条件独自存在。龙树用这种相互依赖来解释“空”：事物没有一种不依赖任何条件、从自身就能成立的本性，这种被否定的本性叫作“自性”。说植物是空的，仍然承认它会生长、能开花；恰恰因为它依赖条件，浇水或缺水才会使它改变。"},{"questionIds":["T112"],"title":"“空”也需要条件","body":"龙树用“空”说明事物没有独立不变的自性，也把这一点用在“空”本身上。这种解释是为了纠正我们把事物看成独立存在的认识，也依赖讨论的对象、使用的概念和需要解决的问题。如果又把“空”当成一种不依赖任何条件的东西，就重新建立了它所批评的自性。因此，理解空不能停在找到一个永远不变的最终答案。"}]},{"profileId":"p89","title":"经验能直接证明外物是什么吗","body":"世亲在《唯识二十论》中讨论梦境：梦里能有鲜明、连贯的事物，但醒来后才发现，并没有相应的东西站在面前。他用这个例子质疑，从“我确实这样经历到了”，能否直接推出“认识之外一定有一个与之相同的对象”。理解经验，还需要考察记忆、习惯和认识活动怎样使它形成。","sourceIds":["source_p89"]},{"profileId":"p90","title":"领会怎样进入日常生活","body":"《坛经》认为，每个人本来都有成佛的可能，修行要认识自己本有的佛性，这叫“见性”。这种认识可能在某个契机突然发生，所以称为“顿悟”。它也重视日常中的修行：面对事情时，能否减少贪求和执着。若只是努力守住一种特殊的清净感，并把它当成可以永远占有的东西，又会陷入新的执着。","sourceIds":["source_p90"]}],"questionLessons":[{"questionId":"Q01","title":"享乐主义与体验机器","body":"如果一生都感觉幸福，这是否就是好的人生？享乐主义认为，生活过得好不好，取决于我们实际感受到了多少快乐、承受了多少痛苦。\n\n哲学家诺齐克提出了“体验机器”思想实验。你可以把它想成一台超级虚拟现实机器：它能让你体验成功、爱情和各种幸福，进入后，你会忘记这些是虚构的，感觉完全和真的一样。诺齐克认为，我们仍然有理由拒绝它，因为我们还希望真正做成一些事，与真实的人和世界发生联系。如果这些事情本身也有价值，快乐的感觉就不是评价人生的唯一标准。","responses":{"A":"幸福的感受足以使人生过得好，即使产生这些感受的经历是虚构的。享乐主义把快乐和痛苦作为评价生活的根本依据，你的回答偏向这个方向。","B":"同样感到幸福，真实经历与虚构经历对你仍有不同价值。诺齐克用体验机器追问的也是这一点：除了快乐，我们是否还想与真实的世界发生联系？这是一种非享乐主义的理由。","C":"真正帮到一个人，和只体验到帮助他的快乐，对你来说并不等价。行动实际改变了什么，也有自身的价值。这是非享乐主义的一种理由：快乐并没有概括生活中全部值得追求的东西。"},"sourceIds":["source_wellbeing"]},{"questionId":"Q02","title":"结果与做事的边界","body":"为了让朋友少受伤，可以说谎吗？后果主义根据行动带来的结果判断对错。功利主义是其中一种，它要求把所有受影响者的快乐和痛苦都算进去；如果这个谎确实减少了伤害，就有支持它的理由。\n\n康德对说谎的态度更严格。他认为，说谎会破坏他人据实判断和自主选择的机会。如果人人都把“对我有利时可以说谎”当作准则，承诺和信任也会失去基础。因此，在他的伦理学中，好结果还不足以使说谎变得正当。","responses":{"A":"为了让朋友少受伤，可以说这句谎。你的理由把行动的后果放在首位，接近后果主义的判断方式。","B":"说真话本身就是应当遵守的要求，好结果还不足以取消它。这个理由接近义务论，也与康德对诚实的重视相近。","C":"朋友应当有机会知道实情，自己作决定。替他隐瞒，也就替他决定了什么值得知道。这里对自主选择的重视，与康德伦理学尊重人的自主性有关。"},"sourceIds":["source_p45","source_p34"]},{"questionId":"Q03","title":"什么让过去的你仍然是你","body":"身体还是原来的身体，记忆和性格却全变了，我们为什么还说这是同一个人？洛克用过一个思想实验：假如王子的意识进入鞋匠的身体，并带着王子的记忆醒来，眼前这个人究竟是谁？洛克认为，就人格而言，他是王子；就身体而言，他是鞋匠。\n\n这个例子把两种判断分开了：一种依据身体和生命是否延续，另一种依据意识、记忆等心理联系是否延续。后来，心理连续性理论进一步讨论了性格、意图与记忆之间的联系。","responses":{"A":"即使记忆消失、性格改变，只要身体与生命一直延续，你仍把这个人认作原来的人。这接近身体连续性理论判断个人身份的办法。","B":"记忆与性格一旦彻底断裂，你对“还是不是原来那个人”的判断就会动摇。心理连续性理论同样重视这些联系，用它们来理解身份的延续。","C":"失去记忆，并没有抹去与亲近者共同生活的事实，彼此的责任也还在。你的回答从这些关系来理解身份，关心他仍是谁的家人、朋友。"},"sourceIds":["source_p26"]},{"questionId":"Q04","title":"有原因的选择，也能自由吗","body":"你喜欢某种音乐，可能与成长经历有关。但当你自己决定去听演唱会时，我们通常仍会说，这是你的自由选择。休谟认为，行动有原因，与行动自由可以同时成立。自由在于你能按照自己的意愿行动，而没有被关起来或受到强迫。这类主张叫作“相容论”。\n\n不相容论对自由提出了不同要求：如果过去和自然规律已经决定了你唯一可能做的事，自由意志就无法成立。在这道题里，“自己愿意”和“当时确实能选别的”，因此成了两种不同的判断依据。","responses":{"A":"选择有原因，仍可以是自愿的。相容论认为，决定论与自由能够同时成立；你用“自己愿意、没有被逼迫”来判断自由，接近其中的一种解释。","B":"要算自由，就必须真的有机会选别的。按照这个理由，如果过去和自然规律已经决定唯一结果，自由便无法成立。这接近不相容论的思路。","C":"很想发脾气时，仍能停下来想清楚，再决定怎样做。你把这种反思和控制能力看作自由的重要条件，一些相容论者也从这里解释人的自由。"},"sourceIds":["source_p29"]},{"questionId":"Q05","title":"科学理论为什么值得相信","body":"一个理论总能预测实验结果，是因为它说中了世界的真实情况吗？科学实在论者认为，如果理论与现实毫不相干，它长期成功就很难解释。因此，成功的预测能让我们有理由相信，理论至少抓住了现实中的一部分规律。\n\n工具主义更看重理论的用途：只要能可靠地计算和预测，它就有价值。另一个需要考虑的情况是，不同理论有时能解释同一批现象。这时，仅凭眼前的预测结果，还选不出哪种解释更接近真实。","responses":{"A":"理论反复预测成功，需要一个解释。相信它把握了现实中的规律，就是科学实在论常用的一种理由，你的回答接近这个方向。","B":"理论可以帮助预测和解决问题，因此值得使用。它是否如实描述世界，你暂时不作判断。这与科学工具主义看待理论的方式相近。","C":"同一批证据可能支持不止一种解释。在看到更多实验或理由之前，你还不急着选定其中一种理论。"},"sourceIds":["source_scirealism"]},{"questionId":"Q06","title":"规则和起点，哪个对公平更重要","body":"罗尔斯提出了“无知之幕”：假设你要和大家一起制定社会规则，却不知道自己会出生在富裕家庭还是贫困家庭，也不知道自己的天赋和社会地位，你会同意怎样的安排？这样设想，是为了让人无法只按自己眼下的优势制定规则。\n\n罗尔斯认为，公平需要保障基本自由和公平的机会；社会经济差距还应当有利于处境最不利的人。例如，一场考试虽然对所有人使用同一张试卷，但长期接受的教育相差很大，仍会影响人们实际拥有的机会。","responses":{"A":"规则是否一致、有没有欺骗或不当占便宜，是你判断公平的主要依据，这接近程序正义的思路。","B":"起点不同，同样的努力可能换来很不一样的机会。你希望缩小这种差距，这接近机会平等主义对公平的理解。","C":"人与人之间即使还有差距，每个人也应当过上有保障的生活。充足主义把这条基本要求放在中心，与你选的理由相近。"},"sourceIds":["source_p75"]},{"questionId":"Q07","title":"意义从哪里来","body":"萨特认为，人没有一个出生时就确定好的用途。一个人要成为什么样的人，需要通过实际的选择和行动逐渐形成。例如，你选择照顾家人、从事某种工作，这些投入会成为你生活的内容，你也要承担相应的责任。\n\n加缪关心另一种处境：人渴望知道生命最终有什么意义，世界却没有给出满意的回答。他把这种冲突称为“荒诞”。在他看来，即使得不到最终答案，人仍可以清醒地生活、行动，并反抗使人受苦的处境。","responses":{"A":"关心一个人、投入一件事，本身就能赋予生活意义。萨特的存在主义也重视人通过选择和行动形成自己的生活，这与你的想法有相近之处。","B":"即使当下不喜欢，帮助别人等事情仍可能值得做。这个理由承认事情本身的价值，人生意义因此也可以超出个人偏好。","C":"西西弗斯被罚不断把巨石推上山，石头却总会滚回山脚。加缪借这个神话讨论：当生活没有最终答案，人怎样继续活下去？你的选择与此相近——即使不知道人生最终为了什么，仍愿意认真生活。"},"sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p63"]},{"questionId":"Q08","title":"所有人同意，就一定对吗","body":"即使一个社会普遍接受奴隶制，奴隶制就正当了吗？道德实在论认为，道德判断有客观的对错，人们也可能集体犯错；批评被广泛接受的制度，可能正是在指出真实的不公。\n\n人们赞同一件事，也可能是因为不了解后果，或者根本不敢反对。这涉及共识怎样形成，和道德是否有客观对错是两种不同的问题。题中的选项分别表达了这些理由。","responses":{"A":"所有人都赞同，仍可能一起判断错了。你把道德对错与人们的实际态度区分开，这接近道德实在论的思路。","B":"同意需要建立在知情和自愿的基础上：当事人知道后果，也有拒绝的机会。满足这些条件，赞同才有道德分量，这是你重视的理由。","C":"如果有人受骗，或者不敢反对，一致赞同就无法说明事情是对的。你关心的是这种共识能否成为可信的判断依据。"},"sourceIds":["source_moralrealism"]},{"questionId":"Q09","title":"解释大脑，解释了感受吗","body":"医生可以说明受伤后神经如何传递信号、大脑哪些区域开始活动。但这些知识是否已经解释了你亲身感到的疼痛？物理主义认为，人的意识也属于物理世界，可以从大脑等物理系统的结构和活动来理解。\n\n查尔默斯把“为什么物理过程会伴随主观感受”称为意识的“难问题”。知道大脑怎样处理信息，似乎还没有直接告诉我们，为什么这个过程对当事人而言会有一种感觉。还有研究者提醒，理解疼痛也需要考虑整个身体及其所处的环境。","responses":{"A":"把大脑产生疼痛的过程讲清楚，你就认为疼痛已经得到了解释。物理主义也尝试用物理过程说明心灵，包括我们亲身感到的痛。","B":"神经信号怎样传递，可以说明；这些活动为什么伴随着痛的感觉，却仍待回答。这接近查尔默斯提出的意识“难问题”：为什么物理活动会带来主观体验？","C":"疼痛会随身体状态和周围环境改变。你希望把这些因素一并纳入解释，这与具身认知重视身体及其处境的思路相近。"},"sourceIds":["source_physicalism"]},{"questionId":"Q10","title":"有随机性，就有自由吗","body":"假如时间倒回去，连你的记忆、情绪和周围每个细节都完全一样，下一步还可能不同吗？因果决定论认为，完整的过去状态加上自然规律，已经确定了之后会发生什么。因此，只要所有条件都相同，结果也会相同。\n\n非决定论允许相同条件下出现不同结果。但“结果可能不同”还涉及两种情况：可能是你能够主动选择，也可能只是随机事件改变了结果。掷硬币决定去哪里就有这种区别：结果虽然不确定，去向却交给了硬币。","responses":{"A":"完整的过去和自然规律都相同，结果也会相同，这是因果决定论的基本看法。这样的选择是否自由，取决于你用什么标准理解自由。","B":"即使过去和规律完全相同，人仍可能主动选择另一条路。这个回答属于非决定论方向，并把另一种可能归于人的选择能力。","C":"同样的条件可以出现不同结果，符合非决定论的思路。不过，掷骰子的结果也能变化，掷骰子的人未必能控制它。你在意的正是随机变化与主动选择的区别。"},"sourceIds":["source_determinism"]},{"questionId":"Q11","title":"推理能告诉我们多少","body":"要知道窗外有没有下雨，我们通常会去看一眼；证明一道数学题，却似乎能靠推理完成。理性主义者认为，理智和推理本身就能提供一些知识。笛卡尔试图从能够确定的起点出发，建立可靠的知识。\n\n经验主义者更强调经验提供的材料。洛克认为，人的观念来自感觉，以及对自身思维活动的反省。推理固然有用，但它对现实的认识也需要说明自己的根据。","responses":{"A":"你认为有些关于现实的知识可以凭推理获得，这接近理性主义对理智能力的理解。","B":"推理得出的说法，还要经得起观察检验。把经验作为认识现实的重要根据，是经验主义的基本思路，也符合你选的理由。","C":"你没有认定所有知识都来自同一种方法，而是认为不同问题要用不同的认识方法。这道回答表达了推理与经验并用的偏好，还需要具体问题来区分你对两者各自作用的理解。"},"sourceIds":["source_epistemology"]},{"questionId":"Q12","title":"朋友为什么能得到特别照顾","body":"朋友和陌生人同样需要帮助，我们是否有理由先帮朋友？儒家伦理重视人在具体关系中的责任。一个人作为子女、父母或朋友，会承担不同的义务，亲近关系因此能成为优先照顾某个人的理由。\n\n功利主义则要求把每个受影响者的幸福都算进去，陌生人的痛苦也有同样的分量。如果帮助朋友更有效，功利主义者也可能先帮朋友，但理由在于能带来更好的结果。选择相同，背后的道德理由可以不同。","responses":{"A":"你选择帮助朋友，是因为亲近关系本身带来特别的责任。儒家伦理重视关系中的义务，与这个理由有相近之处。","B":"两个人同样需要帮助，就应得到平等的机会。你采用了不偏亲疏的标准；功利主义也要求平等考虑每个人的利益，但抽签本身并不直接决定一种伦理立场。","C":"了解朋友的处境，让你更有把握帮上忙，所以你选择帮助朋友。这个理由看重实际效果，如果帮助陌生人更有效，你的选择也可能改变。"},"sourceIds":["source_p77","source_p45"]},{"questionId":"FP01","title":"唯物、唯心与心物二元论","body":"这些立场争论的是世界最根本的构成。唯物主义认为，自然和物质并不依赖谁的思想，意识也从物质活动中产生。唯心主义则把精神或意识放在根本位置，认为物质世界最终依赖它。这里的精神并不一定是某个个人随时变化的念头。\n\n心物二元论认为，精神与物质不能完全归为同一种东西。笛卡尔就是重要代表：他把能够思考的心灵与占据空间的物体区别开来。认为意识很重要，尚不足以区分这三种看法；关键在于你认为它与物质是什么关系。","responses":{"A":"沿着星球、生命和身体的变化，一直追到思想怎样产生，这是你接受的解释方向。唯物主义同样认为，意识产生于物质活动，物质世界的存在不依赖意识。","B":"在你的解释里，意识处在更根本的位置，星球和身体也要从它来说明。这接近唯心主义：物质世界最终依赖精神或意识而存在。","C":"身体有身体的过程，心灵也有无法完全归入身体的特点。把两者都看作真实、又认为它们不能相互还原，这接近心物二元论。"},"sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_idealism","source_p23"]},{"questionId":"FP02","title":"历史唯物主义在解释什么","body":"为什么一种观念会在某个时代流行？历史唯物主义会考察人们怎样生产和维持生活，劳动分工、财产关系又怎样影响制度与思想。马克思把这些联系放在历史解释的中心。\n\n小镇转向工厂生产后，工作时间和家庭安排可能改变，人们对守时与成功的理解也随之变化。另一种解释会优先追查学校、宗教或新理想怎样推动社会改变。多因素解释则把这些原因放在一起，考察它们在具体历史中各自起了什么作用。","responses":{"B":"你认为新思想推动了生活方式与制度的改变，这接近把观念看作历史主要动力的解释。","C":"你认为几种原因会相互影响，谁起主导作用要看具体历史情况，这接近多因素历史解释。","A":"工作怎样组织、收入怎样分配，会影响小镇的人如何生活和思考。历史唯物主义从生产与社会关系来解释制度和观念，也考察观念怎样反过来影响社会生活。"},"sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p37"]},{"questionId":"FP03","title":"共同占有、福利改革与财产权","body":"社会主义关心谁拥有生产资料、谁能决定生产；社会民主主义通常保留市场与私人企业，同时通过公共服务、税收和劳动保障改善分配。两者可能赞成同一项福利措施，却对更长远的所有制安排有不同看法。\n\n自由至上主义更重视个人权利和正当取得的财产。诺齐克认为，评价一种分配，需要考察财产怎样取得与转移；结果不平均，本身还不能证明取得过程不正当。这里区分的是社会制度的基本取向。","responses":{"C":"只要取得正当、交易自愿，工厂收益就应由所有者支配。你认为缩小差距本身还不足以要求强制再分配，这与自由至上主义对财产权的重视相近。","A":"除了分到更多收入，劳动者还应当参与决定工厂怎样生产、收益怎样分配。这接近社会主义对共同掌握生产资料的主张；这里的生产资料，就是工厂和机器等用于生产的资源。","B":"保留私人经营，再通过税收和公共服务分享自动化带来的收益，是你支持的安排。这接近社会民主主义：保留市场，同时用公共制度改善分配和劳动保障。"},"sourceIds":["source_socialism","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"questionId":"FP04","title":"后果主义、义务论与德性伦理学","body":"志愿者的两难，在于帮助更多人、履行承诺和体谅具体的人，都有道理，却无法同时做到。\n\n后果主义比较不同做法最终带来的帮助和伤害，以整体结果来判断。义务论认为，承诺等责任能够约束行动，即使违约会带来更多好处，也不能只算收益。德性伦理学则从人的品格和实际判断出发：一个可靠、体恤他人的人，应当如何看待眼前这两种请求？这种判断需要经验，也要能说明为什么这样取舍。","responses":{"A":"两边都需要帮助，应该比较各自会得到多少帮助、受到多少伤害。后果主义以行动的整体结果来判断该怎样做，与你选的理由相近。","B":"对老人作出的承诺，已经带来一份责任。另一边能得到更多帮助，并不足以直接取消这份责任。义务论重视这种约束：判断行动时，要考虑自己应当履行的义务。","C":"可靠和体恤他人，都要在具体两难中落实。德性伦理学关心一个人怎样养成这样的品格，以及怎样作出恰当判断。你更看重的也是这两点。"},"sourceIds":["source_p45","source_p34","source_p07"]},{"questionId":"FP05","title":"有神论、无神论与不可知论","body":"有神论肯定神的存在；这道题中的无神论选项明确否定神的存在。不可知论则对自己是否有足够根据判断神的存在保持保留。\n\n一个人相信自然规律，并不能直接推出他是否信神；相信神的人，也可能认为自然现象遵循规律。这些观点对世界如何存在和运行，有各自不同的解释。","responses":{"B":"世界和它的规律本身就能成为解释的起点，你认为没有创造者。对神的存在作出这种否定，属于无神论的判断。","C":"世界怎样运行得到了解释，创造者是否存在却仍未确定。你对“存在”和“不存在”都暂缓判断，这接近不可知论。","A":"自然规律可以说明世界怎样运行，你仍相信有一位创造者作为世界存在的根源。这个回答属于有神论方向。"},"sourceIds":["source_atheism"]},{"questionId":"W01","title":"实在论：世界是否依赖被认识","body":"外部世界实在论认为，山与岩石等事物的存在独立于是否有意识认识它们。但一座山从哪里算起、哪些东西归为同一类，又会涉及人的分类。\n\n事物可以独立存在，人对它的分类也可以带着自身视角。还有人对“完全脱离一切经验的存在”保留判断，因为这个说法的含义或判断依据尚不清楚。","responses":{"C":"石头和土不靠人来维持存在，但把哪些部分算作“一座山”，涉及人的划分。这个回答承认外部事物独立存在，也注意到我们会用自己的概念来整理它们。","A":"即使从未有谁看见，山也照样存在。外部世界实在论强调的正是这种独立性：被认识不是事物存在的条件。","B":"如果“存在”完全超出任何可能的经验，我们究竟在断言什么？你对外部世界保留判断，原因在于这个说法的含义尚不清楚。"},"sourceIds":["source_p51","source_p28"]},{"questionId":"V03","title":"从过去推到未来，凭什么","body":"每天都看见太阳升起，会使我们相信明天也会如此。休谟追问：过去反复发生，就能在逻辑上保证未来一定相同吗？如果用“过去一直可以这样预测”来证明，又已经使用了同一种从过去推向未来的办法。\n\n这就是归纳问题：我们在生活和科学中离不开经验预测，却仍需解释它为什么可靠。承认这里缺少逻辑必然的保证，可以与继续依据经验行动并存。","responses":{"A":"过去的记录给了预测的依据，却无法在逻辑上保证明天一定相同。休谟的归纳问题就出在这里：过去反复发生的事，为什么能支持对未来的判断？","B":"自然规律是你相信预测的根据。接下来仍有一个问题：我们怎样知道掌握的规律会在未来继续成立？这个追问也是归纳问题的一部分。","C":"出门、种地或安排明天的事，都很难等到有了绝对证明才开始。这个回答重视经验预测在生活中的必要性；预测为什么可靠，则还需要另外说明。"},"sourceIds":["source_p29"]},{"questionId":"H01","title":"观念与它所处的时代","body":"判断一个观念有没有道理，与解释它为什么在某个时代流行，是相关但不同的问题。前者检查证据和论证；后者还会考察生活条件、制度和传播权力。\n\n马克思重视观念与社会生活的联系，福柯则研究知识、制度与权力怎样共同塑造人们习以为常的判断。追查来源之后，我们仍可以继续讨论这个观念本身是否成立。","responses":{"A":"在你看来，观念曾经流行，并不能代替支持它的理由。判断对错更重要的依据，是双方的论证和证据。","B":"生活条件改变，人们习以为常的想法也会改变。你重视这种联系，这与历史唯物主义关注社会生活如何塑造思想的方向相近。","C":"你关心哪些机构能传播一种说法、哪些人的意见难以被听见。福柯也研究知识与权力的联系，以及这种联系如何塑造人们认可的观念。"},"sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p72"]},{"questionId":"C01","title":"平等与财产权的分歧","body":"继承财产并非受益者本人努力的结果，却能显著改变他拥有的机会。平等主义者会追问，制度应当怎样减弱出身的影响；充足主义更重视每个人是否拥有足够的生活条件。\n\n诺齐克一类财产权理论关注财产取得和转移的过程：如果过程正当，单凭财富差距很大，还不足以要求重新分配。这里的争论涉及机会、基本需要与个人权利。","responses":{"B":"家产会影响一个人能接受怎样的教育、拥有多少选择。你希望制度减弱出身带来的差距，让人有更公平的机会，这接近机会平等主义。","C":"你最重视每个人的基本生活是否有保障，这接近充足主义。它用“足够”来判断分配，关注生活条件是否达到应有的水平。","A":"你重视财产取得和转移的正当性。诺齐克一类财产权理论认为，若这些过程正当，差距大本身还不足以要求重新分配。"},"sourceIds":["source_p75","source_p76"]},{"questionId":"T34","title":"心灵与身体，是两种东西吗？","body":"心灵是另一种存在，还是身体的活动？笛卡尔认为，身体占据空间，心灵能够思考，两者可以分开存在，因此是两类不同的东西。想抬手的念头怎样使手动起来，也就成了二元论必须解释的问题。\n\n物理主义把心灵放在物理世界中，用大脑等身体系统的活动来理解思想和感受。梅洛-庞蒂则从身体怎样感知和行动来理解经验，把心灵与身体的关系放回亲身生活中讨论。","responses":{"A":"你把能够思考的心灵与身体看成两类不同的存在，这接近笛卡尔的心物二元论。","B":"你认为思想就是身体或大脑的活动。这是物理主义的一种回答：用物理过程解释心灵。","C":"你对预先把心灵和身体分开的问法有疑问。梅洛-庞蒂也从身体的感知与行动出发，重新理解我们怎样认识和经历世界。"},"sourceIds":["source_p23","source_physicalism","source_p64"]},{"questionId":"A01","title":"艺术价值来自哪里","body":"审美主观主义重视欣赏者的感受与偏好；审美客观主义认为，作品的某些特点能够提供评价的理由，价值并不完全由个人喜好决定。\n\n强调历史背景的观点则认为，同一种艺术形式在不同时代可能表达不同的东西。评价作品时，这些理由可以同时起作用，题目问的是哪种理由对你更重要。","responses":{"C":"同一首歌放在不同年代，可能表达不同的东西。艺术语境主义重视这种背景：作品在当时完成了什么表达，带来了怎样的创新？你的回答也从这里判断。","A":"听众实际感受到的快乐和满足，是你评价歌曲的主要理由，这接近重视欣赏者偏好的审美主观主义。","B":"即使喜好不同，作品的结构和表达仍有值得讨论的优劣。相信艺术评价能超出个人偏好，这接近审美客观主义的方向。"},"sourceIds":["source_beauty","source_p68"]},{"questionId":"R03","title":"苦难为什么会成为信仰的问题","body":"如果一位创造者既能阻止苦难，又完全善良，为什么仍会有无辜者受苦？这就是宗教哲学中的“恶的问题”。有人据此反对这种信念，也有人认为人的知识有限，或自由、成长等价值可能解释一部分苦难。争论的关键是：这些解释能否充分说明实际发生的苦难。","sourceIds":["evil_sep"],"responses":{"A":"你把无辜苦难看作需要信仰认真回应的反对理由。","B":"你认为人的理解有限，仅凭苦难还不足以否定这种信念。","C":"你更关注信仰怎样回应受苦的人，例如给予安慰和实际帮助。"}}],"positionLessons":[{"positionTitle":"历史唯物主义","title":"从生活条件理解历史","body":"同样一句“靠努力就能成功”，在土地、工厂和教育机会掌握在不同人手里的社会中，含义会很不同。历史唯物主义把生产和生活条件作为理解社会的基础：人们怎样劳动、怎样占有资源，会影响制度，也会影响流行的观念。马克思因此主张，讨论社会问题还要考察现实中的阶级关系和利益。","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p37","source_p72"]},{"positionTitle":"相容论","title":"有原因的选择，也能出于自愿","body":"你因为喜欢音乐而学琴，这个愿望有成长经历和性格上的原因；它仍可能是你愿意作出的选择。相容论关注选择是否出于自己的愿望和判断，是否受到强迫。决定论即使成立，也未必抹去这种自愿行动与被迫行动的区别。","sourceIds":["source_p29","philpapers2020","source_p35"]},{"positionTitle":"自由意志论","title":"未来是否真的有别的可能","body":"自由意志论认为，至少有些决定没有被此前的条件和自然规律完全预定。人在选择时，确实能够走向不止一种未来。它还需要说明：这种开放的选择怎样由行动者作出，而不只是偶然发生的一次随机事件。","sourceIds":["source_p29","source_determinism","source_p25"]},{"positionTitle":"自由意志怀疑论","title":"奖惩需要怎样的自由","body":"一个人的性格、欲望和处境有许多并非自己选择的来源。自由意志怀疑论因此追问：人是否拥有足够的控制，理应仅仅因为做了某件事就受到痛苦的惩罚？这种怀疑仍允许讨论如何保护他人、预防伤害和帮助人改变行为。","sourceIds":["source_p29","source_determinism","source_p25"]},{"positionTitle":"后果主义","title":"把受到影响的人都算进去","body":"后果主义根据行动带来的影响判断对错：谁会受益、谁会受损，影响有多大、会持续多久。功利主义是其中一种重要理论，以总体福祉评价后果，也把远处和陌生人的利益算在内。它面临的难题是：多数人的获益，是否足以证明牺牲少数人是正当的？","sourceIds":["source_p44","source_p45","source_p34"]},{"positionTitle":"义务论","title":"有些手段需要独立的理由","body":"如果一项行为能带来好结果，它就一定正当吗？义务论认为，承诺、权利和对人的尊重也能直接构成行动的理由。康德尤其要求我们检查自己的原则能否让人人采用，并尊重每个人自己的目的。一个人不应只是达成他人目标的工具。","sourceIds":["source_p34","source_p45","source_p07"]},{"positionTitle":"道德实在论","title":"大家赞同，也可能都错了","body":"假如一个社会普遍认可奴隶制，道德实在论仍允许说：这个社会在道德上判断错了。它认为，有些道德事实并不由赞成的人数或个人喜好决定。接下来的争论是，我们通过怎样的理由认识这些事实，又怎样解释长期存在的道德分歧。","sourceIds":["source_moralrealism","source_p71"]},{"positionTitle":"享乐主义","title":"幸福是否最终在于感受","body":"这里的享乐主义讨论什么使人生本身变好。它把快乐看作本身有价值的东西，把痛苦看作本身不好的东西。诺齐克的体验机器提出一个检验：若虚拟人生能带来完全真实的幸福感，我们还要不要现实中的经历？答案会影响我们是否把感受视为人生价值的最终标准。","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","source_p06","source_p09"]},{"positionTitle":"非享乐主义","title":"快乐之外，生活还需要什么","body":"有时我们宁愿经历一件困难却真实的事，也不愿只拥有一场逼真的美梦。这为非享乐主义提供了理由：知识、友谊、亲自完成的行动等，可能具有超出快乐感受的价值。不同理论对这份清单意见不一，但都认为，单凭一个人有多快乐，还不足以评价整个人生。","sourceIds":["source_wellbeing","source_p43"]},{"positionTitle":"科学工具主义","title":"好用的理论，意味着什么","body":"一张地图能带你到达目的地，却没有必要把地面上的一切都画出来。科学工具主义也重视理论的这种用途：它是否帮助我们预测现象、组织经验和解决问题？采用一个成功的理论，并不一定要相信它提到的每一种不可观察对象都真实存在。","sourceIds":["source_p12","philpapers2020","source_scirealism"]},{"positionTitle":"科学实在论","title":"从看得见的现象认识看不见的东西","body":"我们看不到电子，却能通过许多相互配合的实验研究它。科学实在论认为，成熟科学理论的成功可以成为相信其所描述对象和结构的理由。科学仍可能修正错误；相信它能认识真实世界，与把今天的理论当作最终答案，是两回事。","sourceIds":["source_scirealism","source_p12"]},{"positionTitle":"机会平等主义","title":"出身不该决定能走多远","body":"同样有能力和意愿的两个人，可能因为家庭财富不同而得到完全不同的教育和工作机会。机会平等主义认为，这种差异需要制度回应。它关心人能否公平地发展和竞争；仅仅宣布所有人遵守相同规则，还未必消除了起点上的障碍。","sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"positionTitle":"充足主义","title":"每个人怎样才算拥有足够的生活条件","body":"假如一项分配能让最困难的人获得医疗和住所，另一项只能让原本富裕的人之间更接近，充足主义会优先关注前者。它把每个人是否达到足够的生活水平放在中心。争论随后落在“足够”的标准，以及达到标准后如何看待剩余差距。","sourceIds":["source_p32","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"positionTitle":"身体连续性理论","title":"变化中的身体，还是同一个人吗","body":"照片中的你与今天的你，外貌和身体成分都变了，但生命过程一直延续。身体连续性理论从这条持续的身体或生命历史理解个人身份。失忆、身体移植等设想则会考验它：身体延续与记忆、意识分离时，哪一种联系更能说明你是谁？","sourceIds":["philpapers2020","source_p26"]},{"positionTitle":"意识的解释鸿沟","title":"大脑活动为什么会伴随感受","body":"研究者可以记录神经活动，说明你如何辨认颜色、报告疼痛。但这些说明是否已经回答了“为什么会亲身感到疼”？意识的解释鸿沟指向的就是这个距离。它提出了解释上的困难，至于困难意味着心物二元论，还是需要更好的物理理论，还要进一步讨论。","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_p59","source_p64"]},{"positionTitle":"实在论","title":"世界会独立于我们的判断存在吗","body":"就算所有人都认定地球是平的，地球本身也依然是圆的。实在论认为，事物的存在和性质并不由我们的认识或信念决定。哲学中的实在论有不同对象：对山川、科学对象、数学或道德采取实在论，所需的论证也不完全相同。","sourceIds":["source_p51","source_p28","source_p50"]},{"positionTitle":"语言语境主义","title":"同一句话，在不同场合说什么","body":"朋友指着满桌菜说“已经够了”，与救援人员指着救生衣说这句话，表达的标准并不相同。语言语境主义强调，理解一句话要知道谁在说、对谁说、当时在做什么。词句提供线索，具体使用的情境也参与决定它表达的意思。","sourceIds":["source_p52","source_p65"]},{"positionTitle":"艺术语境主义","title":"作品为什么需要放回它的时代","body":"今天看起来普通的一种画法，在它出现时可能改变了人们表现世界的方式。艺术语境主义因此把创作背景、艺术传统和当时的问题纳入评价。作品的价值既涉及眼前看见的形式，也涉及它在那段历史中做出了什么。","sourceIds":["source_beauty","source_p68"]},{"positionTitle":"德性伦理学","title":"好的人怎样作出判断","body":"一位诚实的人也需要判断，什么时候该直说，什么时候该体谅别人的处境。德性伦理学关注这种逐渐养成的品格与判断能力。亚里士多德认为，反复的行动形成习惯，实践中的智慧又帮助我们在具体场合找到恰当的做法。","sourceIds":["source_p07","source_p44","source_p05"]},{"positionTitle":"证据主义","title":"相信得越坚定，需要怎样的根据","body":"传言恰好符合自己的愿望，并不会使它更可靠。证据主义要求信念得到相称的证据支持：理由薄弱时，应当降低确信程度。它关心的是相信一件事有没有充分根据，也会讨论情感、信任和生活实践能否提供这样的根据。","sourceIds":["source_p42","source_p47"]},{"positionTitle":"历史主义","title":"思想也有自己的来路","body":"“正常的家庭”“合理的工作”并非在所有时代都意味着同一件事。历史主义强调，理解一个观念或制度，要考察它形成、变化的历史。找到历史来源之后，仍然需要讨论它今天是否有道理；解释来路与评价对错各自需要理由。","sourceIds":["source_p30","source_p40","source_p41"]},{"positionTitle":"唯物主义","title":"意识怎样从自然中出现","body":"身体会疲劳，药物会改变感受，脑部损伤也会影响记忆。这些现象使人有理由从生命和身体的活动理解意识。唯物主义把物质看作世界的基础，并把精神生活放在自然和社会的发展中解释。不同唯物主义理论对意识如何产生，仍有不同回答。","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_idealism","source_p23"]},{"positionTitle":"唯心主义","title":"为什么把精神放在根本位置","body":"我们接触世界时，总已在感知、思考和理解之中。唯心主义从不同路径进一步主张，精神或意识对世界具有根本地位。贝克莱着重讨论感知与存在，黑格尔则讨论思想、现实和历史的联系。这些理论中的“精神”，不都等于某个人眼前的念头。","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_idealism","source_p23"]},{"positionTitle":"心物二元论","title":"心灵与身体，是两种东西吗","body":"笛卡尔把身体的根本特征理解为占据空间，把心灵的根本特征理解为思考，并试图论证它们可以分别存在。这形成了他的心物二元论。随后出现了一个难题：想抬手的念头，究竟怎样让身体动起来？二元论需要进一步解释两者如何相互影响。","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_idealism","source_p23"]},{"positionTitle":"观念主导的历史观","title":"思想怎样成为历史的力量","body":"宗教改革、政治理想和对尊严的新理解，都可能促使人重新组织生活。这种历史解释把思想与观念的变化放在主要位置。它要说明观念如何影响行动、组织和制度，也会遇到另一类追问：为什么某种思想偏偏在那个时代得到接受？","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p37"]},{"positionTitle":"多因素历史解释","title":"为什么一件事常有多种原因","body":"一项制度的变化可能同时受到技术、经济利益、政治组织和思想运动影响。多因素历史解释主张，把这些力量及其相互作用一起考察。它的任务是说明具体事件中哪些原因更关键，而不是把所有因素都当作同样重要。","sourceIds":["source_p40","source_p37"]},{"positionTitle":"社会主义取向","title":"谁能决定怎样生产和分配","body":"一家企业的决策会影响劳动者、社区和资源使用。社会主义取向认为，生产资源和相关决定应当具有更强的社会共同掌握与参与。不同社会主义理论对市场、国家、合作社和劳动者自治的安排各有主张；共同的问题是，谁掌握生产条件，谁能参与决定。","sourceIds":["source_socialism","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"positionTitle":"社会民主主义取向","title":"市场之外，需要怎样的公共保障","body":"一个人可能因为失业、生病或家庭出身而失去发展机会。社会民主主义取向保留市场经济，同时通过公共医疗、教育、劳动保障和再分配缓和这种风险。它希望让经济活力与较平等的社会条件并存，具体制度则需要持续比较效果与代价。","sourceIds":["source_socialism","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"positionTitle":"自由至上主义取向","title":"个人权利给公共目标划下什么边界","body":"即使一项政策能让总体处境改善，个人仍可能追问：谁有权强制我为它付出？自由至上主义取向把个人自由与正当财产权放在核心位置。诺齐克尤其强调取得、转移和纠正不义的过程；国家的强制行动需要受到权利的限制。","sourceIds":["source_socialism","source_p75","source_p76"]},{"positionTitle":"有神论","title":"世界为何存在，需要怎样的解释","body":"有神论认为神存在。不同传统把神理解为创造者、世界存在的根源或道德与宗教生活的中心。自然为何存在、秩序从何而来、宗教经验是否可信，都是人们为信仰寻找理由时会讨论的问题。","sourceIds":["source_atheism"]},{"positionTitle":"无神论","title":"从自然本身理解世界","body":"无神论否认神的存在。有人认为自然解释已经足够，有人认为支持神存在的论证不成立，也有人从世界中的苦难提出疑问。这些理由并不完全相同；一个人接受怎样的无神论，取决于他否认的是哪一种神观，以及依据是什么。","sourceIds":["source_atheism"]},{"positionTitle":"不可知论","title":"承认一个问题暂时没有定论","body":"关于神是否存在，不可知论认为我们缺少足够的认识，因而暂缓肯定或否定。有人把这看作目前证据不足，也有人认为这个问题超出了人的知识能力。前一种人可能继续寻找证据，后一种人则怀疑我们能否找到决定性的答案。","sourceIds":["source_atheism"]},{"positionTitle":"外部世界实在论","title":"无人看见的山，仍然在那里","body":"一座山在有人到来之前已经形成，人离开后也继续存在。外部世界实在论把这种独立于感知者的存在看作真实。我们可能误认山的高度或颜色，但认识可能出错，并不直接意味着被认识的世界由认识本身创造。","sourceIds":["source_p51","source_p28"]},{"positionTitle":"悬置对外部世界的判断","title":"“经验之外的存在”指什么","body":"我们通过观察、测量和推理认识世界，却很难站到所有经验之外，检查经验与世界是否一致。如果说一个东西“完全独立于任何可能的经验而存在”，这个说法究竟指什么，又凭什么判断？选择这一方向的人，对外界的判断有所保留，原因在于问题的含义或证据尚不清楚。","sourceIds":["source_p51","source_p28"]},{"positionTitle":"实在论与概念建构","title":"世界独立，分类却可以不同","body":"同一片土地可以按河流、行政边界或植被划分，土地本身并不会随地图消失。这个思路同时承认世界的独立存在，以及概念和分类中的人为选择。接下来要讨论的是，哪些划分有客观根据，哪些主要服务于我们的目的。","sourceIds":["source_p51","source_p28"]},{"positionTitle":"经验与理性相结合","title":"材料与理解怎样配合","body":"观察给我们材料，但仅有许多印象，还不足以形成判断。推理帮助我们发现关系，也需要经验检验它对现实的运用。把两者结合，可以有不同理论：康德尤其追问，人的认识能力提供了哪些组织经验的条件。","sourceIds":["source_epistemology","source_p17","source_p22"]},{"positionTitle":"人生意义的主体论","title":"你投入的事情，为什么值得做","body":"同一种活动，可能让一个人深感值得，却让另一个人觉得空虚。人生意义的主体论从人的关心、选择和投入理解这种差异。它把“这件事对我有什么意义”放在中心，也需要面对一个问题：任何真心投入的目标，是否都同样能使人生有意义？","sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p63","source_p06"]},{"positionTitle":"人生意义的客观论","title":"有些事情为何值得人追求","body":"照顾他人、认识真相或创造优秀作品，可能在一个人尚未喜欢它们时就具有价值。人生意义的客观论认为，意义不完全取决于个人态度。不同理论会提出不同的价值，也会讨论一个人怎样真正参与其中，让这些价值成为自己生活的一部分。","sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p63","source_p06"]},{"positionTitle":"荒诞主义","title":"西西弗斯为什么还要推石头","body":"加缪把人的意义渴望与世界的沉默之间的冲突称为荒诞。西西弗斯不断把石头推上山，石头又滚落下来，正是他用来思考这种处境的形象。加缪重视清醒地承认处境，继续生活和反抗；这种反抗也要顾及同样身处其中的他人。","sourceIds":["source_p61","source_p63","source_p06"]},{"positionTitle":"审美主观主义","title":"美与欣赏者的感受有关吗","body":"同一首歌会使一个人感动，另一个人却毫无感觉。审美主观主义把欣赏者的感受、偏好或评价放在理解美的中心。人们仍然可以交流作品和训练欣赏能力，但美的根据怎样离开具体欣赏者而成立，会成为它追问的问题。","sourceIds":["source_beauty","source_p68"]},{"positionTitle":"审美客观主义取向","title":"喜好不同，仍能讨论作品的优劣","body":"一部电影的叙事、表演和形式可以提供具体的评价理由。审美客观主义取向认为，这些理由不完全由个人喜欢与否决定。它需要进一步说明什么构成好的作品，以及欣赏经验、文化差异与这些标准怎样相互关联。","sourceIds":["source_beauty","source_p68"]},{"positionTitle":"反思自主性","title":"愿望也能接受自己的检验","body":"你可能很想做一件事，反省之后却认为这个愿望不值得照办。反思自主性重视这种审视理由、调整欲望并据此行动的能力。它让自由超出一时冲动，也提出进一步的问题：反省所依据的价值，怎样才算真正得到自己的认可？","sourceIds":["source_p29"]},{"positionTitle":"不相容论","title":"自由与预先决定能同时成立吗","body":"如果过去的状态和自然规律早已固定了每一个选择，我们是否还拥有自由意志？不相容论认为，两者不能同时成立。其中有人保留自由而否定决定论，也有人接受决定论而怀疑自由；还需要追问，才能知道你更接近哪一条路。","sourceIds":["source_p29"]},{"positionTitle":"物理主义","title":"从身体活动理解思想与感受","body":"麻醉、药物和脑部损伤会改变意识，使人有理由把心灵与物理过程联系起来。物理主义进一步认为，一切存在最终都是物理的，意识也属于这个世界。它内部仍有不同解释：心理活动是否就是大脑活动，还是需要从更复杂的物理组织中理解？","sourceIds":["source_physicalism","source_p23","source_p64"]},{"positionTitle":"具身认知","title":"身体怎样参与思考","body":"熟练骑车时，身体会随着道路的起伏和车辆的变化作出调整，这些动作往往发生在刻意计算之前。具身认知重视这种联系：感知和思考受到身体、动作和环境共同塑造。梅洛-庞蒂也从亲身的身体经验出发，研究人怎样经历世界。","sourceIds":["source_p59","source_p64","philpapers2020"]},{"positionTitle":"理性主义","title":"有些道理，能否通过推理认识","body":"一项论证的每一步如果都成立，我们可以通过理解它的理由获得知识。理性主义尤其强调，有些知识不以感官经验为最终根据。笛卡尔和莱布尼茨分别探索了这样的可能；争论还包括，纯粹推理能认识哪些关于现实的事实。","sourceIds":["source_epistemology","source_p17","source_p22"]},{"positionTitle":"经验主义","title":"知识为什么要回到观察","body":"一种说法听起来很有道理，实际观察却可能使我们改口。经验主义因此把感官经验看作认识世界的重要根据或来源。洛克研究观念怎样来自经验，休谟进一步检视我们从经验走向因果判断时，究竟依靠了什么。","sourceIds":["source_epistemology","source_p17","source_p22"]},{"positionTitle":"程序正义","title":"过程公正，为什么本身也重要","body":"即使一次分配恰好让所有人满意，暗箱决定或偏袒亲友仍会使人怀疑它是否公平。程序正义重视决定事情的方式：规则是否公开，参与者是否获得平等对待，能否提出异议。公平的程序与公平的结果怎样配合，是接下来的问题。","sourceIds":["source_p75"]},{"positionTitle":"心理连续性理论","title":"记忆与性格怎样连接过去的你","body":"你之所以把童年的经历当作自己的过去，可能因为记忆、性格、意图和能力之间存在延续。心理连续性理论从这些联系理解个人身份。洛克特别讨论意识与记忆；失忆、复制等设想则会考验，怎样的心理联系才足以构成同一个人。","sourceIds":["source_p26"]},{"positionTitle":"因果决定论","title":"相同的过去，会不会只有一个未来","body":"因果决定论认为，给定过去的完整状态和自然规律，未来就只有一种可能。这比“事情都有原因”更强：有原因的过程也可能允许不同结果。决定论是否成立，与人是否自由还需要分别论证；相容论和不相容论正是在后一个问题上分开。","sourceIds":["source_determinism","source_p25"]},{"positionTitle":"非决定论","title":"未来为什么可能不止一种","body":"非决定论认为，同样的过去和自然规律可以容许不止一种未来。它为某些开放的过程留下空间，却还没有说明人如何控制选择。一次随机结果与一个出于自己理由的决定有什么关系，需要关于自由意志的进一步理论。","sourceIds":["source_determinism","source_p25"]},{"positionTitle":"怀疑主义","title":"理由到哪里，判断就到哪里","body":"看起来可信的印象可能出错，不同论证也可能彼此冲突。怀疑主义据此检视我们凭什么声称自己知道。有些怀疑针对特定领域，有些则尝试暂缓广泛的判断；古代怀疑主义者还讨论了怎样在保持判断开放时继续日常生活。","sourceIds":["source_p12"]},{"positionTitle":"中观学派","title":"一张桌子怎样依靠条件存在","body":"桌子依靠木材、加工、支撑结构和使用方式，不能脱离这些条件而独立成立。龙树用“空”说明事物没有独立不变的本性，并将它与缘起联系起来：事物依条件而存在。日常世界仍能运作，正因为它们处在关系和变化之中。","sourceIds":["source_p88"]}]}}